Software
Houzz Logo Print
spincrazy25_gw

Flooring in Open Concept/ Pics Please

17 years ago

When you have an open concept kitchen that is basically one big room shared with living space, I know it would be best to use all the same flooring material. DH has a problem with that because of course I want wood, and since we tend to be messy, he is concerned with maintenance/durability.

Would it look like crap to have part tile, part wood? If you have any pictures of this, I'd really like to see.

Thanks!

Comments (14)

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks to whoever is giving me a bump...

    No ideas out there?

  • PRO
    17 years ago

    Can you give us a floor plan?
    It might help us to make some suggestions...

  • 17 years ago

    What flooring does he want to use in the living space?

    We have hardwood in our house and are renovating. I decided to put hardwood in the kitchen as well b/c I have heard that there isn't a problem with upkeep.

  • PRO
    17 years ago

    I agree all wood would be my choice too.
    However, if you need to do a mix, how about doing a border of tile (18" - 24") around the living room with the wood just in the center?

    That ties it all together, and puts tile in the high traffic area next to the slider, etc.

  • 17 years ago

    I did *exactly* what your DH suggested. Now, I do have a bar that also divides the areas a bit, but by and large it is one big open space.

    How deep is that header? It may be enough to separate the spaces anyway.

    Another thing I did was use similar finishes (paint, trim, bar panelling) to unify the spaces.

    Here is a link that might be useful: picture from living room to kitchen

  • 17 years ago

    We just redid our main floor, taking out walls, and ended up with a similiar open floor plan to what you are doing. I put the same oak hardwood everywhere, and absolutely love it. There are no transitions to break up the space, and it is so easy to clean.

    I'll attach a link to a slide show of pics, since I don't have a pic that shows the whole space.

    Here is a link that might be useful: slideshow of flooring pictures

  • 17 years ago

    I kept my wood throughout because it is a small space and I really wanted one surface from the view from the front door to the kitchen. But, it is getting pretty dinged up. My stepmohter did a little tile kitchen (nice grey slate) and it looks beautiful with the wood - not too choppy at all.

  • 17 years ago

    Looking at models homes has become a hobby for me. One thing I noticed is that many of the homes often had more than two types of flooring. The overall feel of each type of flooring was always the same, e.g., all rustic, all contemporary. I think one flooring looks nice, but I also love the combinations. Our new kitchen will be very open and we'll be doing separate flooring.

    What I am trying to say is don't feel like you must have all the same flooring.

  • 17 years ago

    I think this kitchen is so pretty, and it has 2 different floors.... however, the designer writing the article about this thought it would have been better with one type of flooring.....

    Here is a link that might be useful: kitchen design link

  • 17 years ago

    I had two kinds of flooring in an open floor plan for 15 years, and I HATED it. My kitchen and breakfast nook are open to the family room. The developer/prior owners had sheet vinyl in the kitchen and BR but berber carpet in the FR.

    First, both flooring choices were just plain hideous, which I assume won't be an issue for you :)

    Second, the transition from vinyl to carpet was a major league PITA to clean. The carpet was raised about 1/2" above the vinyl. Dirt collected there. Mere mopping one side and vacuuming the other didn't work -- I had to get down on my hands and knees and scrub to keep the transition clean-ish. Dirt also tended to collect in the inch or so of vinyl bordering the transition. I'm sure you'll design it better than the developer, with both floors the same height and a T-molding strip, but dirt can collect against a T-molding with even a tiny height differential.

    Third, the choppy look, which needs no further explanation. Since the idea of an open floor plan is to have one room flow into the other, I have always felt that using two floor coverings to clearly differentiate the two rooms is at cross purposes.

    Blue

  • 17 years ago

    I forgot to post pix.

    This isn't the greatest pic of the floor, but you can see the floor on the side of the island and the FR (fireplace, sofa) in the background.

    This pic is taken from more-or-less the doorway to the kitchen/BR/FR, where there is a large open space with FR to left, kitchen to right.

    The transition used to run smack dab down the middle of the open space -- yecch!!! It also affected furniture placement, because it looked strange to have the edge of the sofa hanging off the carpet and onto the sheet vinyl; now, with one expanse of floor, I can move it as I please or even get a bigger sofa (which I will do with all the heaps of money I have lying around after finishing a kitchen remodel -- NOT!).

    Blue

  • 17 years ago

    we recently redid our kitchen/living room/ eating area and installed new flooring. I went with wood throughout. Hardwood floors are very durable and you shouldn't worry about it. Look at the Janka scale and choose one that is on the higher end. I went with quartersawn white oak. I have two little kids and they are rough on the house and the hardwood flooring doesn't show a thing. we do lots of arts and crafts and cooking, etc. and I clean it up and you can't see a thing. I went with tung oil for the finish vs. polyurethane. There is lots of discussion on this on the flooring forum.

    I agree with others that one flooring material will be less choppy and a better way to go.

    It sort of gets to your philosophy. When I was growing up I remember people in my neighborhood with thick clear plastic runners over their wall to wall carpet meant to preserve it... and plastic over the lamp shades for the same reason. Then there are those who don't want to live that way and just expect a certain amount of wear and tear that will result from living one's life and a "I'll cross that bridge when I get there" attitude.

    Here's a pic of our hardwood flooring in the kitchen. I don't have scatter rugs or anything because I feel like they trap crumbs, etc.... would rather be able to easily sweep up the dirt. It has been about one year since the floors have been in.

    ps: don't go for fir or cherry... too soft.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the pics everyone. Sounds like I could do a split if I chose some great stuff.....but one is the best. I thought I'd show what I have now just for fun- since I detest this split and the kitchen is mostly closed off. Off course, as bluekit mentioned, I hope to have something better than white vinyl and parquet! Blech!