Wow! You have a great location. Is that part with the deck around it part of the main house?

I would put the kind without windows, and since you have the nice curved edging on the corners, maybe even the rustic looking ones.

Our doors are solid and DH built transoms to go over the doors to let in light.

{{!gwi}}

Some of my neighbors picked windowless because of a potential security issue (small burglar?) with the windowed ones; I picked windowed ones because I hated coming into the garage when there was absolutely, positively no light at all. I know these aren't decorating opinions, just practical ones.

I think the windows add the extra pop that your home needs. However, if you go with a windowless front I would pick a decorative one like the barn door style. Our old garage doors had the windows on the top section and they looked like they arched, which was pretty. To add more wow to your home, I would repaint to another color other than white. Let your trim remain white and add shutters to the top windows....I think that will give you more interest. The dark trim looks too heavy.