Software
Houzz Logo Print
palimpsest

less discernment = blanket 'dislike'?

15 years ago

One of the things I don't understand is blanket statements such as "I hate____because it's____". First, it's such a sweeping generalization. Second, because it excludes so much. If you love granite and think it's the best countertop material going, great. But to the exclusion of everything else? Let's substitute something else...That's like deciding that since you love peach Dannon yogurt, that's all you're going to eat, and you are going to get annoyed at people who don't want to eat it 1460 times a year, like you do.That mentality is out there.(I am not against granite, I am just not for it exclusively).

Then, there are those who hate____ because it reminds me of _____. (right now "the eighties" seems popular.

But also I think some people don't discern between one ___ and another ____.

I was looking at the following for a client who had a large wall and was thinking about art and all sorts of things, and I thought for that amount of art and framing we could probably do a couple of panels of this: (Three panels of almost floor to ceiling would be a couple thousand maybe)

I was multitasking and friend of mine, said "Oh my parents had wallpaper like that in their house." I asked all kinds of questions, and she got more and more puzzled and she said "It's just that 1960s mural stuff, right?" So what her parents had was this:

{{!gwi}}

So, its the same but not the same, and 1840s vs. 1950s. But I am still not sure she saw the difference.

Well most of us can in here, especially when put side to side, but I am not sure that matters as much as what the word itself symbolizes.

But "I hate white appliances" means this:

{{!gwi}}

But the statement includes this:

{{!gwi}}

and this:

{{!gwi}}

Likewise:

This:{{!gwi}}

Isn't really this:{{!gwi}}

This:{{!gwi}}

is not this:{{!gwi}}

And this:{{!gwi}}

isn't this:{{!gwi}}

Comments (42)

  • 15 years ago

    AAH, Pal....but that's because you have a discerning eye! Lots of people who post here don't have that ability here.

    I have a good friend who eats my cooking fairly often....but he hates onions/ Or at least he did until I caramelized a bunch and put them on a crust, topped with shredded imported parmesan cheese and baked it! "I hate onions", he said, "but not those kind of onions."

    I hate white appliances....but not the 2nd and 3rd you posted....you get the idea...
    Linda C

  • 15 years ago

    I think there are plenty of discerning eyes in here (as opposed to my friend, perhaps) but I think that certain objects become symbolic examples of everything in a particular category. They have shown that one of the reasons many people can't draw is because they use a symbolic shorthand for what they see rather than recording it exactly as they do see it.

  • 15 years ago

    I'll tackle the mural/wallpaper. My mom painted a mural on our LR wall when I was about 8. It was beautiful (early 1960s), but when I see any mural, no matter what it is, it reminds me of my mom's mural.

    If I didn't like her mural I'd probably say to other's, "I don't like murals because it reminds me of the one I had growing up." And vice versa if I liked it.

    It's as simple as that so I don't really get what you're saying. People go by memories and sometimes it doesn't matter what style an object it, it still brings back those memories.

    Not sure if any of that made sense.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not sure what you want to discuss. The word hate itself, or using the word hate to exclude other things in the category, eg. your white appliance analogy.
    When on GW sites, I don;t use the word "hate" (rarely use it regardless) because I think it is insulting and upsetting to the people who "like" that which is being hated.

    My favourite "hate" is that of white kitchens. There are lots of products that I wouldn't use in my kitchen (it's white and I would have no other) or home for a variety of reasons - not my taste, out of my budget, wrong colour, but it doesn't mean I hate them. It just means that it doesn't suit my needs. I wish that others could understand that instead of vehemently hating an inanimate object that someone else might like.
    There is a reason as to why there is a myriad of choices in the marketplace for different styles, colours, forms, art, objects and that's because we are all different. We have different ways of looking at things, and of appreciating things.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree. I think of something like this when I hear people say they hate brass

    I couldn't replace two fixtures of that general style (but worse) in my current house fast enough -- but not because they were "brass". I replaced them because they were cheap, overused builder fixtures that didn't fit the style of my house and they stood out like a sore thumb. I replaced both of those fixtures with actual antiqued brass that I love.

  • 15 years ago

    It's not the memories or the stuff, it's the disdain in the voice as if "only an idiot could LIKE that".

  • 15 years ago

    I find people who are ignorant in the way you describe usually have equally narrow views in others parts of life.
    Sometimes education helps but that kind of stubbornness runs deep.

  • 15 years ago

    People go by memories and sometimes it doesn't matter what style an object it, it still brings back those memories.

    This is exactly like pal's example of not being able to draw. People see what's in their head, not what's in front of them.

  • 15 years ago

    Too often someone's general statement is perceived as an absolute. Most of the time, I don't think anyone has an absolute like or dislike of a type of decor, just a general "not for me" feeling about it. Appliance color, stained oak cabinets, brass...there is likely to be an example somewhere that they find attractive.

    I don't understand the desire to criticize or take personal offense. Yes, I see the threads that teeter on (or topple over) the edge. Seems more like a little boredom has set in and we're looking for a bit of action than anyone who truly hates a category or feels attacked. I certainly don't think that the people who post here lack the ability to discern poor vs good design. We only see a glimpse into the personalities/abilities of those who take the time to share their ideas. Sometimes we shorthand our statements to reduce finger fatigue :)

    People use generalities. Some assume that the audience realizes there are exceptions. Do we always need to qualify our dislikes?

  • 15 years ago

    Yeah, well, maybe. I agree that a broad dislike is not sensible but ... Your last example is perfect for me to comment on. The first stripe (fabric or wallpaper) is the type that turned me off of any almost any stripe. It may be "classic" but it does not please my eye. Reasonable? No. However after having seen it in cheap furnishings and expensive furnishings I can't get past my dislike. You can use it in your house though and I will not comment on it. Sometimes we just don't like things.

  • 15 years ago

    Sometimes people like what they think they are supposed to like. If Pottery Barn slapped the 50's mural on the wall in a catalog, many people would run out and buy it. I actually like the 50's commercial illustrator feel of it.

    I think the blanket "likes" are as bad as the blanket dislikes. Certain finishes and materials that are wildly impractical show up to the point where some of the rooms people post are carbon copies of each other, regardless of the use. I wonder how families with teen girls will like their vanities with no storage or pale marble counters when they have been stained by nail polish remover. Form should follow function.

  • 15 years ago

    I dislike the first stripe, and I have never liked it, even during one of its upswings in popularity. It is currently available Waverly, so someplace, they must be using it. But this is my example of what people think of when they think of wallpaper and don't like it. I like the second stripe a lot.

    The 1950s mural is Thibaut, and they still make it although I think you have to get it directly through them. It speaks of a particular period though. The "real thing" Zuber, has been in production for 170 years, and doesn't so much speak of a period as a genre.

  • 15 years ago

    What about fear?

    Don't you think that some people are shallow enough that they may comprehend the difference between the $29 colonial brass fixture and the lacqured solid brass one. But they are so caught up by the vain notion that THEY understand the difference, but don't anticipate that others will, that they still will select something else? The inferred dislike of others??? The inability to use what one actually prefers?

    Or the other side of that. The person who may have a genuine item, and the trend flavor of the month is an import knock-off of that item (starburst mirror, MCM chair, what have you.) Is that person less likely to exhibit the genuine article at this time because of the implied following of the trend and de-valuation of the bonne fide item? Or do you just go with it and know that you have what you have? How to deal with the the implied notion that YOU can tell the difference, but most others cannot?

    What is the decor value of actual (used) vintage estate sale vs. (new) Pier One Imports?

  • 15 years ago

    I'm sure I am guilty of making blanket statements. "I hate granite" doesn't really mean I hate the substance granite in all possible countertops, it means "I hate the mad craze for granite that makes it so everyone acts like the formica we grew up with was an aesthetic or functionless plague, instead of a perfectly functional surface that often came in fun colors or finishes." Maybe I am the only person who wishes she had sparkles in her laminate?

    Likewise with wall to wall carpet. "I hate wall to wall carpet" means I hate the wall-to-wall *I* have had to live with in my lifetime--inexpensive, dog-scented, unpleasant. I don't dispute that others can have nice wall to wall, but I do forget to represent that fact when I say "Ugh. I hate carpet!" to anyone who will listen when I am tired of vacuuming, etc.

    So, mea culpa!

  • 15 years ago

    I suppose if I had the funds and inclination to replace my carpet every 6 months I might not say " I hate wall to wall carpet" so much. (even wool)
    So, there are parameters to my dislikes, anyway.

    I will never say that about granite inspite of its seemingly ubiquitous quality but I guess I hang out with non trendy poor folks who still think it's special.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow. I feel like I should apologize.

    In a recent thread I commented that I "hate" reality shows. I just meant that they are not MY preferred type of TV show but I have many friends who watch them (and I certainly don't think any of them are idiots for doing so).

    In the same post I did not mean to offend anyone who is into contemporary decorating. As I see your contemporary pics I am coming more around to it. Understandably, I get a little more excited when people are discussing my preferred style(s).

    So to anyone who watches reality shows or decorates in a contemporary style (or anyone else that I may have inadvertently offended), please accept my apologies.

    I like to see all the different opinions. We don't have to agree, and sometimes it is more interesting when we don't, as long as we are respectful.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't think there is anything disrespectful about saying that you hate something that you do in fact hate, unless you are directly addressing another poster's house. In fact, I think there's sometimes too much disruption throughout GW from people who feel entitled to sweep into a discussion they were not even part of with faux outrage and high dudgeon because someone doesn't like something they happen to have. People need to be able to discuss things in general terms without thinking it's all about them.

    Also, I don't think the word "hate" is what pal is talking about. You can substitute the phrase "don't personally prefer," if you like, but that doesn't make any difference. I think pal is addressing the fact that people can make overbroad, overgeneral statements because they lump everything into one category even when there are wide differences in taste or quality--thinking that all brass equals '80s builder-grade chandeliers or whatever.

  • 15 years ago

    I thought it was Zuber. If not, it certainly has the hand painted look. The white appliances? What can I say? I really like the first one. I wonder how long it will take for that clunky look to be "in" again, and then everybody will want it for their vintage kitchen.

    Why people make blanket statements that they "like" or "hate" something....I'll suggest that, in many cases - in most cases - those words are merely shortcuts, they are abbreviated versions of a like or dislike intended to convey a general feeling about a larger category. I'll bet that, in many cases, the very same people who place their intense likes or dislikes out there for the world to see could ID quite a few exceptions. It's just easier to say that I really dislike the Pottery Barn look than it is to say that I dislike most of the colors and styles I'm familiar with -- but that that green Whatever wasn't bad, and that those white plates are nice, and that I like those curtains, just not in the colors offered, and that I am bored by the styles of almost every piece of furniture, but that that little side table might work perfectly in the hall. And so on....

    BTW I also like the Thibault paper. Even though what popped into my head was a sofa and matching chairs, in white "damask," all covered in plastic. Wait....that was my grandparents' house!

  • 15 years ago

    Correct. I think that people are allowed to hate whatever they want, that's a personal prerogative. It is the lumping together that I am exploring. I have to deal with this sometimes on design jobs and the real meaning behind it has to be dissected out.

    I had a client who "hated" vinyl floor so supposed she was "stuck with ceramic tile with mats on it." Wide eliminations like this really narrow choices.

    What it really mean was that she Liked everything about vinyl flooring except the currently popular patterns, (comfort for her bad knees and easy to care for) but preferred the plain look available in ceramic tile but disliked everything else about it.

    I just looked until I found a really plain vinyl, she only "hated" it because she hadn't seen what was actually available, but just uncommon.

  • 15 years ago

    I see that pal said something quite similar to what I just said, in his second post, but far more concisely! I am making a slightly different point, however. I take it, pal, that you're saying people overgeneralize but do not realize it. I'm saying they overgeneralize, do realize it, but do not have the time or inclination to say so, nor do they enumerate or describe exceptions, nor do they explain precisely what goes through their heads when they generalize. These exceptions sometimes come out in subsequent discussions on the subject.

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you Marcolo - you made me feel better about my use of the word hate (I didn't mean it to be "insulting" to anyone). We need to be able to discuss things in general terms without fear of offending.

    Some people like shiny brass, but not antique brass. Some people like antique but not shiny. Some just don't like any brass. Some don't like warm metals, including all brass. (I like brass). On GW we can always ask which type of _____ were you referring to (if it wasn't clearly stated).

    I think I understand Pal's point when dealing with a client - that maybe some close themselves off to an idea. They need your discerning eye to explain the differences. Maybe it helps to show the 3 white stoves (or whatever) and ask do you dislike all of them or just one (and explain the one you were thinking of using and why). Sometimes it may be associated with a bad memory, other times we don't know why we dislike something. If you really dislike stripes (florals, or whatever) you might not care what era they came from.

    Curious about "feel entitled to sweep into a discussion they were not even part of" - isn't everyone welcome?

  • 15 years ago

    When I read your post I was thinking of my own preconceived notions. I don't like blue rooms. Rather, I don't like them IN MY OWN HOUSE. Because my whole house growing up was cream and blue with rose accents and we were NOT ALLOWED to play on the blue velvet sofa (our kids STILL are not, in that same house, lol) or to hide behind the cream, blue and rose lined curtains (my parents do allow the grandkids to do this - they've lightened up).

    We played in the 2 rooms that were decorated in warm wood, oranges, browns, greens, yellows.

    So I didn't do this consciously, but when I look at the 3 houses I've decorated so far ('decorated' is probably way too strong a term, but I do love to choose paint), I tend toward yellows, warm grays, golds, greens. I did do my dining room Gray Wisp but I really struggled over whether or not I could handle it (I love it, it's beautiful with our 1880's boxed ceiling, chair rail and lots of white molding). It was while making the decision on the DR that I realized why I had never chosen a blue or cool gray before. (I've now done 2 baths in Sterling and Quiet Moments and they do look good, in small doses, in my house!)

    So I guess that's my hangup. I try not to project it as a blanket statement and it's helped me to come to terms with where my seemingly instinctive dislike of something comes from.

    It's also kind of like picking a baby name - you go through so many that have associations for you or your partner, a name you love turns out to be the name of a girl who broke his heart when he was 16, etc. etc.

    Interesting thread! :)

  • 15 years ago

    Curious about "feel entitled to sweep into a discussion they were not even part of" - isn't everyone welcome?

    There's a whole sentence there you quoted only part of, which went on to say: "with faux outrage and high dudgeon because someone doesn't like something they happen to have." Meaning, somebody says they hate subway tiles and then someone who was not part of the discussion prances in with fake hurt feelings, as if the whole conversation were about them to begin with. Just an attention ploy.

  • 15 years ago

    I understand about what you mean, Marco, but I am not sure the feelings are always fake. In the "I am tired of..." thread my contribution: " but for the same amount of money, or a little bit more you could have entry-level granite." was interpreted as "anti-granite" but really it was that to me it seems that people who have granite want other people to have it and nothing else, almost to the point of being annoyed if they aren't listened to. I think someone may have been banned over freaking out at me about granite or SS. At least I never saw her again.

    But yeah, sometimes a general discussion gets taken so personally that I want to post a certain Carly Simon song.

  • 15 years ago

    Sorry the partial quote was partially my lazy fingers, but I now realize I was being senitive to the wrong part of the sentence.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm the one who used the term "anti-granite" and I wasn't targeting you Pal, or your remarks specifically, but rather, as I also noted, a trend I've seen around GW recently.

    I totally get how obnoxious the dictate from HGTV or other "powers that be," is to have certain finishes and materials in a house, lest it be deemed hideous, "dated," and stamped "impossible to sell." Truly, I understand that. I would be willing to wager that I find that state of affairs more offensive and sad really, than many, many people ever will.

    But we also need to allow ourselves to like and to pursue something that *is* trendy or fashionable if we simply do like it. To shun something *because* it is "in" is the flip side of the same coin as selecting something *because* it is "in!"

    I am not going to light up like a Christmas tree & pronounce someone a courageous soul simply because they like & buy laminate countertops and vinyl flooring for their 2011 kitchen re-do. That does not make them brave iconoclasts who deserve accolades, for crying out loud.

    If laminate and vinyl make someone's heart sing, they should have them & forget about wood and granite, marble or tile. I can see how any material can work for a person, appeal to a person.

    The ony caveat: just be installing those things because that's what you truly want, not to be proving how reversing a trend makes a statement of some kind. To do so is as much nonsense to me as following a trend.

    Anything can be done well. A laminate and vinyl kitchen with white appliances could be fabulous, I have no doubt.

    We love what we love. It doesn't always make sense to others. I have a niece who wears no metal other than silver. She'd rather go out naked than be caught wearing gold. No matter how nice or expensive or high-end a brass light fixture is, she'd reject it out of hand because it is "golden" in tone. She'd say she "hated" brass in a heartbeat, and her global rejection of it would be true FOR HER.

    Not wanting wall to wall carpet is true for me. To say I "hate it" is not to say I can't see the beauty or usefullness of it for all houses...just mine!

    What if there are people who don't want this or that in their houses and they make a blanket statment about certain finishes or materials, regardless of price point or quality? There are people in this world who just don't want brass in their lives (or granite or wood, or chrome or nickel, or carpet.) Vive la difference!

  • 15 years ago

    "because she hadn't seen what was actually available, but just uncommon."

    I think this is key, and ties in with what you wrote on the "tired of" thread, Pal, about the push toward uniformity. It is so much easier to find so many of the usual colors, patterns, finishes than it is anything out of the ordinary. And with so many more places to find the ordinary now -- countless television channels, the internet -- I think fatigue sets in that much faster. And with so much information available, people's eyes tend to glaze over and discernment takes a hit.

    Becky

  • 15 years ago

    Like others said, I think at least some of it is related to conversational short-cuts.

    Some people don't seem to have very long attention spans either. I blame a good portion of that on Twitter.

    I realize Twitter is likely more a symptom than a cause...but it makes me feel good to blame it on them anyway. ;)

  • 15 years ago

    Pal, I gotta say that being too precise and discerning has been making my life hell lately -- and I don't necessarily mean in the home decor department. It seems to me sometimes that many, many people can speak imprecisely and in generalties to one another and get along just fine and they understand each other. I can't, and it causes problems. I feel like an alien.

    A good example from the world of work: My small company of coworkers might discuss concepts like "sales order" or "ASN" without precise reference to a specific piece of data or database; they may in fact be referring to a report or a process and not to the items I named. For them, the words are a shorthand for --- I don't know what. But my colleagues get the job done together and understand each other. It is a constant source of amazement to me, and I often feel a bit silly drilling them about detail they have not interest in so that I can get my precision needs met. In my world those words describe very specific things and I have to know the exact meaning.

    I believe the seeds were present even when I was a little girl. One summer my mom had me walk my brother (4 years younger) to the barber for a haircut. Already, at 10 or so, I was too literal to live, and I asked her, "What kind?". The best response I could get out of her was "A regular boy's haircut". That had no meaning to me. When I presented my brother's head to the barber and he asked what I wanted, I pointed to a style poster hanging on the shop walls that looked like the cut a couple of the popular boys in my grade sported.

    My mother was horrified when I delivered her crewcutted son.

  • 15 years ago

    Lack of exposure used to mean that people did not know their options. Also a designer could do the same kitchen in 20 houses and as long as the people weren't friends, who knew?

    Then came the internet. Just like Television destroyed the career of a number of previously successful comedians, suddenly, if we wanted to, we could see just about every option. (Comedians could go a year and circuit the clubs with the same jokes before TV, once its heard on TV, everyone hears it within days, and you need new material)

    Now, the "everything" has become TOO MUCH and there is so much overload that making a decision can be very difficult, and it is easier to go with a decision someone else has made.

  • 15 years ago

    I was about to ask whether the majority of people really do all the research and go into overload mode. Then I reconsidered because I am running across it more and more. People who take forever to make a decision because there are so many options. Not that I don't find myself doing it on occasion, but don't you just want to slap people who can't decide between the green and blue iPad covers (recent example). Just pick one and deal with it!

  • 15 years ago

    IMO, since women are generally more emotional, the word hate comes to mind when they *really* don't like something. For instance, *I* hate men w/beards! I can't describe my disdain using any other word. To say I dislike beards doesn't get my point across strongly enough. If someone else likes a bearded man, I have no problem. Que sera, sera. ;o)

  • 15 years ago

    I love granite...to look at. But I don't want to give up the practicality of my formica. Yet, when we finally get around to updating our *gasp* 80s kitchen, I think we are going to have to go the granite route to stay in line with our neighborhood. (Everyone else has already replaced their formica with granite.)

    I love tiled bathrooms...to look at. But being a child of the 50s, I know how wonderful it was when fiberglass showers became popular, because they were so easy to clean.

    I love SS appliances...to look at. But when a friend of mine told me how difficult it was to keep hers fingerprint free, I knew they weren't for me, and I will never have any.

    I think that the blanket we may be talking about, is the trend for everyone to think they need to have the granite, SS appliances, etc., etc,. etc. It's everywhere. Here, HGTV, magazines, blogs....

    I look at my house, which I absolutely love, but it was built in the *gasp again* 80s. It's a very well built house with lots of upgrades and details that make it special. Yet in today's decorating climate, it would disgust most people. It's an interesting position to be in to look at the features that I used to love, and think, hmmmm, maybe we should update that.

  • 15 years ago

    IMO, if magazines/tv shows/decorators didn't make such a big deal re:paint color/granite/ss/wood floors etc, trends would cease to exist. People would decorate/remodel in their *own* choice, w/o outside influences. Agree/disagree? ;o)

  • 15 years ago

    no way! who could this? i have two in my dining room:

    or this? i have four of these...

  • 15 years ago

    Individual memory-associations, a la Proust, certainly play a role. When I say I found a great piece of vintage furniture, I have a friend who always reacts as though she were imagining this:

    when in reality it's like this:

    But the question of relative levels of discernment ability is also really fascinating. It brings to mind the psychological phenomenon called synethesia: people who taste shapes, hear colors, etc. I have a niece with grapheme-color synesthesia who sees letters and numbers as each having their own distinct color. It's the darndest thing. She dislikes certain colors because she dislikes the numbers she associates with them (for whatever reason, like for instance the multiplication table for a red 9 is harder to memorize than a yellow 2). This isn't memory, really, but rather an entirely different form of perceptual association.

    Which leads to the question: nobody could like what I taste when I taste Brussels sprouts, so they must be tasting something very different than I am. Are they more discerning than I vis-a-vis cruciferous vegetables, or are they simply wired differently?

  • 15 years ago

    I have color -smell/taste synesthesia although it doesn't seem to be very complete, like many people there are a number of smells that are brown or green and I have a tough time with certain browns and greens because of this. Mostly because the smells I "see" are either unpleasant, or hover right between pleasant and unpleasant.I also taste certain colors but this is so linked in with smell that I don't know that I separate them all that much. I have some blue smells and tastes but they don't seem to limit me as much.

  • 15 years ago

    Yep, kinda like that washed out mint green - OK, let's say gov'mnt green... I smell elementary school!

    "less discernment = blanket 'dislike'?"

    I try not to do that, because, for instance, I prefer a real brass (darkest black-green) patina on a handle set that looks like it should have a patina and looks apropos for the door (it would have been totally wrong for our front door). Then again I prefer a polished brass finish on others that are apropos for the design of the handle as well as the door (this one was the winner here). And then again, I like ORB (got it in the kitchen where it makes sense) and Nickle where they are appropriate. KWIM?

  • 15 years ago

    some people see black and white and others see many shades of gray..... and those who see gray can try to 'help' the others to see the gray, but some REALLY can't see it...

    but, also, i think some who make such blanket statements such as 'i hate white appliances' are not adding the very important caveat 'that i can afford' !!! the examples of the white ranges above really isn't fair since the 1st pic is of a bottom of the line electric and the 3rd is a much higher priced professional range.
    same with the brass chandys and the berber carpeting-the 1st are similar to what one would find in a TB built house without any 'upgrades'...

  • 15 years ago

    The white range thing is the manufacturer's fault. That is what is available now. Something with no features, some in the price point of the Electrolux, and then the pricing jumps to $4000. That's it. The same seems to be happening to refrigerators right now too.

  • 15 years ago

    Trends gain in popularity, get overdone and lose popularity. Then people start to 'hate' the trend they saw everywhere, for too many years.

    Okay, maybe it's just me, but the minute one group 'hates' a certain look...they're kids usually end up loving it. Coincidence? :)

  • 15 years ago

    I think a lot of people do not consider context, and some people even get annoyed or think you are practicing peudointellectualism when you talk about context and do a lot of eye rolling.

    There is an architectural blogger in my city, who if he did not say he was either in an arhitecture progrm or had just completed one, I would think he was about 15. This is because the entire blog is laced with profanity used as adjectives, adverbs and nouns. I am no stranger to profanity but seeing buildings regularly described as "kick a-- m----r f----rs" page after page is tedious to say the least. I look at it for the historic pictures, which he seems to be talented at unearthing.

    Anyway, he hates just about everthing after the Victorian shift to early skyscraper stuff, with the exception of some deco commercial buildings. Everything. He has a category something like "Butt Ugly-A-- building of the week" although that doesn't seem quite profane enough. Usually, this is accompanied by some comment like "Intellectual architecture types will try to tell you that if you don't like this building you 'Just don't understand it' and that b---s---."

    But the bottom line is that he Doesn't understand it, because things don't happen in a vacuum, and there are all sorts of things that influence why things Look the way they do at certain times.

    I'll be the first to admit that there have been things that I didn't like because I didn't understand them. My new house is one of them. I thought these houses were ugly for years, and when I did my design program and understood more about context and history, I undertand enough about Why they look the way they do, that they don't look ugly anymore.