Software
Houzz Logo Print
sochi

Modern vs. Contemporary architecture

15 years ago

A recent houzz idea book looks at the confusion between modern and contemporary architecture. In this piece he is only looking at exterior architecture, he promises to do a modern/contemporary interiors piece soon. We've had many debates over what is modern vs. contemporary here, so I though some of you might be interested.

https://www.houzz.com/magazine/modern-or-contemporary-whats-the-difference-stsetivw-vs~397977_campaign=updates&utm_medium=email&utm_content=gallery0&d=0amp;w=1985

Comments (5)

  • 15 years ago

    I agree, with the exception perhaps, that the contemporary houses he illustrates still have roots in modernism, while contemporary also includes all the McMansionist Neo-Palladian, Neo-Norman, Neo-Georgian, Neo-Tuscan etc. houses that riff on historic ideas but are open planned, vaulted, polyglot-vocabulary houses. Such as the house in "candied kitchen" thread. Clearly a contemporary house, taste be what it may.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tradition-based Contemporary

  • 15 years ago

    That was what confused me a little palimpsest - it is exactly those McMansions, Neo-Tuscan etc. places that I would have called contemporary. I could clearly see a connection to modernism in most of the 'contemporary' houses he reviewed. In fact a couple of them I thought he would label as modern (in part because I perhaps wrongly assumed I like modern, don't like contemporary). I'll be interested to see his idea book on modern vs. contemporary interiors, hopefully there will be a few kitchens.

  • 15 years ago

    I saw this article a few days ago. This particular architect is very rooted in "modern", a conclusion I have made about him, having read his other articles in the past. The concept of "contemporary" being temporal and "modern" being a particular type of style are absolutely right. I think 'contemporary' needs more adjective to clarify when used to describe architecture.

    It is quite commmon to see a Conlonial (craftmans, arts and crafts, Victorian etc) style exterior homes with 'contemporary' interiors with a nod to traditional influence.

    For example, here in the Pacific NW, we have a particular style of architecture that we call "Pacific NW Contemporary" which merge modern with many elements of arts and crafts with the use of wood and natural elements, horizontal lines, large eaves, that let in abundant natural light. These have evolved in the past 60 years. The homes that were built 60 years ago are called PNW Contemporary and the newer ones are called the same.

    It would be helpful if people actually clarified, contemporay with phrases like:
    contemporary craftsman which are ubiquitous newer track housing here in the Pacific NW.
    contemporary neo-colonial, which are popular track housing in the mid Atlantic coast.
    For example, Eichler homes are called mid century Modern because they were a nod to modern design that had a particular look in the mid 1900s.

    Currently, there is a resurgence of modern influenced architecture. 10 to 15/20 years ago, modern was not as popular. (I know because I had a hard time finding modern design in things that I did at that time!) Everyone wanted the Pottery Barn look. All of sudden, Modern is hot.

    Perhaps, the newer modern influenced home exteriors should be called new century Modern (NCM) rather than the generic contemporary.

  • 15 years ago

    Sochi: thanks for posting that gallery. I've always known that there was difference between the two and I've always known that I prefer contemporary over modern. That gallery side-by-side like that helped me remember why. I like modern for its starkness of lines but I wouldn't want to live in it. I find contemporary to be slightly "warmer" in its architectural lines as compared to the modern. . I'll have to go back and research interiors to see if its the same.
    I noticed that when coastal_love_modern posted her kitchen that some called it modern and others called it contemporary so which is it? I would call it contemporary because although the lines of it are clean and sharp, there is a certain warmth to it.

    Now, what do I call McMansions et al ?- ugly.

  • 15 years ago

    Sorry - coastal_modern_love. (Posted her name wrong)