Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjl443

Why no range/cooktop in peninsula

14 years ago

One of the comments that I got on my design was not to put the stove/cook-top in the peninsula. Is there a thread/some info that I can read as to why this is not a good idea?

Thanks!

Roberta

Comments (6)

  • 14 years ago

    Generally two issues. One depends on whether you want seating on the peninsula. You don't want seating near the cooktop. The other is that the range hood blocks the view, so you end up going with a downdraft which isn't nearly as effective. In our case we weren't going to have seating, but the hood issue convinced me to move the range elsewhere in our design.

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you so much!

    I do have a 2 year old and would prefer to keep it removed from his area for obvious reasons. We were looking at opening up our kitchen into the dining room with a peninsula in between, but I do think it would work better with the stove on the outer wall and the peninsula being prep space.

  • 14 years ago

    I just wanted to add, though it is an unpopular choice here there are some of that love island/peninsula cooking. I had it for over 20 some years, redid the kit and did it again in my last house. It didn't work here and I miss it. Yep venting is an issue. I did find that last set up with a tall thermador telescope it was not to bad. Worked perfect for back burners and I just tilted a pan lid on the front burners when necessary to direct steam, fumes etc toward the vent and it worked.

  • 14 years ago

    It is fine to have seating at the island with the rangetop as long as there is a reasonable buffer between the seats and the rangetop. We have had a rangetop on an island for over 25 years. Generally, one would want at least 2 feet between the edge of the counter where the stools are and the rangetop or cooktop.

    IMO, the feelings on this forum against rangetops or cooktops on islands are generally more negative than is justified. For instance, take the issue of whether a hood blocks the view. Somehow people don't object to pot racks or chandeliers over islands complain that a rangetop blocks the view. To me, it doesn't block it any more significantly than those items - if anything because it has simpler lines it is less of a visual distraction.

    Ventilation for an island cooking surface generally is going to cost more than a wall hood. Island hoods have to be finished on 4 sides and have to have the structure to support themselves from the ceiling attachment point. Wall hoods have to be finished at most on 3 sides and are attached to the wall so they don't need as much structure. Therefore, an island hood usually costs $500 to 1K more than an equivalent wall hood. (But you may make some or all of that up in not having a fancy behind range blacksplash.)

    Some people prefer to have a large uninterrupted island surface. In our L plus island kitchen, I prefer to have all of the L available for the window and wall cabinets by having the sink on the L under the window and the rangetop on the island.

    I've put a link below for one of the recent threads on the topic. There was another thread a while ago where more of us who liked our island/peninsula rangetops spoke up, but I'm having trouble finding it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/kitchbath/msg0519363531998.html?20

  • 14 years ago

    Even if you don't have seating behind your peninsula/island, you still need enough clearance behind the cooktop so that passers-by cannot bump into pots, or get hit with cooking splatter. Also, grease splatters can make the floor beyond very slippery and unsafe if there isn't enough counter space behind the range/cooktop.

    Personally, I'm a function-before-form sort of gal. I believe that once function is taken care of, there are plenty of alternatives available to make everything look good.

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz