Based on the pics, I'd go with the Burgundy Cherry cabs. The others actually look like oak in the pic and the styling appears much more casual. It seems you're going for a more high-end look with the stone. The finish on the spice cabs also doesn't look as rich and full-bodied :)

My little ole $.02 :)

Thanks!!

I agree with Squirrel. I just love the Burgundy Cherry Cabs so much. They are so rich and beautiful.

Hi liptonjl, having fun yet? Picking out this stuff was such a headache for me. But then, now that I'm done, I miss the adreneline rush. LOL

Two things;
1. Your floor color is very important in trying to choose your cabinets. What kind of wood floor?

2. Are you really looking at two different styles of cabinets? Or is it just the color? Those are so very different and like the others have said, the lighter one doesn't seem like the style you were looking for in Old World.

That said, I do like the Burgundy ones in style but the brown appeals to me in color and looks nice with the granite. (probably because I have dark brown and an Old World theme)

I did a quick mock up so you can see them side by side.
{{!gwi}}

Thank you for doing that lindy! The pics are just to show the color, neither are actually the style. The hardwood is going to be a medium shade... Probably would come close to matching the cabinets.
Here's a pic of what the hardwood will look like:

I want the dog!

(I think the burgundy is a more formal coloring.)

It that's the color of your hw flooring, on the yellow/orange side, I don't think I'd do the burgundy as it does look like a blue-red and if it's the one in my mind, it has a purplish-ness to it.