Software
Houzz Logo Print
su333

what is this Less is More?

17 years ago

I am decorating and I thought more for more, but someone

was telling me that Less is more. Not understanding this,

I also think I put this same topic on the crafts by accident

I am a newbie so please forgive me. I like flea market and

cottage style. Tell me about this Less is More thing.

Thanks and God Bless you

Su

Comments (35)

  • 17 years ago

    Have you ever seen a woman who is wearing so many accessories - jewelry, belts, hair doodads, etc., that you don't notice the woman herself? That is a case of more being too much.

  • 17 years ago

    I have always been a 'less is more' person. Can't stand when every wall and horizontal surface is covered.

    Maybe this will help....

    Here is a link that might be useful: Minimalism

  • 17 years ago

    I thought the name of Malevich's piece was "Moscow at night" :)

    If you're into flea market/cottage style, though, you're inherently more of a maximalist, I would think...but even with that kind of style, remember what Coco Chanel said: when you think you're perfectly dressed and accessorized, take one thing off. Restraint rather than excess is key.

    I love it when I see it, but then I find all these cool art pieces for the walls and end up squeezing things closer together. I've also never really loved the wall colors I've had before, but now I do, so maybe things will change. Oddly enough, even though I've edited professionally and have been in demand for my revision/cutting skills, I'm not very good at "editing" my own house...that would be a skill I need to develop. Probably comes partly because the idea of cycling things in and out of display seems like too much bother LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Two schools...'less is more' and 'more is better'.

    Contemporary is pretty much always, less is more. Other styles, where everything is layered on, like my3dogs and others, is more is better.

    I like both. Only bad thing about the latter, IMO, is dusting.

  • 17 years ago

    Could never grasp the theory that less is more ???
    How could too much of a good thing be not good?
    To me 'More is More' I've my entire life embracing
    that concept.

    Joann

  • 17 years ago

    Too much of a good thing can be too much, so less of it is more.........

    I wear bold necklaces so I don't wear earrings.......

    sometimes a little less of something is better, lol...........

  • 17 years ago

    Either look, either extreme, takes some skill to do correctly. Too much of more and your house looks like a junque shoppe. Too little of less and it looks like a hospital room. Balance is everything and it is sometimes hard to achieve.

    To the OP...has someone specifically told you that Less is More WRT your home? Maybe you need to edit a bit....either your living spaces or your circle of friends. ;-)

  • 17 years ago

    Naturally I HAVE to offer another alternative in this discussion! (LOL!)

    Anyway -- I prefer a balance between groupings of objects or artworks or craft items AND some "naked" space to allow the eye (and spirit) to "rest" and appreciate the rest.

    I do believe that accessories of ANY kind should be edited, rotated and re-organized in any space or room for a fresh look. Of course -- switching things around for a seasonal OR party look can be wonderful too!

    I do have a lot of accessories in my home and have learned that I am not a minimalist by any stretch of the imagination!

    If a space or room is too naked -- and devoid of any personality from the folks who live there -- then it will always seem cold and sterile!

    EQUALLY -- a room or space that is too "stuffed" will appear (to me!) to be way too hot and messy. ((this could be due to my age of course! Just teasing!))

    Finding that magical balance between having some items out for viewing AND allowing some spaces to "breathe" is the key!

    Jan (who always has trouble keeping her balance ..... LOL!)

  • 17 years ago

    Just wanted to add - when doing "Less is more" it's important that the less be of exceptional quality and can stand on its own.

    Jim

  • 17 years ago

    Less is more.......relaxing. Less is less to clean and maintain and worry about, leaving time for more meaningful things in life.

  • 17 years ago

    More is fabulous :oP

  • 17 years ago

    Well said Jim.

  • 17 years ago

    "Less is more" is such a powerful statement on so many levels! When it comes to decorating, less is more because the beauty of objects become apparent when they are not lost in clutter. Also, "negative space" around objects and art creates a soothing atmoshpere. One needn't adopt zen-like simplicity to embrace the idea that less is more, but an absence of lots of extraneous stuff & clutter is key, w/an emphasis on well-chosen accessories instead of things just taking up space.

    I live near someone who is very "more is more" in her decor, both indoors & out. Imo, it all feels like an effort to impress others, rather than to express or create something of beauty. She always uses LOTS of everything, & it all must be glitzy & attention-getting. She doesn't understand that more is just more, or get the appeal of understated elegance.

    There is a sociological/spiritual component to this statement as well as an aesthetic one. "More is more" often = "conspicuous consumption," which is so often an effort to stand out head & shoulders above the rest or at least keep up w/the Joneses. This way of life can be alienating to others & hard on the planet's resources. It can also lead people into financial ruin!

    The less is more approach to living embraces the notion to "Live simply so that others may simply live."

    The Japanese concept of "Wabi Sabi" is a striking expression of less is more.

    Here is a link that might be useful: less is more with wabi sabi

  • 17 years ago

    The best way to get a visual on less and etc. is to
    pull up posters homes on here and take a look.
    Look at my3dogs home and you will see more is beautiful
    and in wonderful taste the way she has decorated.
    Its fab and full.
    Some of the posters homes are drop dead gorgeous and they
    have lots of beautiful accessories.
    Such differnt taste on here.
    Some homes have nothing anywhere. In a LR you will see tables
    with nothing on them and maybe one pic on the wall.
    Kitchens with nothing anywhere.
    To me it looks like no one lives there.
    Thats just my op.
    What ever you like as far as "things" go really depends
    on your personality.

  • 17 years ago

    Jim said it all. I think quality is the deciding factor in making any design appealing. Doesn't have to cost a lot of money, but has to be sturdy and has or will stand the test of time. Making an old piece new is my favorite design element.

    I love my3dog's decor because it is not cluttered and each piece stands on its' own.

    I love less is more in my furniture and decor because as Parma mentioned "dust" is not my favorite thing. I also don't like to have to move furniture in order to get around a room when I am deep cleaning. Moving something from a wall is one thing, having to move it side to side to vaccum around it, is not for me.

    In short, OP, if you look around a room and it's a blur, that means less would be more (better). LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Great post, Stinky.

    After which, one person said My3dogs is "more" and another says "it is not cluttered." Which is it?! lol

    I'm in the less is more camp - not to be confused with the room is not decorated (as love-my-lilhome describe).

    A room that is busy with special finishes (on the walls, ceiling and/or floor), over the top trim/tile and too many accessories/pictures doesn't let the eye or mind rest....but to each their own.

  • 17 years ago

    It's all about balance; less is not more if the design doesn't work and more is not more if it means unorganized and thoughtless. Neither is better than the other and both require
    their own specific maintenances. I like both ways exceptionally executed. But I prefer to clean the Less is More way.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm with Joann on this -- more is more -- and let me say I love her style of decorating.

    Less is more is minimalism, IOW, don't have anything out/showing that you don't absolutely need. I think of very sleek, ultra-mod styles.

    I don't want to insult anyone who loves that style, as to each her own (and they do have less housework to do), but I have never been drawn to it. Personally, I love eye candy everywhere you look in a room. It needs to be tastefully done, of course... as the "more is more" look can be "junky" if not done well. I think the Cottage decor types are not the less is more types, though.

    BTW, have you checked out the cottage decor thread in the Gallery? I love looking through it and I think you'll find it very inspirational. If you have a collection of inspirational Cottage Style pictures, please feel free to add them. I took the liberty of making the category rather broad, from beach to shabby-chic, to primative, to bears and moose, to very chic, to about everything else cottage-y.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cottage Decor

  • 17 years ago

    This is a fascinating topic! I've been in cluttered rooms that are beautiful because of how things are grouped together and they're not dusty but very clean, which makes "More is More" attractive. I love old fashioned table runners with pretty things sitting on them. Kind of "Victorian" which is a good example of clutter with style.

    I'm middle of the road. I can't stand rooms that are sparse with just a few nice objects. It has a cold feeling to me. I like a little bit of clean clutter, knick knacks and pictures to make a home feel homey.

    Most of all, I need a place to put a glass of water and a book when I sit down! lol

  • 17 years ago

    As far as decorating, I'd describe the concept of "less is more" by saying the fewer items competing for your attention, the more you'll look at whatever *is* there.

  • 17 years ago

    Wow, now I understand, I am so glad you guys explained
    it to me, Thanks, I enjoyed all your comments.
    Thanks
    Su

  • 17 years ago

    While "less is more" refers to minimalist design, I think it can be applied to the design concept of "elegant simplicity." I feel comforted and restful when I'm in a room that is not overly decorated.

    Having said that, I often struggle with designing/decorating my home to not be over the top. Should I have drapes or just let the window trim speak for itself? Should I add tin tiles to my kitchen ceiling or will that look too busy? Should I hang a collection of several pieces of art on a wall or just a couple of select pieces?

    Years ago, when DH and I first started dating, he made a comment that I had a lot of "junk" in my house. I was appalled because I thought I did a great job with what little money I had. But he made me see my place through fresh eyes and he was right. So I had a garage sale and sold all my little meaningless chochkees. My place looked and felt so much better without all the "stuff."

  • 17 years ago

    I am a minimalism, while my sister and her husband are "over the top" with knick-knacks. However, when we visited for Thanksgiving, my 27 year old daughter told me that I need more knick-knacks like my sister. I've declined. :)

  • 17 years ago

    'Less is more'

    'More is better'
    {{!gwi}}

    'Nothing is best'

  • 17 years ago

    Amen stinky.

  • 17 years ago

    Less is more is minimalism, IOW, don't have anything out/showing that you don't absolutely need. I think of very sleek, ultra-mod styles.

    Not to me. It's more along the lines of Kellyeng's first sentence: "While "less is more" refers to minimalist design, I think it can be applied to the design concept of "elegant simplicity." I feel comforted and restful when I'm in a room that is not overly decorated."

    Pharoh's "less is more" is modern/contemporary to me and not a less is more room. It's cold, sterile and uninviting. The "More is better" room is too crowded and busy - I hope that's a store. Neither are rooms that make me want to spend time there.

    Everyone is going to have a different definition for "less is more" and "more is better." For me, "less is more" is not having something sitting in every corner, nook and cranny. Space to rest the eyes. Tabletops are not cluttered. There are eye-catching, interesting items in the room that lead the eye around the room. Not chaotic like the "more is better" above.

  • 17 years ago

    My home is a "more is better" cottage wannabe.

  • 17 years ago

    "more" does not mean "cluttered" Cluttered is when stuff is on top of stuff and you can't see anything because it's a blurr of stuff. That's clutter. LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Perfect Pharaoh!,
    I was thinking about Chinese Oppulance vs Japanese Zen
    both may be exquizitely execuited or exequited devastatingly.
    Perfection of either extreme requires a profoundly deep understanding.
    which leaves a lot of options for personal taste, lol
    don't ya wish there was gardenweb spellcheck
    Happy New Year Everyone!!!!!

  • 17 years ago

    Everyone is going to have a different definition for "less is more" and "more is better." For me, "less is more" is not having something sitting in every corner, nook and cranny. Space to rest the eyes. Tabletops are not cluttered. There are eye-catching, interesting items in the room that lead the eye around the room. Not chaotic like the "more is better" above.

    That is how I see it. You don't have to be a minimalist to be a less is more, you just have to know when to stop.

  • 17 years ago

    I not only think less is more, I think fewer "little" things are more....no trinkets that you have to get right on top of to know what they are, not to mention all the nooks and crannies that make it impossible to clean.

    Susan

  • 17 years ago

    My idea of less is more is something my art teacher taught me........in a painting we used negative painting. It taught you to leave room & you painted the outline of the shape. In decorating, I think of it as not crowding the room so as the other decor pieces have room to breathe & look pretty. You need negative space. I have read on BH&G also....to create a spacious room, you have to leave space which amounts to the same thing. Overdoing a room isn't necessarily a good thing as neither as underdoing a room. Restraint is key.
    Hope this helps....we all do too much sometimes & then take away.......have fun with your decorating! bonnie

  • 17 years ago

    Well, reading the above, less is more is definitely in the eye of the beholder. I prefer a My3dogs approach to most of my home. It's interesting, warm and inviting. I do choose a less is more (but never contemporary) look in the bedroom where I like a restful look. Nothing is the "right" way. It's what sets us apart and keeps us interesting.

  • 17 years ago

    well, first of all if you invite someone into your home, they should remember it is 'yours' and it will follow your style and taste. some people like plaid jackets, some stripped and some solid. The way we live does reflect that. If you invite someone in and they do not like that, they should not let the door hit them in the behind on the way out.

    You can take part of your things and put in boxes that are decorative and trade out your trinkets and pretties through out the year. good time to really clean and dust and rearrange to satisfy the need to have a lot of nice things.

    Younger kids do not understand how their parents and grandparents went thru the depression when you HAD to reuse and recycle things. Folks, that time may be on us again. Now some people like to buy one painting that is very expensive to show that have such good quality taste when 3 pics adding up to same price over a few years would be just as tasteful. But they will sure tell you each time you see them that it cost $$$$. They think to be IN they need to stand with a glass of wine in front of the painting and study it....

    The paint colors change names each year so we will buy more paint and put in the latest trend color. Furniture and linen companies do the same. It is their way of staying in business. Do you realize that some antique furniture that is better built than today cost a lot less than a new piece of furniture that is basically fiberboard. You do what you like with your home no matter what the designers say.

  • 17 years ago

    mpdwmom, I don't know if you know Christopher Lowell, the TV designer. He says that if you can't identify an item from across the room then it is considered room dandruff! LOL, he makes sense. Now when I see little trinkets around a room I think of what he said. I prefer to keep my trinkets in a glass cabinet for many reason, mainly so the cats don't break them.