Software
Houzz Logo Print
adh673

Lessor of two evils?

16 years ago

I think my kitchen shrank since I planned it.

Right now, the island is drawn on the floor (post demo) with an island that has 45 inches on the aisle by the pantry wall and door to the basement. On the sink side, it has 42 inches. These measurements are all cabinet to cabinet, not granite overhang. I dont know what my granite overhang will be as I am late picking it out. My cabinets are inset.

Anyway, on the 45 inch side, we have an overhang for stools for my little helpers (kids). But that is feeling a little tight as the door to the basement swings partially into this aisle. A 30 inch door.

On the other hand, the aisle by the sink is 42 except for the farm sink cabinet which bumps it down to 39. And the sink will be a double bump out, so really probably 38.

I am inclined to tell my GC to move my island over 2 inches towards the sink wall. He's not loving this as all their piping and electrical were just run to fit the original model. But I think these two inches might make a difference to the walkway where there is seating.

He says that I could be crowding the sink. Argh!

What should I do?

Comments (2)

  • 16 years ago

    I thing your GC might be right. If you have inset cabinets, you can probably get away with a 3/4" to 1" counter overhang. That means your 38" aisle at the sink is now down to around 37". If you move the island toward the sink a couple of inches, you're down to 35"...and now an issue begins as to whether your DW door will fit in the aisle. It probably will as most DW doors, I think, extend approx 30" when open, but there will definitely not be enough room for anyone to even squeeze by the DW.

    When you say your sink is going to be a "double bump out", what do you mean? Usually bumpouts are 3" to 6". Is it a bump into the kitchen? Or is it a bump out the back wall? I seem to recall you asking for help with a bumped out, counter-height window.

    If you have 6" or more of bump out, do you really need the sink to bump into the kitchen? So, could you eliminate the the bump into the kitchen? That would give you back several inches and then moving the island is a possibility...I would try for 3", btw. 42" down to 39" (or even 38") is just barely doable... That would give you a 48" aisle behind the seats...54" would be much better, but I suspect your kitchen is too narrow for that. (How wide is your kitchen, btw?)

    What type of pantry do you have behind the seats? Cabinets? Drywalled? How deep is it? Could it be reduced a few inches?

    Is the refrigerator also on that wall? Is it a built-in or free-standing (counter-depth or deeper)? If your refrigerator is also behind the seats, then factor in the refrigerator's depth as well, including handles. They all impact aisle width and how much room is needed to get past someone sitting at the island.

    What is your island seating overhang? If it's > 15", then I would reduce it to 15". If it's =

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Buehl, so you think I should aim for 3/4 inch overhang? The DW is a miehl fully integrated but its sort of at the end of the island I think. Im going to go check the specs on it.

    Behind the seating is a wall and pantry cabinet. Nothing can really be reduced. Its only 18 inches deep as is due to some air returns/piping behind it.

    The sink is double bump out because the sink cabinet is 27 inches and the sink is a farm sink so it will be out another 1 inch or so? I dont know. In retrospect I guess I didnt need the bumped out sink cabinet since I am going to box out the window a little but when I ordered I had planned a window like cali linda which I couldnt get to work in my dimensions.

    Here is the plan:

    {{!gwi}}

    So, basically I just need to at this point decide where to anchor the island and which aisle to skimp on a bit. I'm used to a big space by the pantry side so Ive been leaning towards giving that more leeway but I dont really know the impact of possibly only 35 inches between the farm sink and the island.

    My overhang is only 12 inches, which is all I could do. My kids sit at my island today (prior to demo) with no overhang (they drag chairs up there to hang out with me) so 12 inches was better than nothing for us.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!