Software
Houzz Logo Print
portia_gw

Forcing Narcissus, not paperwhites

11 years ago

Google wasn't that helpful with this particular question... I have some Flower Record leftovers from my 250 pack box from Van E's sale...would like to try forcing them inside this winter.

I've done paperwhites for years now, super easy. So, I started the FR's the same way about a week ago, in small rocks in pots of water, water barely touching the bottoms, but as of today, only about 1/3 have sprouted roots...the rest are in various stages of green stem tips showing or slight powdery mildew starting on the bulb.

Took them all out, planted the ones with obvious roots together in one container, and now contemplating the rest of them.

Thinking I leave them out in sunlight on a flat cookie tray in our sunroom, and just spritz them with water for a few days to see if I can get roots going before planting? Almost all of them have green stem tips showing...so I feel like they are on the cusp.

Any other suggestions? Is this a foolhardy exercise? (I'll probably still try it since I have a fair amt of leftovers!)

Does anyone spray with fungicide before forcing inside?

It's funny how out of about 30 bulbs, the ones that sprouted roots have a giant plethora of them, but the others are still sleepy. Wonder what makes it want to 'go'.

Thanks in advance!

Comments (7)

  • 11 years ago

    Were these bulbs chilled before forcing? It might have been that some did not get a sufficient chilling time. I think Van Engelen says on its website that the bulbs are not prechilled. I Googled "chilling daffodils" and thought this article was rather nice:

    http://www.bhg.com/gardening/flowers/bulbs/forcing-spring-bulbs/

    I gave no input on the mold....hopefully someone might comment how to further with your current situation.

  • 11 years ago

    I am not at all sure about this but I believe that Paper Whites are a variety of tazetta narcissus which do not require a winter chill. Hence the ease with which they can be grown indoors. I can't find any evidence that Flower Record is a tazetta and therefore I assume it needs a chill period in the dark or it won't flower. Narcissus intended for growing outdoors in places with a winter don't get a pre chill at the suppliers. They get it automatically after they're planted in the garden. So if these bulbs were mine I'd pot them up and put them into a cold dark place for several weeks before bringing them inside. I do this with Hyacinths every year but I've never forced daffs so this is all conjecture. Over here bulbs are sold as 'prepared'if they are intended for indoor growing i.e. pre-chilled. So I've never done it myself.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes I did wonder about the chill period...since the rest did get planted in the garden and are getting a chill time right now. I'll put the few pots in the basement and bring them out a month from now and see what occurs. The ones I unpotted (slightly moldy) have dried out, so I'll put them in there too.

    Should have left the box outside for a few weeks before attempting this I guess!

    I might leave the one pot that does have roots and is growing to see if it will flower with no chill period, if nothing else an interesting experiment.

    Thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    Is the basement really cold? The link says 35 - 48 f is needed.

    Flower Record is mentioned in this article.

    p.s. the chill needs to be damp as well as cold, so the bulbs need to be potted up, not loose.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Forcing Daffodils

  • 11 years ago

    I'm pretty sure that Narcissus and paperwhites are the exact same thing. I've seen some yellow Narcissus on the internet but don't know if growing them is any different.

  • 11 years ago

    Paperwhites don't require cold periods, they're native to regions that don't experience the cold that other species require.
    Paperwhites are a species of narcissus, but that doesn't mean that they're the same as every other species :)

  • 11 years ago

    Exactly, All Paperwhites are Narcissi but not all Narcissi are Paperwhites. In fact all Daffodils are Narcissi botanically speaking. But the term Narcissus is used in common parlance to mean certain short cupped species and varieties. Depending on their native habitat they may or may not require a chill period. Paperwhites are so popular for indoor growing precisely because they don't need chilling. You can just plant them up and stick them straight indoors.

Sponsored