Software
Houzz Logo Print
delawaretoys

TV over fireplace...one more time?

11 years ago
I know there are over 11,000 posts here about hanging a TV over a fireplace and there are only two possible decisions that can be made - yes or no. I STILL cannot make up my mind! I recently moved the TV out of the corner and slowly moved it, over the course of a few weeks, to where it now resides; squarely in front of the fireplace. This was done to get my wife used to the idea a bit at a time because she is not yet convinced a TV belongs over a fireplace.

This is what I want - I want that floor space the TV takes up so we don't have furniture taking up almost all the floor space in the room. We don't have a family room, so I can't remove it altogether (we like watching TV). I am also considering changing our wood burning fireplace we never use because of the mess (and having to buy, stack, and store wood), to a gas fireplace we would probably use. The existing fireplace is not large so we could comfortably hang the TV where the top of it would be 70 inches from the floor which would leave us 2' from the ceiling; we have 8' ceilings.

Comments (32)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Over the fireplace!!! Why cover up a beautiful fireplace and take away detail from your home with a tv??

    delawaretoys thanked DKR Countertops
  • 11 years ago
    Yes, over the fireplace.

    Btw, love your red chair! I have an almost identical one in bright greenish blue and I cherish it.
    delawaretoys thanked crowley48
  • 11 years ago
    Excuse my poor choice of prepositions..."I am thinking of hanging it ABOVE the fireplace"!
  • 11 years ago

    I think maybe you stuck that TV there in front of the fireplace, which hides it completely-- not so much to get your wife "used to the idea a bit at a time," but, rather, you knew she would hate seeing that black box covering up her fireplace day in and day out. So that, after a while, it would grate on her so badly, she'd scream, throw up her hands, and say, "Oh, just put it anywhere you like." And then you get the big black box over the fireplace, just like you wanted in the first place. That's what I think. :)

    I'm one of those people who cannot envision putting a big black box like that on the wall, over a fireplace or not. Can you hide it some way? Since you don't use the fireplace, put in cabinetry there, deep and wide enough for a TV, and with doors that can hide it when you're not watching it. Or maybe the bedroom (I know-- bad place for a TV), but that way, no one has to see it but you two. :)

    delawaretoys thanked dbh
  • 11 years ago
    My plan, if it comes together, is to have the same cabinet maker that built our kitchen cabinets design something that would hide the TV. I would love to get one one of those stealth TVs that turn into a mirror when it's not acting like a TV, but the PowerBall numbers are forever NOT in our favor.
  • 11 years ago

    Gosh, Rina-- I hate to say it, but I almost suggested the garage myself-- and then I thought that was just bad.

    delawaretoys: I have not seen the stealth TVs. Wow. I might find that slightly disturbing. So get that cabinet maker on the phone today; it may not be as expensive as you think. We had a seriously talented cabinet maker put in some built-in bookcases for us last year-- really looks like they came with the 90 year old house-- and that was not as expensive as I had imagined-- not even close. I was surprised. It helps if you're going to paint them, too (so the wood doesn't have to be top of the line cherry or anything).

    delawaretoys thanked dbh
  • 11 years ago
    Go for it. I am not a fan of TV's over fireplace but if you can mount it very low I think it would work fine. But change out your drapes for full length ones!
    delawaretoys thanked Kevin Hurley
  • 11 years ago

    If Mrs Delawaretoys would be comfortable, how about a pretty slider mounted with barn-door hardware (modern, residential version!) to cover the TV when no one's watching? You can choose white wood to match the fireplace surround or whatever appeals... The slider can be ordered (or made, if you're handy) just long enough to cover the "black box" lol! Here's one using a mirror!

    http://rusticahardware.com/mini-barn-door-hardware/

    delawaretoys thanked User
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    I think over the fireplace is fine. We are seeing trends even with our multi-million dollar homeowners. They are all mounting TV's over fireplaces.
    delawaretoys thanked The Well Planned Home
  • 11 years ago

    Those who are against TVs over the fireplace often cite the potential for neck issues... But since they never mounted their TVs over the fireplace, they aren't speaking from experience. I love my TV over the fireplace and I hate TVs next to the fireplace bc they always look awkward and take up space better used for seating. I didn't develop neck issues, and I watch a lot of TV.

    Has anyone actually tried the tV over the fireplace and developed neck issues?

    Delawaretoys, Rina is right. We need to see your wife's chosen location for the TV so we can evaluate.

    delawaretoys thanked emilyam819
  • 11 years ago
    Where divi hide cable box etc?
    Many fireplace us between sliding doors and windows
    Also when u walk in first thing u see is the fireplace and Donot want tv
    To be first thing
    Otherwise would love tv on top
    Donot want to stare at cable box
    On mantel
    Ideas?
    delawaretoys thanked 20fleetwood
  • 11 years ago

    emilyam819: Just to clarify my earlier statement-- I'm not against TVs over the fireplace because of any potential neck problems. I just find a TV over the fireplace aesthetically unappealing. I know you can go to hell for saying that here, but that's my issue with it-- nothing more. :)


    delawaretoys thanked dbh
  • 11 years ago

    If you want the t.v. over the fireplace and your wife agrees, why not do it? And you gain floor space -- that's always a plus.

    delawaretoys thanked hatetoshop
  • 11 years ago

    Sorry, dianahb... my comment wasn't directly in response to yours.

    I should have also said, it depends on the room. What is good for some rooms might not be good for others.

    delawaretoys thanked emilyam819
  • 11 years ago
    Not crazy about TVs above fireplace. People tend to sit too close causing the neck kink issue, BUT if that is the only place it will work, I understand your issue about furniture everywhere clogging up walk space. Great idea to change to a gas fireplace, place a mantel above firebox to deflect heat rising to TV. Doesn't have to be big and chunky, and place your TV as low as you can taking in consideration your neck and how it looks. Great idea to work with a carpenter, between the 2 of you, you will make it work. I hope you post your finished work. :-)
    delawaretoys thanked Joy
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Seems there's a plant stand in front of the window? If there's room for a spare chair and plant, why not just move hubby's spot back over somewhere else? Draw the curtain or buy a blackout liner.

    delawaretoys thanked everdebz
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you all for your ideas. There are other places we could and have had the TV; on the right side of the room in front of the only wall with no window or bookcase and in the corner between the bookcase and the large window. But I like the chairs where they are now; makes the room look bigger. I was hoping someone who has hung their TV above the fireplace would respond and let me know if they like it or wish they had not done it.



  • 11 years ago

    What a charming room. It has buckets of personality. And a cat. I'm inclined to agree that over the fireplace is the only sensible place for the TV -- although I believe we are still seeing only three walls -- but then the fourth may be open plan, yes? So, installed in cabinetry .... hmmm .... I guess.

    delawaretoys thanked Rina
  • 11 years ago
    Sometimes you just have to try something to see if you like it. What works for someone else may or may not work for you. As long as your room is big enough, you won't get the neck kink issue from sitting too close and as far as appearances go, surely putting the TV over the fireplace is preferable to in front of
    delawaretoys thanked mandy_moo_pants
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We hung our t.v. over the fireplace (tried it elsewhere but didn't work). No neck pain and no regrets.

    delawaretoys thanked hatetoshop
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks again for the suggestions. Yes Rina - the fourth wall isn't a wall - it's the opening to the dining room; no place there for a TV.


  • 11 years ago
    Well as was said .... the rich folks are doing it ..... so it must be OK. I am having trouble putting all the walls etc. together. On first look it seems an OK spot given circumstance. If other wall is only option ..... where I wonder does that furniture would go. Assume you would then have backs etc. to fireplace! Which would be a shame. Why not stick it up with cables loose and see how it is for a week or 2. If OK sort out the cables. If not remove bracket and try other wall.
    delawaretoys thanked clutteredval
  • 11 years ago

    No.

    delawaretoys thanked retroearth
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Such a pretty room. Love the built-in bookcases-- and the photogenic cat.

    That's a big blank wall over that couch. Again, I'd see about finding (or having some built for you) cabinetry to house the TV-- on that big blank wall-- and then re-arrange your furniture (couch). Another option might be to change the shelving (remove several shelves, if they're movable) on the existing bookcases, drill some holes and run wiring in there (so wires don't trail on floor) and place the TV on one of the shelves. Move your couch off that wall; put the chairs there, and the couch perpendicular to that wall, so that it faces the bookcase. Is that a viable option??

    Not to beat a dead horse here, but it's such a warm lovely space and seems a shame to hang the TV on the wall-- anywhere. Looking at the additional photos here, hanging it over the fireplace would also seem an awkward perspective, from the TV viewer's point of view. I don't know that anyone would get a very good vantage point.

    delawaretoys thanked dbh
  • 11 years ago

    The TV could be tucked into the bookcase, but for me it would spoil what is a classic look in a room that pays homage to books -- the solidly book-filled shelves, floor to ceiling; particularly when there are a pair of them, as here.

    I wondered if the TV would fit neatly between the opening and door on the dining room wall, but then it would be facing a window, with the reflection problem that creates (although I know a lot of people live happily with such reflections). The couch could be left where it is, probably, with the TV on either of the short walls, as it's perfectly comfortable to watch TV side-on; one just swivels one's body a bit. Diana, I think the TV over the fireplace -- aside from a possible height problem -- isn't really awkward from the TV viewer's point of view in practice. But maybe it's aesthetically uncomfortable, it looks as though it would be awkward, neither one thing nor 'tother.

    delawaretoys thanked Rina
  • 11 years ago

    Hey Rina. I wasn't talking about the TV-over-fireplace-neck issue-- I just found (and maybe I'm not seeing this correctly from the photos provided)-- the fireplace itself seems awkwardly placed, not central in the room-- an odd location (right beside the front door and not central in the room?). That's why I thought you would never get a good view with it placed there. The fireplace itself is so off-centered in this particular room, that to place any chair in a spot that would have a good view seems near impossible to me.

    We have wall-to-wall and floor-to-ceiling bookcases. And I did remove a couple of shelves to fit in a TV. Granted, my TV is not as big as delawaretoys' but it is in there and totally unobtrusive. The rest of the bookcases still house books (too many of them). ;)


    delawaretoys thanked dbh
  • 11 years ago

    we have TV over fireplace.. it's out of the way.. no neck pain.. very happy.. good luck..

    delawaretoys thanked judy Shafer
  • 11 years ago

    Move the tv out of the way, get some painters tapes and tape the sizeof the tv on the wall. Looks like your room can handle it and I don't see another option in your house.

    delawaretoys thanked tennisanyone
  • 11 years ago

    Looking again, here is what I would also do. I would move one of the big chars next to the fireplace too, move the couch down, more centered and then get a big piece of art over the couch. That will balance out the heavy tv/fireplace wall.

    delawaretoys thanked tennisanyone
  • 11 years ago

    a mantle shelf or a floating shelf unit (or a rustic looking timber?) just above the FP will provide a definitive separation between the FP and the TV...run all cords through the wall...so simple with a $5 snake from the hardware store and you will have a great look. why waste floor space with the tv unit....you room will instantly feel more spacious! also consider simple, straight hanging curtain panels to frame out your windows....a simple change to make a space feel brighter and bigger!

    delawaretoys thanked potchiemagoodleberry
  • 11 years ago

    Have you actually raised the TV to the height it would be over the fireplace and tried to watch it for at least 1 & 1/2 hours? I doubt it will be comfortable. The best height to watch TV is when sitting down your eyes are level with 1/3 the way down from the top of the TV. See this LINK

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21