Software
Houzz Logo Print
glib2

Will we get peaches this year?

11 years ago

Last year, no peaches anywhere in MI (much too cold). This year the winter has not been so bad, with numerous thaws but also quick dips into negative temps (F). We have had maybe 7 nights total below 0F, and now looking at 3 out of 4 nights around -10F (it was -11F this morning). Is this enough to kill peach buds?

Comments (25)

  • 11 years ago

    Sounds like you would probably still have a crop if things don't get worse. But that is borderline and there could be some damage.


  • 11 years ago

    Probably not. Chop the trees for firewood :)


    I'd guess you lose some fruit buds, but i doubt all of them. Extended forecast looks very cold for the midwest right through late month.


  • 11 years ago

    All peaches are not equal and neither are same temps at different points of cold hardiness. I'd rather get these lows in late Jan than mid Feb but I'm hopeful that -10 or so won't adversely affect most varieties I'm growing here. In the past, when I only grew more cold hardy varieties like Red Haven and Madison I used to get good crops even after -15. The only year here where stone fruit was completely frozen out by winter lows we got below -20.

  • 11 years ago

    I don't have as many trees so last year -14 was enough to kill all buds. MSU says -10 damage starts and at -18 all are dead. With the most damage at -14. This morning here it was only -1 it didn't get as cold but Sunday and Monday nights look dangerously close to killing buds. Looks like I got lucky from what Glib reports.

  • 11 years ago

    Just went through some of my old pics and took a quick peek at some weather data. Winter 2011 had -19F and a couple of -17F days (Dec/Jan)...and a -14F in Feb...before it turned mild. I still had flower buds and produced a handful of peaches...This being from Aug of 2011...i believe its Reliance.



  • 11 years ago

    I'm not that concerned as I plan on grafting like crazy on my trees anyway. At least my raspberries, blueberries, and currants could care less. I'm going to add some super hardy blackberries this year too.



  • 11 years ago

    I'm glad I don't live where you yankees live. Our low sunday is supposed to be 19. No wonder so many of you guys retire to Florida. Our problems happen, when we get these temps after blooms have opened not before.

  • 11 years ago

    Just a thought...

    How practical would it be to throw a tarp over a tree, cinch it at the bottom and hang an incandescent bulb (appropriately sized) within. All it would need to do is to keep the temp from falling below -10 or so. One of you engineers out there ... please calculate the heat output ;)

    It would be easier to do on an espalier planting as one could run a string of bulbs hanging from one of the trellis wires and just drape a tarp over the top.

    Crazy!!!... but we have done weirder stuff to save our trees.

    Mike




  • 11 years ago

    In my case, I have four peach trees, interspersed through a 25 trees orchard, on the other side of the road from the house. Not easy at all. this winter has been good, in average temps, but it is the lows that matter. with a low of -11 so far, I can still expect peaches. Thanks to all.

  • 11 years ago

    There are other factors outside of just how cold it got. Weather before, time of winter, snow cover, sun, wind... who knows what else. I would say that peaches probably can't handle anything below -20F. ..even the hardiest types.

    I would love to know just how cold my garage (attached, but not heated) was last winter (brutal...45 days below 0F). All my container trees (peaches, pluots, plums) are in there and all bloomed just fine. My guess is its probably +10F over outside temps...if that. The ceiling is just open trusses so the heat that is in there just flows right out the ridge vent.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's supposed to hit -5 on Sunday, so I'm planning on tossing a tarp over a persimmon tree. I tried to do it earlier this week (Friday was -9 in the 10-day forecast, but the current forecast for tonight, doesn't even go below 0), but found the hard way that even small trees are bigger that you would think. This time, I've measured, gotten a bigger tarp, and will have my daughter help me. A 20'x20' tarp should be enough for a 6-7' tall, 4-5' wide tree (hopefully).

    I'm not sure if I need a heat source in there or not, as I probably only need 2-3 degrees of protection (it survived -3 last year unprotected without any die-back). Maybe the heat from the ground would be enough. If not, a bucket of water would be my next choice.

    For one of the very small persimmons, I just shoveled snow onto it, covering the bottom 90% of the tree. I'll see if it was needed, by checking if the top dies.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In Purling NY weatherman is calling for possible -10f. As there is quite some variability even within a zone, this is getting very close to the danger zone for some of my stone fruit.

    All that is needed is to keep it to no lower than between -5 & -8. I was just wondering if such a small temp increase could be accomplished with an electric bulb under a tarp controlled by a thermostat.

    I know this is not practical for many here, but, to someone with a small backyard situation it could be a very small hassle to avoid the summer long misery of looking at non-bearing trees.

    I am lucky in that I have electricity in my 150'x50' espalier orchard with only about 200 feet of stone fruit espaliers no taller than 6 - 7 feet.

    Mike

  • 11 years ago

    I've put the tarp over my Tam Kam persimmon and decided not to use any additional heat source. Sealing it in with snow (and 3-5 more inches on the way, before tomorrow night's cold) should hopefully keep enough heat in. I probably only need 1-2 degrees, given the forecast. Hopefully I didn't do more harm than good, bending the branches a bit and possibly some fumes from the new tarp (which I noticed after I had it almost all the way on...).


    I wouldn't bother with it, but I really want to try some of these and I think the tree is just about ready to produce. The last 2 years it has dropped all the fruit. This past year it held onto one for a while before dropping, just to tease me.



  • 11 years ago

    Mes, are you sure they aren't talking about chill factor? I haven't heard of actual lows predicted like that in NY near the water. I'm inland and am anticipating something close to that on Sunday but if you hit that in Nassau I'd be below -20 in the hills of Putnam County. NYC isn't supposed to go below 0.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    H'man...

    I was talking about Purling NY, 12470.

    Exit 21 off Thruway about 35 miles south of Albany.

    U.S. Weather service says -12 tonight.

    Others say -6 and -8

    Mike

  • 11 years ago

    Bob:

    My experince with persimmon is that the tarp is useless without a heat source. Mine froze back to major wood last yr when I used all the lights to save something else.


  • 11 years ago

    Well, I'll have to cross my fingers, as it got colder than forecast. I measured -8.1 as a low, but it couldn't have been there for long. Most of the night was -3 to -4, then sometime in the next 3.5 hours, it dropped to -8, and came back up to -6. So, it probably wasn't below -6 for more than an hour or two.

    If we get another night like this, I'll try Christmas lights on an extension cord, but I don't think it will happen this winter. The 10 day forecast only goes down to -2 and after that we're almost to March.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I didn't get as lucky it was -16 last night, bye bye fruit buds. Well at least i won't feel bad about hacking back scaffolds to graft new cultivars. I thought I would be cutting off a lot of fruit, so a good year to do it.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry to hear that Drew. Maybe you'll get lucky and slide by. Can't tell how many yrs I've been frozen out in the spring. In TX I'm sure I've had freeze damage 30-35 yrs out of 40. Not a total loss most yrs but at least damage.


  • 11 years ago

    Had -7F here, but most of the nite was around -4F... We don't have much snow in this area...a few crusty inches. Rest of this week looks cold..single digit highs, below 0F lows (maybe -10F /-12F...)... I have some chip buds that i'm worried about if it gets really cold..but we'll see.


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Fruitnut. 9 miles south of me in Detroit it was only -9F. 30 miles north of me it was -26F. Where my cottage is. Oh well. It's part of growing these things. I will still have raspberries, blueberries, strawberries, melons, watermelons, so it will be fine. Hopefully some blackberries. I'm going to buy Darrow and Nelson the hardest of hardy blackberries and play with crossing them to improve flavor. Also use some local wilds this year. Thursday night it is expected to be -12F so more is coming.

    Both my cars the batteries were dead this morning. One I just bought a new battery last year.

  • 11 years ago

    It was about -15F here west of Detroit, and we have another expected really cold night at -14F Thursday. So it is a 50/50 shot whether there will be peaches this year. Obviously, very few MI peaches this year too, regardless of our particular outcome.

  • 11 years ago

    It's that Murphy guy and his laws! Boy if I ever see him.... I put peaches in, in 2012 and we have 2 years below -10, which the last time was about 1993 it got that low.

  • 11 years ago

    In my part of NY it reached -10 which doesn't worry me much although most tender varieties will be questionable. About the same low as last year and the peach, plum and nect crop was fine.


    After this week true winter appears to be over.

  • 11 years ago

    Lucky! 10 days from now we have a high of 19F. The Great Lakes are so frozen, it keeps it nice and cool around here. -14F lows are coming later this week here. The frozen lakes will make it a cool spring too. It's going to take 3 or 4 years for the lakes to heat up to normal temps. It works the other way too, when we have hot years, the lakes keep the winters mild. But that's not happening anytime soon.