I like the edgecomb grey. It's nice and warm and still lighter than the tile. The whites are too white.

Old Groucho trail. I know Walmart has the swatch for it.

Yes, Jerry is almost right - Old Goucho Trail is in the greige family and would look good with your tile. Google images of it and you'll see it changes from company to company.

Well, that's bizarre. I googled it and got a bunch of photos of Groucho Marx! Is it Groucho or Goucho, decoenthusiaste? Goucho googled just leads me to a bunch of cowboy images! LOL

But I have to say, there is no perfect paint that goes with everything as Jerry has stated in another post where he recommends this same colour. Best to audition a few different tones before choosing the ideal colour when you're ready for painting.

I also want to emphasize that the quality of paint is extremely important and I would never send someone to Walmart for paint. Please consider a top-of-the-line Benjamin Moore product called Aura. This will give you excellent performance in your bathroom.

Thanks everyone, I decided to go with edgecomb, hopefully the white mirror and molding will make it pop. Trim in aura, paint in natura. I couldn't find gaucho trail either. No perfect paint is true @Cynthia, but there is always one that stands out in the bunch of wall testers! I appreciate the feedback!

You're absolutely right, Sarah. You did your homework very nicely so it was easy to tell what was right for your room. Great job, and the room will be lovely. Of that I have no doubt. Thanks for consulting with us on this.