Software
Houzz Logo Print
rouge21_gw

Compost enough?

Roses are considered to be heavy feeders? If so can regular additions of quality compost be enough in this respect?

If not I would appreciate getting recommendations re rose food NPK and the timing of the applications.

Comments (5)

  • 11 years ago

    It turns out that the use of lots of compost, like everything else, is a good idea in some climates (warm and dry), and not so good in very humid climates, where folks on here have said it promotes disease and rot.

    Having said that, I will tell you what I do. I live in No Cal, in a dry summer Mediterranean climate. I put Osmocote ( the 9 month kind) on all of my roses when I prune (or just clean up around) them - it is a timed release rose food. I also give each rose 3 gallons of MAXSEA (the all purpose version, diluted as per the instrucitons) at that time. Then I put compost all around each rose, about 2 inches deep. Then I sprinkle some sort of weed seed germination preventative (I use Preen) on top of the compost, and water it in as per the instructions.

    That's it for the year. Please note, in my climate the roses keep growing and blooming most of the winter - they usually do not go dormant. Every climate will need different strategies and tactics - check with your local rose society, or neighbors who grow lovely roses.

    Jackie

  • 11 years ago

    Compost is good for the soil and good soil grows good roses. Any organics that enrich the soil are a good thing. However, it doesn't hurt to add a good fertilizer now and again either. I've used most all of them and they all work pretty well. You don't need to buy one specific for roses either. Any good balanced flower fertilizer will work.

    In the early spring (for me that's usually April weather permitting) I mix up a batch of dry stuff to scratch into the soil, a time release fertilizer, some Holly Tone (it's basically the same as the Rose Tone but cheaper) and some Epsom Salts. Then I go to foliar feedings with a liquid fertilizer and some fish emulsion every two weeks until the end of June when my shows are over. After that I feed them about once a month until the end of the season. I don't quit feeding them in August because they keep growing until October whether I feed them or not and I want them to go into winter fat and happy! I figure if I'm going to get new growth anyway it might as well be well fed new growth. Either way I'm probably going to lose the new growth over winter but at least my roses don't go into winter hungry!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I can't use dry fertilizer at all because I have a bunch of dumb free ranging chickens who like to eat it! So I only use liquid types..diluted fish fert, MG for roses, chicken and rabbit manure compost, & worm compost. The only dry stuff I put down is the alfalfa pellets and the chickens don't like them and they turn to mush soon as I water them anyways.

  • 11 years ago

    Depends on what roses you are growing. Modern roses like HTs like a lot of chemical food. Once bloomers prefer something like an annual dose of compost. Species roses don't get fed at all.


  • 11 years ago

    A gal I used to work with never fertilized her roses and brought in gorgeous bouquets all summer long. Go figure. I think roses are remarkably tolerant of many conditions. Jackie, I am in a similar climate to yours. Your method sounds nice and easy--I like it!