If Amazon is selling it for $919, I'd probably ask $600 per chair on CL, to start.

I was going to say $300 also. For a long time after it's new, it's all just used furniture, no matter what the original quality is.

All good points! I was guessing a little more than 50% off.......starting around $400.....so apparently I wasn't too far off. Thanks for the input!

CS shoppers expect to find inexpensive value. Let us know the offers and selling price.

I agree - I was thinking 200-300 each.

Interestingly, I've just stumbled on this Barcalounger ad on CL in my area. The chairs are strikingly similar to the chairs described by the OP. I would say $900 for the pair is rather steep given that the chairs look a bit worn.

There are a few more Barcalounger pieces for sale on CL in the same area: More Barcalounger Furniture . Several ads have asking prices less than $100. The chairs like the ones belonging to the OP's relatives (or perhaps they're actually the relatives' chairs!) are the highest priced in the whole bunch on CL.

On my CL, they range from 100.00 used to 300.00/each new for a Barcalounger Pegasus II (also a pair).