Software
Houzz Logo Print
bwwhite49

Wood countertops

11 years ago

Anyone have wood like walnut for their countertops? Pros and Cons please

Comments (17)

  • 11 years ago

    My parents have walnut on their island. It is beautiful. You do need to be careful of scratches. They use coasters and place mats for everything, but do have a few dings and scratches after a couple of years of use.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My DS/DIL had new walnut countertops installed when they renovated. Walnut also tops their peninsula that has bar height seating. The wood is beautiful. But they've remarked that while they would keep it for the peninsula counter top where dilligence with coasters for drinks, etc, is worth it for the look, they would never choose it again for the workspace, especially around the sink.

    Of course, they use cutting boards for chopping and spoon rests for stirring utensils. But additionally, they always keep large felt pads on the countertop while doing prep so that sliding pots/pans/utensils don't leave scratches. They are always dabbing at every drop of water or liquids that land on the wood. I'm a pretty careful cook, but I'm not comfortable helping in that kitchen. To me, it's like trying to prep on a beautiful piece of wood furniture.

    When the meal is done, the clean-up over and the felt pads are put away, it's a beautiful looking space. But there are enough other attractive alternatives that I would not choose such a fussy kitchen surface. I think a marble or soapstone countertop that has patina from use has its own charm. But IMHO, scratched or stained wood countertops - not so much.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    These responses sound like tops that have a high polish furniture finish, I think? I believe if you have an oil or Waterlox finish, less pampering will be needed.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The walnut tops don't have high polish furniture finish - think walnut floors and the care maintenance required for your floors as a primary kitchen work surface. Agree with all of amck2's comments. They use place mats instead of felt pads, but make sure most things set on the counter top are not directly on the counter top, but on the place mats.

  • 11 years ago

    I don't have walnut counters, but I use a walnut plank as a cutting board. It is finished only with mineral oil, and the scratches mostly disappear when re-oiled. If it were my countertop, I wouldn't cut directly on it, but then I wouldn't cut directly on ANY countertop. I doubt I would mind the everyday dents and dings, but that's not for everybody.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I also love the look of walnut but really want a countertop that's easy to care for. I've (almost) decided on cherry cabinets with quartz countertops and then want to "flip" the color scheme in the pantry with cabinets painted the color of the quartz (TBD) and cherry for the countertops. I'll get to enjoy the wood in there without having to worry about it so much. Also, while I'm good about using coasters, etc. I hate to play "police" with my guests. I want everyone to be relaxed and comfortable at my house.

  • 11 years ago

    This thread has always stayed with me. I don't have any walnut counters, but I sure do love walnut.

    Walnut island used as cutting board

  • 11 years ago

    Not much gets pampered around here.....I cook every day, make maple syrup, can what needs to be canned, wash the dog in the sink, etc., and I am still pleased with my choice of walnut for my counters. They are Osmo Polyx finished.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Springroz,

    Did you just use the Osmo Polyx or did you also use the epoxy sealer? I am planning on walnut for my island top and have never heard of sealing it with epoxy. Do I need to? Also, do you have any problems with water rings?

  • 11 years ago

    I think I have maple on my island. It's been done for maybe 5 mo now & I have to say that I am probably overly protective of it. I hover over people when the bring a glass near & swoop in with a coaster. If children are visiting, I usually put placemats in front of the seating. It's def a furniture-like finish, so if I did it again, I'd pick something less shiny and maybe already distressed. Here it is before the kitchen was finished.


  • 11 years ago

    We have an antique pine island and new pine on a hutch/coffee station. The island is finished with Good Stuff for Wood - I order it online. DD2 also has old pine counters, but hers is finished with a "green" product. I don't baby our counters, but do wipe up water from the sink if/when I see it.


  • 11 years ago

    Allison,

    That sounds beautiful! Any pics?

  • 11 years ago

    My sister has walnut on her baking zone -- she uses Boos on it -- and it looks great. She loves it.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Leela, Thank you for posting the thread about using the walnut countertop as a cutting board. I am planning on using walnut on my island and I like the idea of treating it with just bees wax and mineral oil.

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry to hijack --

    Meddam - was wondering if you might be able to share the source of your pendant? BTW, wood counter is lovely, I can see why you "swoop" in with coasters!

  • 11 years ago

    My walnut island top was finished with osmo polyx oil and installed 10 days ago. I absolutely love the warmth it adds to my kitchen, but I can't quite relax while using it. We have been careful with trivets and wiping up water, but I already have rings from coffee cups and water glasses, and a couple of light scratches from sliding boxes on it. The nice thing about the osmo finish is that i will be able to sand it lightly and reapply. I am just surprised that it is ready for that 10 days in!

    From this experience I can say confidently that I am not a good candidate for a wood counter near a sink.

    I wonder if I would like the Boos mystery oil finish better for repelling rings from cups and mugs. Tough to know. If anyone had experience with both the Boos and Osmo finish, I'd love to hear about it.

Sponsored
Industry Leading Kitchen & Bath Remodelers in Franklin County, Ohio