Software
Houzz Logo Print
aimless07

Doorstopper Dillema

11 years ago

We moved in about 2 weeks ago and are really happy. An issue we have is our entry and coat closet door which is on the right side of this picture. The front door opens towards the coat closet and the coat closet opens towards the door. Hubby accidentally pushed the front door open too hard and there is already a dent in that coat closet door. The traditional springy door stopper will not work in this case because there is no effective place to put it. So right now, we have installed a hinge pin door stopper on the front door hinge. It is stopping the front door handle from hitting the coat closet door, but it is starting to show some indenting on the door frame. As far as the coat closet door goes, yes, it could hit the front door, but we don't use it all that often so it isn't as big of a concern.

Are there any other doorstoppers out there that won't potentially cause more damage? We primarily enter our home through our garage but we want to make sure this is going to work okay.

Comments (24)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    If you installed a self-closer on the front door it would limit the travel.
    I have seen people attach a self-stick felt pad (used for furniture feet) to the closet knob (in this case) so when the door hits it, it's less likely to leave a mark.
    Last suggestion is to practice mindfulness and not burst through the front door like Rambo. :)
    Casey


  • 11 years ago

    maybe install a decorative metal plate where the two doors meet?


  • 11 years ago

    You could put a doorstop in the floor for the front door. Rather than having it at the far end of the door, mount a few inches from where the door is hinged. Then it won't be a tripping hazard.

    We ordered floor mounted doorstoppers for our new home. This is what our builder recommended and thought a great idea. Now it's just a matter of getting my husband to install them.

    I hate the springy things.




  • 11 years ago

    I'd echo cardinal94's suggestion.

    Our doorstops are mostly baseboard mount, with a few hinge-pin door stops where baseboard mount wasn't possible. By our front door, and mudroom door, though, we installed floor mount doorstops - and are very happy with them!

  • 11 years ago

    We have a similar situation. Right now there's a very elegant solution that involves bubble wrap and packing tape (ugh). The only options we've come up with are not great. A hinge restrictor wouldn't work on our exterior door, something about the Marvin hinges. That's the door that's more likely to "get away from us," not the closet door. I hadn't thought about the floor mount a few inches out from the hinge. I'm trying to think if that would work. Anyone have a photo or even a sketch? Are you thinking of the type like in my office that look like Half Dome in Yosemite? Or the ones that are like upright "sticks"?

  • 11 years ago

    Ours are Deltana:

    http://www.build.com/deltana-fdb278/s511939

    (We were limited in terms of style, because we needed doorstops (for our exterior doors) at least 2.5" high.)

  • 11 years ago

    "mount a few inches from where the door is hinged." Brings to mind words like "fulcrum" and "lever". I have seen such things loosen the screws from the hinges and even split door jambs where the screws are. But, there may still be a place on the floor closer to the other door that works, especially if you put a table, pedestal, or something of interest in the corner, so the door stop doesn't feel like it is in the middle of the room.

  • 11 years ago

    I don't really understand Fred's comment - or maybe he doesn't understand mine. I mean to mount the stop on the floor as intended, but not all the way at the horizontal end of the door like you might see in an office.

    Our home is fairly contemporary with clean, simple lines. There are some neat stops online in all styles. Below, the ones we got - yet to be installed


  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the examples, mommytoc and cardinal. Cardinal, who makes yours?

  • 11 years ago

    Linnea

  • 11 years ago

    A hinge pin door stopper will dent the frame because the weight of the rest of the door past the stopper provides too much leverage and torque. At least two hinge pin stoppers, if not one on every hinge should be used. If someone goes through the door like Rambo, the hinge stopper usually breaks before the door. All other door stops should be used as far away from the hinge side of the door as possible because a floor mounted door stop will not break before the door does.



  • 11 years ago

    I think you might be looking for a Hinge Pin Door Stop - it mounts to the hinge and works as a stop, preventing either door front hitting the other door.

  • 11 years ago

    Fred- Thank you for clarifying. You obviously speak with knowledge and experience. In our case, our doors are solid 96x36. It would take a lot of force (I think) to swing our doors that hard. I do think this applies to our sets of French doors that swing out on a covered porch. I can envision a gust of wind catching a door with that kind of force. We have to take into consideration an elderly parent with poor eyesight living with us and the tripping hazard outweighs other considerations.

    It seems like the original post requires a choice of a less than desirable solution.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    It would take less speed to do damage as the door grows heavier, because force increases with both mass and velocity. A slow-moving but very heavy object still has a lot of energy. In the illustration, the "bad" stop position is turning the door into a lever to bring stress to the hinges.
    Casey


  • 11 years ago

    There is no doubt Fred is right. Over time you will weaken the jamb and hinges, not to mention if anyone leans or falls on the door it can break them immediately. Your stop should be past the halfway point of your door.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Could you post a picture with the front door open?

    Could a stop be mounted to the top corner of the closet door or frame in a location that would work? That might look a little goofy, but I think that three hinge pin stops won't win any beauty contests either.

    One of the things that I am doing with most of the closets in this renovation is elevating the closet floor above the level of the baseboard and running the baseboard across the opening.

    It's a more modern detail and works best with slab doors because there is no panel detail to mess with on a slab door when you effectively shorten the door from the bottom. It clearly puts the closets is a subordinate position design wise because they are clearly not doors to walk through. But the positive aspect of this is that there is definitely a baseboard to put a stop on if there is a problem with conflicting doors.

    I think your situation would bother me enough over time that I would consider moving the closet door to the other wall adjacent to the other doorway.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Moving the door may seem extreme but you're in two weeks and you have wear and tear because of it. What about 5 years or 20 years from now?

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with palimpsest - There is flat-ish rubber doorstop you could mount at the strike-point.
    WALL DOOR STOP
    This one is stainless steel - you could paint it to match the frame.



  • 11 years ago

    Anyone used a stopper like this?

    I don't think I will want to change the actual layout and move the door.

    I really appreciate all the feedback yall have given me.

  • 11 years ago

    Are the porch light and the entry way light switches on the hinge side of the door? If so, Sophie has a point.

  • 11 years ago

    The porch light hangs over the door.


  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, I think someone ordered the wrong hinged door. You need to talk with the builder about that.

  • 11 years ago

    Anyone used a stopper like this? Yes, we have those, but only on interior doors. And they required the molding to be cut away so the top can be accommodated because it is fatter than the hinge.

0