Software
Houzz Logo Print
poppy_pa_6b

The Pilgrim - Rose Cane Blight?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

Hi,

I planted this rose bare root last spring, so this is the first winter I've had it. Could you please look at these canes and tell me what you think it is and what I should do? Yesterday when I was pruning, I thought it was some winter damage, but today I definitely think it's something more. I was hesitant to prune these hard like a HT based on all I've read about DA roses so I didn't just cut it all out initially. Sorry for the out of focus pics.

Thank you~



Comments (13)

  • 11 years ago

    Is it on the non-sun side of the canes as well?

    You do have cankers going there, but they aren't centered on leaf breaks. some of them look to have started as small spots and then spread as if they were burned by sunlight....sunburn if you will. They are active all around the damaged areas...the red color may be a reaction to ethylene gas given off by active fungi.

    I've thought that some year old canes are from genetic stock that evolved to be covered by leaves year round. when it's planted where there is leaf loss, sunburn happens. When I've seen this in my garden, mostly on modern roses (HTs and Austins), it doesn't gird the cane immediately, but the cane doesn't flourish.

  • 11 years ago

    stilanntn6b- 90% of this damage is on the sunny side. There is a small cane that looks like pic#3 on all sides(tan/black/brown- no red) and there are a few small specks of red on the non sunny side of a couple of other canes. What does one do with a rose in this condition?

  • 11 years ago

    Hmm, interesting hypothesis by Ann (Hi Ann).

    I'm not a ruthless canker-pruner, but canes with large areas of dead or infected bark need to come out--certainly cane #1. It looks like #3 is a later stage of #2, where the tan is dead or even absent bark in the wake of the canker (or burn, or whatever it is). In #1 maybe a number of those spots had linked up and killed a larger area.

    I wouldn't worry about the unpictured "small specks." These can have many causes and may be unrelated. But I would prune out the pictured canes. If this happens next year I would discard the variety as unsuited to grow as a shrub rose in my climate. Which Austin rose is it?

  • 11 years ago

    michealg- Thanks for your input. How does this happen? It's The Pilgrim, which should grow in my zone. Although with these last two freezing winters I may have lost a zone or so.

  • 11 years ago

    It may have been because the root system wasn't developed enough to be deep enough to hit liquid water. However, it is fairly common for roses to be described as hardy for a zone even if they do winterkill badly. Whether it is acceptable to *you* is a personal decision.

    Agree that the canes pictured are goners, and need to come out.


  • 11 years ago

    How did you winterize them? It's definitely from winter damage. I get this sort of thing too. I have left them from time to time to see what happens and I can tell you from experience they all die back eventually. Best to just take it off now and save the plant the trouble of trying to feed an already weakened cane.

    Don't worry, DAs will come back from the bottom, and bloom this year, just like your other roses. The only time taking all the cane off is really a problem is if you have once blooming OGRs because they only bloom on canes that are at least one year old. But any repeat blooming rose will bloom on this year's new canes. So chop away!

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks seil, That does make me feel better, although I'm bummed to have to do it. It bloomed the best of any of the new roses in my garden... until the midge showed up, but that's another issue. The other new DA's I got last year, look nothing like this. I only sprayed an anti desiccant on them and put topsoil 8-10 inches up the canes. Should I have wrapped them w/burlap too? Thanks again!

  • 11 years ago

    I was wondering if smother love was a factor. In the east, winter protection does more harm than good because winters tend to be wet. So canker gets going in the protection and kills a cane that would do just fine without it.


  • 11 years ago

    mad_gallica- Are you saying the anti desiccant caused this?

  • 11 years ago

    Poppy - even if a rose is rated hardy to our zones, it doesn't mean it's cane hardy, or even that all of the canes will be healthy ones. For instance, Teasing Georgia is rated to zone 4 or even 3 and is resolutely hardy for me. However, like a lot of Austins the canes are fairly susceptible to winter damage in my climate. They can look fine on the outside but I cut into them and they're dark brown on the inside. Both of my TGs had zero winter protection or babying of any kind, they're just not likely to hold their canes after our winters and are pruned entirely to teh ground. You won't know a thing by June or so though, as it regrows rapidly, almost as fast as you can watch.

    No telling what it is about some Austins that make them do this - The Generous Gardener is another one that's hardy but almost always damaged to the ground, yet Scepter'd Isle just needs some tip pruning. Any number of things can affect the health of an individual cane - the important thing is if the rose survives and grows happily once spring sets in.Once you get these weakened canes off, I suspect your rose will be just fine.

    Cynthia

  • 11 years ago

    Not the anti-dessicant but the 10 to 12 inches of topsoil. It gets wet, stays wet, and wet + above freezing temperatures = canker.


  • 11 years ago

    Cynthia- Thank you for sharing your experience. DA's are new in my garden, and The Pilgrim did the best of any of them in it's first summer, so I was surprised at it's appearance this spring. Ironically it's planted right next to Scepter'd Isle which did have die back but not the canker. I've since pruned The Pilgrim way back and will be happy if it just performs as it did it's first year.

    mad_gallica- The 8-10 inches of topsoil has saved my older roses from dying back to the graft. This being my first rose garden, I'm sure I could have purchased hardier roses, but I haven't had canker issues before either. I'll keep that in mind going forward. Thanks.

  • 11 years ago

    No. If the 6b PA means 6b PA, then the older roses have survived in spite of the winter protection. Been there, done that. It's a matter of playing the odds. The odds of getting a cold winter without snow cover are fairly small. You lucked out the previous winter in that we didn't get the usual ups and downs of winter weather.


Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert