Software
Houzz Logo Print
emilyrosegarden

this rose will be dead in a week - HELP

11 years ago

this is an 8yr old knockout that's been in this spot that long, yellowing started a little over a week ago at the bottom of the plant.

yellowing started about the size of a saucer, then got bigger within days and has now popped up on the other side towards the center of the rose.
hope you can see the wilting look of these leaves, infestation seems to be spreading rapidly and at this rate, will cover the entire rose within the week. Without a diagnosis from some of you experts, I'm hesitant to do anything. Please help.

Comments (34)

  • 11 years ago

    Please post several close-up pictures of the yellow/yellowing leaves.

    Jackie

  • 11 years ago

    hope this helps, Jackie. thank you so much for your response.

  • 11 years ago

    Is the plant stable? Can you rock it? Need to rule out damage to the roots.

  • 11 years ago

    Also, can you check what the canes look like on which the leaves are yellowing and wilting? Are they brown and dying back?

  • 11 years ago

    very stable, havent dug anywhere near this rose either.


  • 11 years ago

    The simple answer: The symptoms are a reaction to a distressed plant due to root damage and/or lack of water. I've seen this happen several times with potted roses.

    The less simple answer: You have a fungal issue that could be working its way up the plant.

  • 11 years ago

    small stems on wilting/dead leaves are green, cut into one of the larger stems, it looks fine. this time of year I hand-water each rose deeply so I'm puzzled it could be lack of water. if fungal issue, would it work its way up uniformly? anything I can do if fungal?


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Looks like lack of nitrogen and/or iron, it needs a balanced fertilizer:

    Diagnosing Rose Problems

    Prune the damaged growth if it bothers you.

  • 11 years ago

    I fertilized a month ago with 10-10-10, it's brand is Rainbow which says each pellet has the same formula. Getting ready to fertilize again with Milorganite. Is this program ok?


  • 11 years ago

    Going on nothing but the pictures, it looks like overwatering to me.

    Where is the rose? Is it somewhere it rains?


  • 11 years ago

    Emily - are the yellowing and wilting leaves on blind shoots (short, thin stems with just a few pairs of leaves; no flower buds)? If so, these blind shoots may just be aging and dying faster, which is normal. You can prune them off.

    And, if you have mulch right to and touching the trunk of the rose, it might be good to pull it back from the base of the plant leaving a clear ring.

  • 11 years ago

    addressing the overwatering - my entire 10 acres is on a slight downhill slope so water never stands anywhere in my yard. addressing the blind shoots, I believe they are. Will pull the mulch back also. Is my fertilization program above ok?


  • 11 years ago

    The plant seems to consist mostly of three very old canes. I would trace back from the yellowing areas to see if they are all derived from the same cane. There may be something wrong with it at the base. Take it out, voila, the plant looks fine.

    I am certain it is not any of the common mineral deficiencies. Overwatering can produce these symptoms, but you've ruled that out, and you've been growing this plant just fine for eight years. One reasonable possibility is verticillium wilt disease. If so, you may lose more canes, but the plant may be able to cure itself with an immune reaction. I have seen that happen.

  • 11 years ago

    will trace the canes and get back to the forum when I get back home. Oh, no, please dont mention the vw word, I thought the plant would surely die if that were it.


  • 11 years ago
    If I were you I would've pruned all the canes with the damaged yellow leaves to save the whole plant , do you have a concave cutter ? The ones which is used in bonsai ? If no then cut the whole stem off the main trunk and see if the rest of the rose plant still gets the yellowing..... Rack up the mulch somewhat to see if there are pests etc in the crown area..... Also don't use fertiliser right now as you've already given a balanced fert.

    Spray neem oil on the leaves to prevent any fungal infections growing in. If you don't have neem oil mix some mild soap in water and spray it on the flip side of the leaves and the front also.

    This rose will not die ..... :-)
  • 11 years ago

    love ur words, "This rose will not die". Raining right now, plan to cut off the main stem that most of the yellowing is on and will spray neem oil. will also check the crown area, will try any and all suggestions you wonderful people have!

  • 11 years ago

    Don't apply anything. It looks like Blushing Knock Out, and mine doesn't like anything on the leaves except rain.. You don't know the cause of the problem yet. The cane could be damaged, or some other mechanical problems. Also, check down to make sure the soil is damp by the roots. Even though you think you are watering deeply, there could be more running off, or being soaked into one location, and the water isn't getting down deep enough. Looking forward to hearing what you find.

  • 11 years ago

    Lot's of good advice. Especially "cutting out" the biggest part of the problem. You have a good feeding program. Over the years I've tried every combination of fertilizers you can think of. I exhibit, so I thought by using "this" or "that" I could get an advantage when show time rolled around. Last year I went back to using the Rainbow 10-10-10 mix and a little Milorganite. The only thing I add is a shovel full of Black Cow on each bush in the spring and fall and fish emulsion 2 times in the spring and 2 times in the fall. The rose's love this method of feeding. Knock Out's are pretty tough, so expect it to clear up soon.


  • 11 years ago

    Your roses are blooming. Where do you live??


  • 11 years ago

    yes, wonderful advice and everyone tries to be so helpful. I started collecting kos before the world ever heard of them and probably have 65. They have never given me any trouble until this came up. Thanks, Ken, for your comments on fertilizing. I dont exhibit, just grow roses for my own pleasure, sometimes I lose one, but I feed and water, deadhead and trim. Like you said, I have searched and searched for any 2 or 3 "experts" to give me a solid program of feeding and finally, I decided on the Rainbow 10-10-10 (only Rainbow) for my first feeding, then milorganite 6 wks later, then back to 10-10-10. In between I foliage feed with a mixture of fish emulsion and kelp at half strength. Seems to work for me. This week has been a burst of color in my rose beds instead of 1 or 2 here and there, and this sick ko was just a sight to see. I am in zone 8 in a bedroom community of Jacksonville, Fl. I like the idea of the Black Cow. Is it too late for me to do that? On our 10 acres we have a mixture of pine and oak trees so naturally, I use for mulch what nature has provided. If I add the Black Cow, can I just put on top of the mulch? May I ask what are some of your favorite roses?

  • 11 years ago

    I suggest you investigate the dying canes - cut one off and scrape back the cambium layer - is there any sign of fungal matter (white fluffy, smells yeasty?) Try to scrape away a little soil at the base of the rose and check for fungal mycelium (black, thin bootstrap bodies, white mycelium with a mushroomy smell). I thought a wilt disease was a possible contender - I certainly hope not as there is no cure and the rose will die a possibly protracted but almost certain death...although they can live for a while losing canes here and there. I am not thinking it is a deficiency or a watering issue - the inconsistency of the damage suggests disease rather than a physiological cause (such as weather etc.)


  • 11 years ago

    I was afraid you were going to say FL. You might want to do some research on Chili Thrips. They have a good strangle hold in FL. They will totally destroy the new growth and put a big hurt on any rose's they are found on.


  • 11 years ago

    "If I add the Black Cow, can I just put on top of the mulch?"

    Organic phosphorus and nitrogen cannot do any good unless they are in contact with the soil where bacteria can work on them.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is there any improvement in the rose now?

  • 11 years ago

    emily: If you are in Jax, FL you are in a zone 9a :)

  • 11 years ago

    Update - I cut out one of the main stems that had most of the yellowing leaves on it and cut out several smaller stems towards the top and inward. That was 2 days ago and have not seen any new yellowing.

    Someone suggested I scrap off the first layer of one of the affected stems, which as you can see, is brown, with this whiteish color. I cannot smell a yeast smell nor is there anything fluffy looking. I also dug around the base of the bush and all I smell is the dirt.

    For the person suggesting I check for chili thrips, I have a call into our county extension office here in Baker County, Fl, to see if they have heard of an outbreak here in Fl and specifically, this county. On my morning rounds today, I closely inspected the leaves, buds and blooms of all my roses and cannot find anything that concerns me.

    For the person responding about my growing zone, I am not in Jacksonville but 30 miles west. My zone is listed as 8a or 8b.

    I will inspect this rose everyday and let yall know. I am so grateful yall are out there and willing to help all of us who dont have the knowledge or experience you have.

  • 11 years ago

    Now the plant looks so beautiful !!

  • 11 years ago

    You're out in the woods. I know the area well. I have some friends that live in that area. I'm hoping you don't have Chili Thrips. Nasty little suckers.


  • 11 years ago

    I spoke to our local extension office and she said she knows of no serious outbreak in this county. However, I am checking every morning for deformed leaves, bud damage, etc. Speaking of the chili thrips, I searched for chili thrips in this garden forum and found an interesting post on various things to use for treatment of the chili thrips. Suggestions are varied, but there was a post that caught my attention wherein someone from the Houston Rose Society (2010) suggested an ant killer named Surrender as being effective because it contains 75% acephate and that ingredient is good for controlling the chili thrips. I use this ant killer myself and because it comes in powder form, I started out sprinkling it over the mounds but the ants just moved on to another location. Then I decided to use it in liquid form and used 1 tsp to a quart of water and put in a small spray bottle, first disturbing the mound and spraying directly on the ants. It works so much better this way and costs $14.85. Plan to use should I encounter chili thrips. Have you heard of this?


  • 11 years ago

    Never used Surrender. I had already moved out of FL. when folks started using it. When I lived in Port St. Lucie I used Orathine after Chili Thrips almost destroyed my garden. No one knew what they were or how to control them back in the early 2000's. It was trial and error. Mostly error.


  • 11 years ago

    Before you reapply, contact Dr. Malcolm Manners at Florida Southern College (Google him) and ask about the chilli thrips. He'll give you the scoop on the chilli thrips and the Surrender.

  • 11 years ago

    cant find specific into on chili thrips, can you summarize his ideas, especially on the use of Surrender. Thx.


  • 11 years ago

    UPDATE.. pics show what has happened to my beautiful knockout since my last posting. My husband had to use a power saw to cut off the main stems they were so hard, like oak. Pics show the interior of the cut off stem. Our extension agent says most wilt will show discoloration inside the stem and this did not. Note the new growth coming. We plan to keep observing and see if the remaining stem dies like the others. If it does, we will submit the plant and soil samples for testing. It's a real puzzler, wouldnt you say?