Software
Houzz Logo Print
hawkeyext

Basil Disease?

11 years ago

Hello, I'm growing Genovese Basil hydroponically in vertical towers and
they all started off great and were very perky for about a month. Over
the next month they lost their perkiness and started showing spots. Most
are transparent, which are the ones I'm concerned about. A few have
light yellow/brownish edges which make it seem like they are too close
to the light. They also have very tiny black dots on them. I am using a Apollo Horticulture 300W LED, and placing it 5
feet back. It was closer but it was burning my cilantro so I kept moving
it back. Any ideas?

Comments (9)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    hawkeyext1,

    I believe that I already have your nutrients in another
    post. I am leaning towards that way though. Judging from the other leaves that
    look a yellow, I would assume the plant roots are probably browning and not
    getting nutrient up take.

    How do the other leaves look on the other crops? I know you
    made a couple changes with the light spacing. Are the other plants bouncing
    back and these falling off?

    Sorry, I have just had a rough morning and might be a little
    loopy because of the lack of coffee so bear with me.

    Also, I noticed you have been having a host of problems. I
    would recommend segmenting out the nutrients and towers if possible. This way
    one change isn’t effecting a host of other variables.

  • 11 years ago

    Hey Jeremiah,

    A lot has happened in the past few weeks. Here's what I've gathered:

    The Basil come down with a disease. They were growing well but the disease was eating away at the leaves. I'm still researching this but if you google "basil tiny black dots" a lot of pictures come up looking like what I have. Of course it has now spread to the oregano and spinach in the towers (as well as a pepper plant in soil). When I removed them all the root structures all looked fine. It seems to just effect the leaves. There goes three months of work...

    Oregano - Did well until the disease came

    Kale - Nutrient Deficiency, typically one leaf of each plant turns yellow

    Spinach and Arugula - Not sure what to do

    Cilantro - Trying less nutrients and lower ppm

    I'm basically gutting everything and starting over. I agree about separating the plants out. Unfortunate with my limited time/money/space I cannot at the moment. Luckily I'm experimenting with all of these plants in dirt as well. I plan to expand this summer and will make sure to separate towers/reservoirs based on the plant type like you suggest.

    I'm not sure how to clean the irrigation tubes (which you brought up in another post) as they are all mounted to the stand. That is going to be a pain. When I was cleaning the reservoir out this weekend I tried increasing the pumps pressure to flush the tubes clean but it didn't help much.

  • 11 years ago

    Found out the problem. It's called "thrips".

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    hawkeyext,


    What do you do for bug or insect prevention/control?


    I use a seaweed spray that appears to have helped keeps bugs away or at bay (at least spider mites). I have heard of some other organic ways as well.


    Also, keep us posted on how the battle goes against them! I would never have thought of this.

  • 11 years ago

    Hey Jeremiah,

    I started using Neem Oil which has helped with the spider mites elsewhere, but I still have small flies and thrips. The files are just around my plants in soil, the thrips on my basil, oregano, and pepper plants (some in soil, some hydroponic).

    Since the neem oil the thrips may have lessened a bit but it's definitely not removing them. In fact, I removed all my basil with thrips and replanted (which I now read shouldn't need to be done) and the thrips came back. So today I started using a garlic spray although I'm nervous because I have peas and beans in the same area and they do not like garlic. So I may transition to an organic Safer Spray I just ordered online.

    Also, I was spraying with neem oil daily but I think it's overkill. I'm seeing brown spots on the basil which could be a fungal disease. I'm going to transition to spraying biweekly.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks. Looking forward to what you learn from your friends. It looks like most of the bugs (minus flies) have went away. I seem to be only dealing with disease now as I sprayed Neem Oil everyday for two weeks and clearly that wasn't a good idea. Live and learn... (and pray the thrips don't come back as I lesson the spray).

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    hawkeyext,

    So, I couldn’t make it out to the farms but did visit some
    great Hydro stores in the Seattle area (Sodo Hydro and Lucky Greenhouse and
    Lighting). I am hopefully going to make it out to some farms this weekend or
    next week, schedule dependent.

    In talking with the team at Sodo Hydro, they recommended
    mixing up the sprays if the pests are hard to get rid of. It sounds like you
    may have already eradicated them so this might not apply any more but this is
    still a good place for a knowledge dump.

    The products that they suggested where:

    • Organocide 3-in-1 Garden Spary
    • Captain Jacks Deadbug Brew
    • Micro-Life
      Biological Mosquito Control (BMC)

    What they stressed is during an infestation it is good to
    spray with a mix of different organic compounds. This would normally be
    achieved by using compost tea and Neem Oil outside; however, most people don’t want
    to spray compost tea around an indoor area.

    The main things outside of Neem to use during an infestation
    are Sesame Oil, Edible Fish Oil, Lemon Juice and beneficial bacteria (good luck
    if you want to mix them yourself). To my understanding the Captain Jacks adds
    bacteria to the plant that goes after insects.

    I would be cautious to anyone looking to spray plants. I
    always recommend looking up the type of plant and how it reacts to the pest
    control substance. Even though the compounds are organic, that doesn’t mean a
    plant or fruit won’t have a bad reaction to it! Also, be sure to give sometime
    between spray and harvest. I normally just do this as a precaution even though
    a lot of organic sprays are fine for human consumption (hence why we use them).

    Now the BMC was more so to go after the flies that are in
    root system. I would say that I would use this as a last resort and just try to
    cover up holes as best as possible, but they said it would do the trick to weed
    and critters out of the water system.

    I know there are a couple powders that can be used; however,
    due to the vertical nature I don’t think those would prove as usuful.

    hawkeyext thanked Humphry Davy, LLC.
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Humphry Davy. I don't think I got a notification that you responded. Very good info in there. I ended up throwing out most of my basil (unfortunately) but also started using Neem Oil as well as an Organic Safer Spray. A combination of those three things did it.

    I have a Pomegranate Tree that still has Aphids. I'll look into your suggestion to see if any of those will help and work on this new pest. Other than that everything else seems to be under control now.

    Thanks again for your help and advice.

Sponsored