How long ago did you plant them and how has your weather been?

Planted around March 15th, within 2 days of arriving. Weather has been great, almost enough rain and I've watered a bit. One of the others now has tiny leaves, but the 3rd is almost def dead and getting browner. I think I will call that good enough, for the price I paid...leaves me some room for the Black & Blue Salvia my sister got me yesterday.

If it's been warm, like 60 and above, for some time now where you are then yes, I'd say the one that hasn't leafed out is dead. Sorry. Even very good nurseries can have duds. I have a potted Peace, not even a bare root, I got from a very good local nursery that I think isn't going to make it either. It happens. Most places will replace plants that don't live within a year. If you can call them maybe they will replace it for you.

I like that Black & Blue salvia too!

It's been a lovely spring here in western Missouri, I would have been pleased with one survival from this group so two is just a bonus. I hope your Peace recovers, the ones at the rose garden are beautiful. We got a Angel Face last year that I was convinced was dead earlier this spring. Pruned it back and gave it some time and now it is looking great. I'm still working on the patience that loving roses seems to require...

If you got yours from the same place I got mine (came in green bag by regular mail) ... none of the roses I received are winners and I intend on asking for replacements of 2 or 3 out of the 4 (1 died, 1 has only bloomed once, and the two left are struggling but ok).