Software
Houzz Logo Print
poncirusguy6b452xx

Heating your house with lightbulbs

11 years ago

Has anyone thought of growing enough plants and in my case, citrus trees to generate enough heat to heat one own house. I have grown greens and citrus trees in my basement and warmed my basement to a comfortable level. I was using about 350 watts. The system worked very well and I got fresh greens every day all winter. My citrus trees quadrupled in size over winter than all summer and fall preceding. My goal is to use about 3000 watts and that should =replace my furnace, While the electric is 2x that of gas, My meter reading fee cost a little more than my gas usage and gas transportation pipe fee combined. Electric looks a lot better now

Steve

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    About 350 watts

    Steve

  • 11 years ago

    Hi Steve,

    Nomen is onto something here. If you plan to heat your whole house, you need to keep a few things in mind:

    1) You'll surely need more than 3000 W for an average two-story home in the dead of winter.
    2) Determine the efficiency of your current heater. If it's an older furnace, you may see some benefit from switching, but it's highly dependent on the efficiency of your current furnace and the price of natural gas versus electricity.
    3) Insulate well. Lighting might be able to heat a very well-insulated home, but even minor leaks will necessitate the addition of supplementary heat sources. Make sure you use high-efficiency windows!
    4) Circulate your basement air. You'll need some way of transporting your hot basement air up to your upper levels. Even though hot air rises, your top level will still be pretty chilly, so you'll need to push the hot air up there. I suspect this will be the most challenging part. You'd need to disconnect the cold air return from your furnace and attach a fun to it, sucking air from the top levels to the basement. Next, you'd have to run your furnace fan, which would take the hot air from the basement and push it up.
    5) You may need to add a few circuits to your basement to handle the load. 3000W = 25 Amps (at 120 V), which overwhelms most residential breakers (commonly rated at 15 A). I'd suggest one line per 1000 W ballast.

    If you take this route, I would replace the CFLs with some sort of high-intensity discharge lamp like high pressure sodium or metal halide, both which would require expensive ballasts and fixtures (though you can get kits for $200-300 each). This has the effect of concentrating the heat in a small area, making it easier for your furnace intake to distribute--so extend your furnace intake to near the ceiling and by the lights. Again, the most challenging part would be keeping your upper levels warm.

    It's an interesting venture. You'd definitely be able to grow a ton of plants in your basement and put the excess heat to use, but I don't know how well it would work in a stand-alone house.

    -Tom


  • 11 years ago

    Hi Tom an Nomen

    My walls are insulated to R-40 and my attic is insulated to R-80. I also have 16 inches deep potting soil covering the 1000 SQFT roof top. every fall I add 2 feet of bagged leaves that stay dry until next spring when I open them. As it stands now I only heat my basement and let the heat rise through vents and grates. The second floor is heated by the same heat rises principle. I control the 1st floor temperature by closing vents and doors. I keep that temperature around 65F. An out door temperature of 0F I will have a 5 degree drop to the 2nd floor. I have inherited one metal halide at 1000 watts and I have grow boxes of another 1500 watts capacity. I will see what happens next winter.

    It will still cost more than the total gas cost but the produce will mare than pay for the extra costs by a wide margin.

    Steve

  • 11 years ago

    Excellent! I look forward to hearing how this turns out! Just make sure you have more than one circuit you can tap into in your basement.

    -Tom

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My 1000w over citrus did not produce 1 fruit. But they are young trees. It costs me about 50 a month to run it. I will never break even.

    When you say the produce will more than make up I hope you mean lettuce, tomatoes, and others.

    Also there is no reason to need a heat bank. Simply run 1/2 of the light on 1/2 the plants for 12 hours then switch. Let's use the metal halide as an example. One ballast wired with a single pole double throw relay on the black out line can run 2 bulbs, each in their own room. One half the day and the other the other half. Id make it myself but they sell these pre made. It's called a flip box. The 2 reflector white lines and the ballast white should be wire nutted together. Same with the 3 green wires.

  • 11 years ago

    One ballast for 2 bulbs. Great idea since I only have the ballast and bulb without the housing.

    I get a $420 a year meter reading and billing charge. That is only if I use no gas. My total gas usage and gas transportation through pipes charge are slightly less than the meter charge. Only 75% of that gas used is for heating. The rest goes for hot water and cooking so it looks a lot more promising to heat with lights. If I grow greens I will get a lot of organic food for the watt. If I grow fruit I will not get my moneys worth or even come close. You are best growing those under sunlight. Since we only eat organic greens we save a fantastic amount of money. My furnace is 22 years old and acts like it, At 3000 per furnace and they only last 20 year that's a lot of money saved. I need one more 1000 watt ballast and I have the CFL bank already. I don't have to drive to the grocery store but 1 out of 4 times.

    The key here is will my wife allow me to turn off the gas and go electric. She will tell you the facts are, you can not cook with an electric stove. If the gas does not turn off I will get a $420 annual meter charge. That is a no go.

    Steve

  • 11 years ago

    Can't cook in an electric? More like won't. I like my electric range. Just takes a short period of time to get used to it.

  • 11 years ago

    I do know that my electric range isn't great for brewing beer!


  • 11 years ago

    I would add a Calamondin to your collection. The one I have has stayed small through the years, maybe 4 feet tall and 3 feet wide. It seems to prefer less than full sun and does just fine in a large pot. The bonus is that it has fruit on it almost year round. The juice is sour with a hint of tangerine or kumquat tang to it but I love having it within arm's reach when I cook. Most of the rest of the citrus collection produces over long periods also but they all want to be big trees whereas the Calamondin requires very little pruning.

  • 11 years ago

    If you're using an HID spectrum bulb you'll be generating a lot of heat. Both metal halide and sodium run hot but I think metal halide is even hotter. I'm assuming you'll be running with heavy fans. Which will dissipate that hit someone bought I'm not sure if you'd be able to generate enough to replace the furnace. I guess it would depend on how far north you were and how cold it was outside. And insulation exposed. Throw some solar panels up for insurance.

  • 11 years ago

    If I dig up my 16 foot X 16 foot dirt basement floor I can replace my gas furnace. The annual meter fee before any gas is used is $420 per year My annual heating cost runs between$200-$400 for the gas and the pipeline fees combined. To heat my house electricity would cost between $400-$800 / year. On a rough winter my light would run a hair cheaper than my furnace. On a mild winter my electric bulb heating would be cheaper than the annual meter fee just by itself.

    Mos of you probably live in cities where the politicians aren't so corrupt. I am not so lucky. This keeps the gas rate low so that the 4000 SQfT home owners pay a set meter fee and get tremendous amount gas at a subsidized rate while us with small home make up the loss with gouging meter fees.

    If you heat with propane