Software
Houzz Logo Print
drballard33

Granite countertop help

11 years ago
My wife and I are doing a kitchen "facelift" painting cabinets, replacing laminate countertops with granite, new paint and stainless appliances. We are stuck on granite. We have been shopping for months and have visited a dozen places and have narrowed it down to a couple choices but are worried about how it will look with our floor tile. One choice is Giallo Ornamental. Here is a pick of a small sample against our floor tile. I know this isn't the best way to visualize
it. We plan on taking an extra floor tile to the granite store this week. The cabinets are pickled maple (yuck) and will be painted white (SW Snow Bound). Thoughts? I

Comments (44)

  • 11 years ago
    Your tile and granite both have a considerable amount of movement in them. I prefer to see one or the other not both. That way they don't compete. I also see quite a bit of pink in your tile on my display that is not present on your small granite sample. What about a more neutral beige tile?
  • 11 years ago
    Well we already have the tile installed (bought the house with it and don't have the budget to replace it. Hoping to match the granite to the tile. Here is a pic of my whole kitchen, please don't mind the mess (my wife would kill me if she knew I posted a pic of the kitchen this way but she is not home and I'm cooking dinner for two hungry young boys).
  • 11 years ago

    I think it's a really good idea to bring a sample of your floor tile when you shop for granite. I agree with the above suggestion that you should stay away with a countertop that has lots of movement but not crazy about the beige counters you have now...the color, that it. Since you are going with white cabinets, you may consider a dark granite for some contrast...unless you are planning to change the floors in the near future.


    Kitchen remodel · More Info


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's really hard to tell when they are so close together...they may work further apart. I would say that the granite has greys/brown and floor tile is more pink. The picture below reflects granite/floors that both reflect the pinkish color - if you like that look. But my suggestion would be to go with the granite but consider a porceline tile (that looks like wood) - if you haven't already purchased the tile and you could lay in a herringbone pattern. I feel less busy tile works better with granite in general. God luck in your decisions..it is difficult.

    HIA 2012 Award Winner · More Info

    Contemporary Kitchen · More Info

  • 11 years ago
    Thanks everyone! The tile shows pink but I think it's the warm lighting which I am hoping to replacing with a cooler color. The tile has lots of grey in it too. The cabinets are god awful which is why we are painting them. The granite we originally wanted was very neutral with greys, creams, etc as you can see ok the pic but they got sold right before we made the decision.
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I think putting the granite sample close to the tile is not the way to visualize the space. The tile and counter are going to be spaced apart by the cabinets and I think this combo would work. Giallo O is a very common and beautiful granite that has some garnet flecks in it. This should work nicely with the pink undertones of your tile.

  • 11 years ago
    Thank you! I kind of agree with you on keeping the granite away from the tile when trying to visualize it. I plan on taking a large sample of the cabinet paint with me and the tile sample and see how the cabinet paint may create a transition between the tile and granite.
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We used Giallo Ornamental granite in our house in Georgia. I loved it. Beautiful and easy cleanup…unlike my darker granite now.

  • 11 years ago

    Agree drballard33 to bring the tile when shopping for granite. It doesn't have to match perfectly, but please make sure the 2 compliment one another. We made the mistake of not doing that several years ago when renovating our kitchen. We have a similar ceramic floor tile like yours (has lots of movement/yellows and oranges in it depending on the light) but will not have to eventurally change it bc it really doesn't work with the new quartzite counter and backsplash. Planning to do that soon. Renovating a kitchen is a process! Good luck.

  • 11 years ago

    Reconsider the granite countertop and look at a quartz product - the movement will be less. the cost will be less as well.

  • 11 years ago
    While I agree Quartz is a great option, many times it can cost more than granite.
  • 11 years ago
    Thanks all for your help...tomorrow my wife is going to take the floor tile to a few granite places for a second look at their selection and matchup. Hopefully we come home with a winner.
  • 11 years ago

    I like the idea of quartz too.

  • 11 years ago
    Quartz is great, I work in hospital food service and it's all we go with due to their ease of cleaning, no need to seal etc...but I have found them to be more expensive than granite, unless you compare it to the rarer granites.
  • 11 years ago

    Quartz is typically more expensive than granite unless you are at the high end granite. I had those ugly cabinets and painted them white and ended up going with a very dark granite (almost black) that looks stunning due to the contrast and it didn't have movement. I don't know how this will look with the tile though but please consider it as visually when you look at the kitchen the white cabinets and dark counter stands out more than anything. Also white cabinets with a nice white quartz looks really amazing as well. I think that combo may go better with your floors than anything. Like everyone said, try not to get a granite with too much movement.

  • 11 years ago
    Thanks for that info...I really like the idea of lighter countertops, especially Quartz...anyone have any pictures of a lighter Quartz that would go well with white cabinets?
  • 11 years ago

    Check out link above for the white quartz and white cabinets

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Consider a pebble pattern rather than a vein pattern in quartz or granite to contrast your tile floor.


  • 11 years ago
    I think a darker brown would look better. Just redid my kitchen know what u r going thru! Good luck!
  • 11 years ago

    OK, went to the granite place today with a floor tile sample and narrowed it down to two choices. The darker slab is a new one they just had delivered and they call it Amber Cloud (although there isn't tons of amber in it, its mostly grey, cream, with some "amberish" brown which I think would work well with the tile. the lighter one is the Giallo Ornamental that we originally liked but its a different lot so it has less vein's and more speckled. What are everyone's

    thoughts on the two? Keep in mind we were going to paint our cabinets either white, or possibly an off white and the wall color is still up in the air but most likely either a light grey or a khaki-light brown color.


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Folks are saying that Giallo Ornamental has movement in it and it really doesn't. It really is a plain granite and would go nicely with your colors. We have used it on white cabinets and on slightly off white cabinets. It is not a strong color and has no overpowering movement so it really just blends with other things around it. You also want to make sure you use a very neutral backsplash to keep it all pulled together. I vote for the Giallo Ornamental. The other is too busy and will be too dark.

  • 11 years ago

    I like the first of the two new ones with the floor. But, just not sure white cabinets will work well with those warm colors. Some light color paint for the cabinets could work, but not sure about white.

  • 11 years ago

    Go for Amber Cloud the one with the "lines" in it. Consider chantilly lace from benjamin moore for the cabinet colour and with either black or rubbed bronze hardware.

  • 11 years ago

    Two great kitchen colours for cabinets in the link. I personally think the lowers with a dark colour and the uppers in white would be stunning.


    http://www.tonischeferdesign.com/2014/05/18/top-4-benjamin-moore-whites/

  • 11 years ago

    Would you consider a cabinet color sort of like White Down in the link lorewren posted? I think a warmer white like that would be beautiful with you floors and possible counter choices.

  • 11 years ago
    Yes I would definitely consider a warmer color cabinet paint. We are planning on doing the granite first then base the paint on how the granite looks with the lighting we have. So it sounds like a lot are leaning towards the amber Cloud?
  • 11 years ago
    Does anyone know another name for the Amber cloud? I am trying to get some design ideas and a Google search shows nothing. Which is strange.
  • 11 years ago

    Me too, can't find a thing about Amber Cloud granite. Must go by another name too.

  • 11 years ago
    I was thinking something with dark base color like tropical brown or something like it with specks
  • 11 years ago

    I would go with quartz in white or a marble color & if you can't afford the quartz for everything, use butcher block on the island. You won't be sorry you went with quartz. No or less maintenance.

  • 11 years ago
    I'm a little late to this discussion but wanted to say that the pic posted by Karen D above is exactly what I pictured when I saw your kitchen. I love the look of the darker countertop. It's a much fresher up to date look.
  • 11 years ago
    Well Granite is getting installed as I type. We went with the Amber Cloud and I'm glad we did. It matches perfectly with the floor tile yet isn't too busy. Next is having the cabinets painted as well as that horrible ugly green wall paint.
  • 11 years ago

    I think granite has had its run. It's virtually everywhere these days, and unless you choose a rare, expensive type with pronounced color, you're going to end up with just another granite countertop. I like the Cesarstone-type materials, and there are some great, punchy colors. Some of my favorites are the recycled glass surfaces. They're "greener" than granite. And even Corian has some nice finishes now, and you can get an integrated, seamless sink, and it wont damage your knives.


  • 11 years ago
    @keenplanner, I don't think granite is trending out of style. It comes in an almost infinite variety of colors and patterns, and a seemingly endless variety of price points as well. The problem is that people get stuck using the same one from the big box store, and there is a strong sense of "been there, done that " as yet another homeowner puts in the same stone. A few dollars more spent at a reputable stone yard can yield beautiful and different results.
  • 11 years ago
    Granite is still in the top 5 of things new home buyers are looking for. When we considered doing a lot of things to our house we spoke with our real estate agent and he said out of all of them granite is a must.
  • 11 years ago

    Oh, my gosh, that's pretty! Can't see much of the floor with the granite in the pic, but it's nice? That choice was my favorite!

  • 11 years ago

    Agree, the granite you chose is perfect and looks great with your floors. Your kitchen is going to be beautiful. Post pictures after you have finished painting the cabinets and walls.

  • 11 years ago
    Don't try and match. Should be contrast. With white cabinets you can do anything. You didn't say what your style is. That would determine your look in granite.
  • 11 years ago
    Yeah floors are busy. Counter should not.
  • 11 years ago
    I would go a lighter background, with more great from floors in it.
  • 11 years ago
    Meant more gray.
  • 11 years ago

    Granite has already been installed.

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars5 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio