Software
Houzz Logo Print
koffman99

Your ideal Hosta soil ?

11 years ago

Since I am starting a hosta bed in the back of my house now I wanted to get the boards opinion on their ideal hosta soil. I know it is somewhat dependent on the type of soil you have already as to what would need to be added. But basically what would be the perfect combination ? Tell me what you have done or what you would do if you could. Look forward to hearing some of your responses. Thanks !

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    the trees above.. are more important than soil ...

    i would never waste money.. amending an entire bed ...

    IF THAT IS WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT ... not quite sure what you are meaning.. with your premise ...

    try again???

    ken


  • 11 years ago

    I'm not sure how much clearer I can be. I am STARTING a hosta bed in my back yard. What could I add to the soil that would make it ideal for the Hostas I am going to plant there ? I am planning on tilling the current soil which consists of several inches of leaf compost, underneath that I would start to run into red clay(which isn't a quick draining soil). I was thinking of adding some sand and or pea gravel to help drainage along with some manure and humus. Would like to hear what other board members have done to make an ideal hosta planting soil environment ?

  • 11 years ago

    I am not a soil expert but we have sandy soil and always add cow manure to any new garden we make. We also add manure when planting a new hosta in an existing bed. Results have been successful for us.

    Vanessa

    koffman99 thanked TheHostaCottage
  • 11 years ago

    I have predominantly red clay. I don't amend my whole garden, I usually dig my hole about twice the size of the pot it's coming out of, and mix some hardwood mulch in with the soil, watering in really well with cow manure tea before I replace soil mixture.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the ideas and suggestions. The area I am considering is about 10 x 10 more or less. Like I mentioned I am planning on tilling in manure (for nitrogen & fertilizer), Some kind of amendment to improve drainage (possibly pea gravel, vermiculite, or diatomaceous earth, which should also help keep voles out, and possibly some peat moss.

  • 11 years ago

    Bungalow,

    That looks like a great area even without anything planted there. I haven't heard of Mushroom compost before will have to check that one out.

  • 11 years ago

    Most excellent question, koffman.

    And you got cranky guy to shout at you! Nice.

    Irony, my interest in proper hosta soil was spurred by cranky guy's disapproval last week of the soil in my new greatest hosta planter ever. And excellent response, BungalowMonkeys; funny AND good advice.

    We deal with the hand we are dealt. My 4 large mature Norway maples shading my house and garden ARE NOT going anywhere. Leaving my only option dealing with the soil I was dealt.

    koffman99 thanked gardencool
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a confession - I have never amended my soil with anything or even fertilized my hostas. My property is one big hill sloping down northwards. My awful neighbor on one side (and uphill from me) seems to hate any kind of ground cover, even grass. So when it rains a sandy flood happens on my property. This spring I did have to go excavate some emerging hostas when they started to get buried in deep sand after a heavy rainfall. I tried to remedy that with some big rocks. This neighbor also leaf blows his TRASH under the fence and onto my property. What a horrid human being.

    When I plant a hosta I dig a hole and not much more except to get rid of a circle of grass or whatever weeds were nearby. Some parts of my yard are a light soil. Some is packed hard dirt...out of curiosity I planted a sagae in the toughest packed area and it seems to love the spot. Maybe it's one of those that likes tight roots. Who knows.

    Maple roots, between water sucking birches, a big bed under black walnuts, oaks, open and hot sun almost all day. Some areas are very sandy. Maybe I'm just lucky and have good soil. This is Iowa after all. Maybe we're a little dirt proud here. ;)

    The only one I've lost was Great Expectations in a pot, but given the nature of GE and my impatience for potted things, I'm not surprised at that one

    I know what I'm supposed to do with the whole expensive hole for the cheap plant ideal. But...I just don't. So I really admire people who take the time to till and prepare beds and new spots for their hostas.

  • 11 years ago

    Post your question on the soils and compost forum. They're very helpful and love talking about dirt. A lot.

    Kathy

    koffman99 thanked zkathy z7a NC
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you Koffman99. It's been a fun project. When it is done I'll be posting more photos of it. That bed is one of 12 new ones we put in. So excited to get them filled in and watch them grow.

    Gardenfool, I don't get on this forum like I used to, but will find that post. Would like to read about your dilemma. Been in a lot of forums lately, multitude of subjects and there is always that "one" person. The knowledgeable "one", tendency to make you laugh sometimes and other times have you wishing you could crack the keyboard over their head. Ken is our "one", a hosta loving snarkster.

  • 11 years ago

    Look up "double digging". It's especially helpful with heavy clay soil.
    bk