Software
Houzz Logo Print
joshing

Different flooring for different rooms?

11 years ago

Will it look awkward and mixed up if I use different flooring for different rooms?

This is for a two story townhome that I used to live in but now use it as a rental. On the first story, I have large tiles as the flooring in the kitchen and the adjoining dining room:



Then, you step down a few stairs from the dining room to the living room:



Right now, there's carpet in this living room but there's a big tear in it and I will replace it with either hardwood or vinyl planks that look like hardwood.

Then, you take the stairs from the dining room to the 2nd story where you basically have a carpeted hallway and two carpeted bedrooms.

I'm considering a couple of options and I'd appreciate some feedback about which one you think is the best option:

1) Just change the living room flooring, and keep the carpeting upstairs.

If I did that, I would avoid the cost of replacing the carpeting upstairs while its still viable. But, I'd be delaying the inevitable because I'd probably have to change the carpet whenever the new tenant moved out.

2) Change the living room flooring, the stairs, and hallway to same flooring- wood or vinyl plank. But, keep the carpeting in the bedrooms.

If I did this, I would be changing the more trafficked areas in the stairs and hallway from vulnerable carpet to a hardier substance. But, I'm afraid it would look strange to see woodish stairs and hallway leading to carpeted bedrooms when they're all on the same floor.

3) Change the living room flooring, the stairs, and the upstairs bedrooms to the same flooring, either wood or vinyl.

Carpeting has traditionally been the most popular flooring for the bedrooms, but I kind of suspect that more and more people now want wood look in the bedrooms too.

Some of the vinyl planks I'm looking at come in different sizes so I was thinking I would use larger planks in the large living room downstairs and then smaller planks in the 2 bedrooms.

4) Assuming I got vinyl, change the living room, stairs, upstairs bedrooms, and upstairs bathrooms to all vinyl planks. I've heard that vinyl is a good choice for the wet environment of the kitchens so I figure it should be a good choice for the wetter bathrooms.

I was going to try to find the most realistic vinyl possible. But, if I put in in the bathroom too, then people would know right away that it wasn't real wood even though it looked real.

Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    For a rental, I'd do only what I had to do and leave the rest to change when it had to be done. I don't have any problem with different flooring in different rooms, esp bedrooms.

  • 11 years ago

    I actually think with the photo you posted different floorings would look great in that space. Have you considered wood looking tile? I've seen some priced very reasonably at Home Depot and it looks beautiful installed. I agree that you want to do the minimum necessary however by putting some money into the floor now (with a wood look tile) will save you down the line as it will hold much better over time and I doubt it will ever look dated.


  • 11 years ago

    I'm reluctant to go with the wood tiles in that living room space because I already have tile in the kitchen and dining room. It seems like it'd be too much tile and I think people want something softer in their living rooms. If I had to do it all again, I would definitely have gone with tiles that look like wood in the dining room and kitchen rather than the tiles I have right now.

    If this was Florida, I could get away with all that tile. But, I don't see that much tile in Southern California.


  • 11 years ago

    At first, I was thinking of doing what Annie suggested.

    But, I was thinking that I should change everything now what I would need to change anyways in a year or two because I could probably get a better price now if I bought and installed all the flooring now rather than separately.

    Plus, it would shorten the turnover time the next time around because I wouldn't need to buy, wait for the materials(flooring company said it takes 2 weeks to order their vinyl), and installation.

    If I wait to show a place before its ready and updated, then it means that I wouldn't be able to show the place while it was still occupied and would need to wait for new tenant to move out before I could do installation for upstairs.

  • 11 years ago

    Because it's a rental I would do vinyl (or whatever material you decide) in the living room, stairs and hall..as you said, the high traffic areas. I would leave carpet in the bedrooms..I would not want a vinyl floor in the bedroom. If carpet is only in the bedrooms, it is easily changed out when necessary, even using remnants...and they don't have to all be the same carpet or color. For any upstairs baths I would use tile, not the vinyl used elsewhere.

  • 11 years ago

    Different rooms are used for different purposes, and different flooring is better suited to different purposes. I think it's completely appropriate to have different flooring throughout the house.

    Also, if you're going for a faux wood, you can't put it on the stairs. The trim pieces needed to finish the edges of the faux wood is always the number one tip off that the wood is not real. And real wood on stairs is expensive.

  • 11 years ago

    I have never been a landlord so I'm not much help on the economics here. But I have been a tenant and carpet anywhere is a huge turn off for me. Three of the four members of our family have dust mite allergies and carpet in the bedroom is particularly bad for that. We have really prioritized hardwood in our choices of where to rent. (Never came across vinyl or tile in bedrooms). I guess you could try to look at your competition and see what kind of flooring is out there--might you get a higher price or a longer duration tenant or faster re-renting if you upgrade the flooring?

  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, California has a different vibe than Florida, you could do laminate. My mom and sister who both live in Southern California used it in their homes and love it. It's really durable, easy to clean and it has more appeal than vinyl.

  • 11 years ago

    What's the giveaway with the trim pieces for faux wood on the stairs? I've never heard of that before.

    If real wood is so expensive to do on stairs, is that why stair treads are so popular right now because you're using half the wood with only the tread while you just need to paint the riser?


  • 11 years ago

    So, if I went with carpet on the stairs, then I should probably go carpet in the hall way too as well as carpet in the bedrooms?

    Otherwise, wouldn't it be weird to see carpet in the stairs, then wood or vinyl planks in the hall way on the second floor leading to carpeted bedrooms?

  • 11 years ago

    And I have wood everywhere, and carpet on the stairs. Some people don't like wood stairs because they find them slippery. For me, it was just cheapness.

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21