Yes, too matchy..

that would be too much. Do something different.

Yes too matchy. Have you ordered the sectional yet? Please make sure it is going to fit in your space with ample room for traffic patterns and we don't see it as a design dilemma on this site! Usually a sofa and two chairs is a much more livable arrangement. You are going to be stuck for many years with this sectional that can't be arranged in any different ways.

Thank you all so much! I'll start shopping for a fun ottoman to change things up a little. I have 3 kids under 4 and the sectional is definitely the best option for us!

Agree with the others so yes go for something complementary but different....maybe in a round to break up all of the angular/square lines. And I'd probably also look for something not tufted.

Also, something with a more open base and/or with legs.

Try this one, has storage and tops reverse

Not sure what size you need, but these are just some ideas for ottoman styles. They all don't fit all the features I mentioned above but most below do and I think any of these could work.

PS These are for general style ideas only...not necessarily fabric/leather color.

Your room is nice and open and large! Love the brick wall.
An ottoman will look great!

Thanks everyone! That's just the stock photo from Macy's, lol - not my house!

The sectional is very large, just make sure it doesn't engulf your space.

How big is your space? I'm looking to buy the same sectional! Love it! :-D

I, too, was just thinking about the ottoman...a different one would be nice! I think I might try round...