Clay pots are not the best as the new roots cling to the pot and break off when you transplant. But I would go ahead and move it to a plastic pot now.

Thanks, Dave!! I will move both today!!

Dave, One of the plumerias I transplanted has leaves that are curling under. I am watering with SuperThrive but transplanting it did not make it happy. Will it die or recover do you think?

Depends on the damage. I have no idea. Did you damage the roots in the process? I'd def. move it to part shade if you haven't already.

Didn't seem to. I was very careful. The good news is that the leaves have bounced back almost to normal. It rained last night and has been overcast which made me worry about too much moisture but I guess that one wanted it. Thanks so much for your help, Dave!