Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_1333051

Fixing newbie mistakes

11 years ago

This townhouse is our first owned home with outdoor space for gardens. Not much, just narrow border gardens around our front and back patios and along our walkway. We moved in in 2012 and the place had only dirt with a few weeds in the rock hard dried out soil. I merrily spent money and backbreaking hours digging compost into the soil, removing weeds and finally planting with low water use perennials (we are in the San Francisco bay area).


Along our walkway I planted bush germander, pinata lavenders, russian sage and some blue spire salvia. The germanders were labeled to reach 2-3' tall and wide, but I have since learned that they naturally reach 4-5' tall and wide.


Since then, things have grown a lot, and I've had to remove 2 of the lavenders because we got a frost in winter that damaged them and then they never really recovered, I tried to prune off the damaged areas but some of them were beyond repair. Too bad, they were pretty - but they did get too wide for the space and needed a lot of pruning.


I love the germanders as plants - their silvery foliage and pretty blue purple flowers, their hardiness etc, But they really are big for this area.


I don't necessarily like a super tidy look, I love plants that appear blurred into eachother and was very happy with the color pallet and appearance of the garden a year or 2 ago.


So right now, this is the walkway to our front door, flanked by the fence and the carport on either side - it doesn't look very good. There are huge spaces left by the removal of the lavenders, made more apparent by the giant germanders dominating the space. I'm afraid it might look better if I just removed them and found plants more appropriately sized, but I would really hate to destroy these plants and there is no other space for them even if I could transplant these established perennials which likely have giant root systems. But, I really don't think it looks attractive to have "walls" of hedge along either side of the walkway - even when I prune them back then the germanders lose their airy natural structure and become a messy hedge.

Can I salvage anything of this overgrown mess, or should I dig up the overgrown plants and start over? What low water use full sun/heat tolerant and appropriately-sized plants could I use here? My tastes are for the blue-purple pallet, love silvery foliage.

In 2012 when first planted (oh how naive I was!)

In 2013-14 when I think everything looked perfect!


and... now.


Comments (12)

  • 11 years ago

    Your best bet for plant choices are good local nurseries.

  • 11 years ago

    I suggest you research Caryopteris and Hebe. There is a small Artemisia, Silver Mound that you might like, I have also read that the Germander can be cut back hard, to six inches. If you could live with doing that every other year they may stay at the attractive size.

    User thanked emmarene9
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    You should use some different kind of plants which makes your garden bit different and colourful.

    From last 2 images looks like bushes that didn't look good.


  • 11 years ago

    I love your plant choices! Beautiful combination and great for Northern California. I wish I had a plant suggestion for you. We are looking at ceanothus maritimus valley violet, but I haven't grown it and I'm not sure if it would also get too big for your space. The annies annuals website is a source of information for me--they have a plant finder tool. Maybe you would find an idea there? Perhaps the california gardening forum on here would be able to make a suggestion.


    But I agree that it is worth a try just cutting them all the way down and see how long it takes to regenerate. If it is fast enough maybe you could do it every couple of years to control the size?

    User thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I love those bush germanders, but agree they have gotten way huge. I think they all need to come out unless you want to whack them back into shape regularly.

    Swap them out for lamb's ears -- Stachys byzantina -- silver foliage, purplish flowers, perfect for small spaces and low water.

    User thanked melle_sacto is hot and dry in CA Zone 9/
  • 11 years ago

    I wonder if we are missing an issue which is not horticultural but the emphasis of the design. The purpose of the path is to get to the doorway. The door way should say "Welcome" and "Enter here". So first, you might consider painting the doorway accordingly. Then a beautiful big pot that plays off the door color and gives you something to work off of for the rest of the planting. You could google "Narrow Entryways" and look at photos of New Orleans French Quarter entries,many of which are in narrow alleyways.

    I hate discarding plants that thrive, but I don't see the point of spending the time clipping back germander and plants that want to fulfill their genetic destiny of growing big and billowing. Your time is money and even if they cost you $15 bucks each. Just not worth it and you know the outcome: they will just keep growing (unless they die.), you've spent a gardening season learning what you already learned the first time.

    Your entryway just can't accomodate that volume. You don't want to add to sense of enclosure to the point of suffocation. I'd consider delicate vines whose tracery the walls enhance. The leaf and form more important than color. Add color low to the ground.

    Find some inexpensive relatively 'flat' garden art for the walls....or beautiful expensive wall sculptures if you can afford it. Check out TJ Maxx, HOmegoods for some bargains you'll enjoy for a few seasons and won't feel bad about getting rid of later.

    Keep billowy or full plants below knee level so pedestrians' eyes and limbs won't get scratched and so you can carry a bundle of groceries without a fight.

    And emphasize the door....that's the point of the path!

    User thanked Marie Tulin Boston burbs z 6a
  • 11 years ago

    By the way, caryopteris really smells bad when you brush against it. I wouldn't have it in a narrow place. It's a repellent, not a welcome. You could try one of the smaller nepetas....not Walker's Low which may be low but not small. (Low doesn't refer to its size anyway) There's smaller versions which smell heavenly...pepperminty. Come to think of it, maybe the emphasis could be plants that smell good....some scented geraniums against the boards that you could pause and enjoy on your way in...

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks all - it sounds like the main consensus is that I'll have to start over with this walkway. I feel guilty ripping up thriving plants! I have tried hacking them back, though not to 6" that would be a lot of work since they have hundreds of stems... but I did that with the lavenders and as you can see the remaining one did not do well with that much cut-back, it started yellowing and withering... I already removed the other one that looked worse.


    atmoscat, yes I think the fact that this is the perfect climate for the bush germander means that the plants outgrew their promised size. And this is AFTER just a few weeks ago I took the hedge shears to them. When it rains in winter the gigantic lavenders were bowing down and wetting our legs - had to hack them back. I have to hack them back every week filling my compost bin!


    So if I mostly start from scratch, what type of plan do you think would look good? I know I can look for specific plant suggestions on the CA forum, my local nursery (except do my own research on the expected final size of the plants this time!) but I posted here because I need some guidance on how to envision the plants as they grow and how to plan the spacing and heights. I was going for a pretty symmetrical look as you can see from the first attempt. Can you envision other options? Do I have room for a taller row of plants at the back and shorter in front? As you can see I tried a sort of staggered plan with the russian sages (which became completely choked out by the germanders and lavenders) and the lavenders, I just had no concept of how some of the plants would thrive and some did not do so well with the intense heat (those purple buttons for example).


    I can't paint anything on the exterior, it's a condo and the HOA does the exterior paint. Some home have dark green doors to match the green trim, the only other color option, but the dark green looks less welcoming back in the alcove, the cream color at least doesn't end up looking like a black hole. The design of the entryway is not the most welcoming, but on the other hand gives us privacy - a rare thing in a condo in an area where the land value is extremely high. The concrete has seen better days, too but again - belongs to the HOA technically though we may see if we can have it refinished and sealed.


    Marie, I can't grow vines on the walls or fence because of the HOA - they would need them removed to paint, can damage the walls and fence, can't have them grow over the top or onto the neighbor's side and vines tend to get very out of control where I live - they grow very vigorously and I'd have to trim weekly or they'd swallow up the house! I did consider running some chains or wires down the pathway and growing grape vines or something, but I'm not sure how that would look - thoughts?


    There is also an A/C unit to the left of the door we had installed last summer, I am trying to disguise with the pots and the reed screen I built there in the second photo up- it was the only place it could be installed so I love having A/C in the hot summer days but I hate the look of the box in the corner.


    Nice smell is a plus - I love the lavender smell, perhaps there are some varieties that will stay smaller/more upright? I actually hate the smell of geraniums! I removed that lantana because it smelled bad when brushed up against too. The germanders smell nice, herbal. Maybe I can put them free on craigslist and find them a new home rather than throw them in the compost bin.


    Thanks for all the ideas! I think I'll have to be patient and wait for end of Sept to do this, because I have a vacation coming up mid Sept and I don't want to have to have the petsitter watering plants. These are so established they barely need any water at all. I'll just have to hack them back until then, but I can draw up some plans.





  • 11 years ago

    Congratulations on your first garden -- it looked great for a while. I suggest you turn to slow-growing plants. Look into succulents to mix with your lavenders. There are many colorful and elegant succulents in the same colors you have been using, but they will not outgrow the space so quickly. Not by a long shot. They are low water use, and when combined with careful thought and planning, can be as elegant or whimsical as any cottage garden. Hummingbirds love them, too. Don't feel bad about pulling out overgrown shrubs. Gardens grow and change, and removal and renewal is part of the process; you just want to slow it down for this small garden space.

    User thanked Kim in PL (SoCal zone 10/Sunset 24)
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Now I don't know if I can wait 6 weeks or more to get started, looking back at pictures from when it looked so good, I just want to have it looking better again I hadn't realized how really awful it had started to look! Here's the entryway with the same pots etc but before the jungle took over... I think it looked reasonably welcoming. We are planning a renovation next year and will replace the lamp by the door, and if we can get HOA permission we will replace the 2 on the carport as well. The awning on the upstairs window was replaced with a Sundowner that doesn't sag like that one did. I'm not sure why it keeps making a thumbnail of my photo, click for the full view.

  • 7 years ago

    I know this is an old post but, this area would have been great as an herb garden.