Software
Houzz Logo Print
merlena87

Planting container roses

11 years ago

A friend of mine showed me some pictures of her landscape today. She has a few roses, not many though, but they seem to be doing good. She has two Mister Lincolns, I am impressed with the way they look, they both looked vigorous and healthy and both had quite a few blooms! They were doing way better than my bare root Mister Lincoln that I planted last year. She got hers from Lowes last year, they were container roses. I have rarely purchased roses that way. Do most of you have good success with these roses?

Comments (13)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Did you mean bare-root or own-root Sara Ann? Thanks

    Maybe it needs more time to establish since it was only planted last year?

    I had a own-root Mister Lincoln and no matter what I did I could only get 20+ blooms per season off of it here...

    I have success with container bought roses matter fact that's all I ever bought.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I meant bare root, grafted. That's what I generally plant. I thought I might try planting more container bought roses. I just wanted to know how good they do for others.

  • 11 years ago

    All of the potted roses available in local nurseries and big box stores are grafted roses. The nursery I shop at the most gets their's from Weeks in late November. They pot them up and start selling them leafed out in March. They charge $24.99 for them. The same bare root roses I'd buy online just with a three month start. Now they do sell some own root roses but those are things like the Drift roses or the Earthkind roses.

  • 11 years ago

    I think it depends on when you're planting. If you're planting early in the season bare root roses should do fine. That's when the nurseries get those same bare roots and pot them up and put them in greenhouses to start them up for later sale. Their advantage, of course, is the greenhouse. Even so a bare root planted in your garden should catch up fairly quickly to the potted ones once the weather warms up. The potted ones will do better later in the season though because they have that head start. Once it's really warm you need to be careful of planting dormant bare roots. They've already been in storage for a LONG time and will be dry so dehydration in the heat could just kill them right off.

  • 11 years ago

    Ask her what she's doing to care for the rose. Is it possible she's fertilizing them more often than you are yours? Did she maybe amend the soil more than you may have? Maybe hers are getting more sun.

    I don't really see any reason why hers would do better than yours just because hers were potted when she got them. Like they say above, most of those potted roses are just bare roots started up earlier by the nurseries and sold for 2x the price. I bet it has more to do with the care of the rose or how much sun/water its getting compared to yours. Also the planting hole amendment and general soil quality of your gardens may differ. Ask her how she cares for her rose and see if she'll help you get yours up to par. Its not that you are doing anything wrong, but maybe she's doing something you are not that the roses really like (a certain fertilizer regimen perhaps).

  • 11 years ago

    Maybe your friend's roses were mislabeled and it isn't really Mr Lincoln... its Olympiad or Chrysler Imperial or Ingrid Bergman or pretty much any other off patent red.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    countrygirl, yep got 20 blooms per season on Mister Lincoln and I thought that was a yawn fest...

  • 11 years ago

    I actually thought the same thing. Mr. Lincoln was a stingy bloomer and a one cane wonder in my garden. There are so many better reds in my opinion. If hers is Ingrid Bergman or Olympiad, it will bloom much more than Mr. Lincoln (at least in my experience). Otherwise, try a smell test. Mr. Lincoln is very fragrant and you should be able to tell if its the same rose by the scent.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm fairly certain from the looks of her two bushes they are Mister Lincoln, doesn't remind me of Chrysler Imperial at all, I'll ask her about fragrance. They are both tall, but one is somewhat taller than the other.

  • 11 years ago

    Actually grafted bare roots do very well when they cross first winter successfully . I have lost a couple of them to winter but if they come back in spring, they t as ️Gud as the expensive nursery ones!!

  • 11 years ago

    I've bought 3 container roses from Low's during the past few years and they have been very good additions to my garden. Two own root (Pink Knock Out and Dark Desire) that are very vigorous. Growing and blooming like crazy. One grafted (Charisma) that has done VERY well and survived 2 nasty winters. I'd be picky and REALLY look any container grown roses over before I plop down any $$$$.

  • 11 years ago

    I've planted a few container roses when I can find something I like at our limited supply rose dealers. I prefer own root due to our cold, long winters but the container roses I have bought have done well so far. One nice thing with container roses is that if they're in bloom you know that you are indeed getting the correct rose. I have gotten some mistagged mail order roses. I bought 'Bolero' rose from HD last year. It wintered over no problem and is super healthy and blooming well. 'Julia Child' suffered severe winter dieback but is doing extremely well despite her needing to be cut literally to the crown. I also was lucky enough to find Easy Elegance own root 'Yellow Submarine' and 'Centennial'. Both are very good repeat bloomers and super healthy. 'Centennial' went through our brutal winter pretty much untouched and has the most exquisite pale apricot to white blooms. 'Yellow Submarine' is new this year but I would purchase her again if I could find a second one!! The blooms are such a pretty shade of yellow and she has no black spot!