Software
Houzz Logo Print
maryl_gw

OT: Which to buy?

The spring flowering bulb catalogs are here and I'm trying to decide what to plant. If any of you deal with less then stellar drainage then you know my dilemma. I don't want anything permanent, just something to make a spring display (no short ground covers for instance). Tulips don't work here, Dutch Iris do, but this year I'm looking for something other then Dutch Iris. How do the taller ornamental onions strike you? Fritillaria maybe?.....Maryl

Comments (15)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi MaryL , I have never grown Frittilaria here as I have heard that they are prone to attracting slugs which cut them off at ground level and the red lily beetle however , I grow several different kinds of Alliums . The drainage here is poor at best but these bulbs do really well here .

    I grow the blue , the yellow , the white and Purple Sensation and the Gigantium .Also when they are done blooming and the seed forms, I just scatter the seed where I would like new ones to come up . It takes 2 to 3 years for a good sized bulb to grow but after the initial output for a few bulbs there is no further cost to replace. I love them and then they serve double duty as a dried flower in vases ( if picked before the seed matures ) and dried hanging upside down. Just a thought.

    Maryl (Okla. Zone 7a) thanked signet_gw(6b)
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Signet. I read that the Frittilaria has a skunky odor to it so I may just go with the Alliums. I know that the big flowered Alliums such as Globmaster are reputed to have large floppy foliage that isn't very attractive, but I'm still curious about them. I hadn't thought about the dried flower angle. Interesting. Appreciate the input............Maryl

  • 11 years ago

    I grow Allium Gigantium and I love them. The folage doesn't really matter much as I have them planted between daylilies. By the time they bloom the folage is going dormant. It is windy here, but the stems hold the large flower heads up. I have a friend that spray paints them after the blooms are done and leaves them in the garden. These pictures were taken in June.



    I try to buy a few every fall, never thought about starting them from seed. Good idea, thanks Signet!

    Maryl (Okla. Zone 7a) thanked nancykvb
  • 11 years ago

    I also grow the Allium Gigantium, and enjoy them.

    kay

    Maryl (Okla. Zone 7a) thanked organic_kitten
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nancy: You read my mind about the wind. I was just wondering about that - this is Oklahoma after all. That's a thought about spray painting them. Someone on this forum (wish I could remember who) posted a field shot this year of blooms of all types and she had a spikey flowered metal object that was painted blue that looked great with her other flowers. I've looked around for one myself, but can't find anything like it. Painting the dried flower balls might work to extend the color. I love your pictures of them. Is the variety Globe Master?............Kay: When do yours bloom?.......Maryl

  • 11 years ago

    The larger allium are showy and long lasting. Only negative for me is that the foliage takes a lot of space and is slow to disappear.

    Maryl (Okla. Zone 7a) thanked mantis__oh
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Mine bloom when my daffs bloom, Maryl, before the daylilies. Cindy is the one who showed us the picture of the spent bloom head painted. She always has a lot of really pretty garden ornaments, and I think she had some of the metal ones.


    kay

  • 11 years ago

    Thank You Roxanna for spotting those blue spikey things for me. Gardeners Supply has them listed alright. Kind of pricey, but they looked so neat in that picture someone posted (Cindy?) that I am more then tempted..........Mantis: Yes, that's what I read too. The foliage just sort of lays on the ground and rots. I only have one semi-suitable place to plant them and it won't have any plants that will cover or distract from the Allium foliage, so I guess I will just have to tolerate it. I doubt if this will be a permanent planting anyway - either by my hand or the hand of mother nature.........Thanks Kay on the timing. That would be about April here probably. ....I posted this here because the bulb forum is very slow and daylily people really know their stuff. If anyone has tried another variety of large flowered Allium other then the Globe Master let me know. They have several types listed (I've already tried Ambassador for instance) and I'm just experimenting..................Maryl

  • 11 years ago

    I grew allium for a few years. Everyone here is right about the foliage,it starts to look bad before they are done blooming. I removed the allium because they reseeded all over my gardens. I didn't always get out in the gardens in time to remove the seed heads. I just decided they weren't worth the work for me personally, mine had a fairly short bloom time. I enjoy them in other peoples gardens now!

    sherry

  • 11 years ago

    If the foliage bugs you as it dies down simply cut it back . Here is a pic of some alliums in my gardens. These ones are "Purple Sensation" and grew from seed scattered when the original bulbs seed heads matured.

  • 11 years ago

    I was curious so checked out the allium stakes ....for 19.95 for 3 you could probably buy a whole whack of 1/2 inch chicken wire( which these are made from and make dozens.

  • 11 years ago

    Where did you see 3 for $20.00? I just bit the bullet and ordered 2 from Gardeners Supply for $40.00 - the place Roxanna suggested.............Mary

    lMetal Allium flowers

  • 11 years ago

    Maryl, the allium stakes you ordered are so much more realistic than the 3 for 19.99. Checked them both out. The cheaper ones are just a ball made of chicken wire like Signet said above.

    Sherry

    Maryl (Okla. Zone 7a) thanked sherrygirl zone5 N il
  • 11 years ago

    Sherry: Thanks for checking it out for me. I would have felt like a real sap had I missed a bargain like that. They come 2 in a package from Gardeners Supply (which I'm sure is no coincidence), since most people design with the rule of odd numbers (3, 5, 7 etc.). ......I grow the "Drumstick" Allium (A. sphaerocephalon) and from them can attest to the "naturalizing" habit of some Alliums (and not just by seed). This one spreads by minute bulb offsets, some smaller then a pea. I'll be watching the seed heads on the ones I add next year. Appreciate the caveat.............Maryl