Software
Houzz Logo Print
sdhoolisover

The Case for Short Curtains

11 years ago

I get it. According to design gurus, short curtains are OUT, as in "OMG what a gross decorating error". Floor length grommet panels are IN. I guess I am alone in my opinion that sill/apron length curtains/drapes can provide as much design class as its longer versions.

Over the years I've had my fair share of long panels, on rods perfectly placed above the window trim to add "height" to the room and barely touching the floor. Honestly, my rooms never seemed any higher, and the drapes were a pain to keep clean.

IMNSHO given the right fabric choice, short curtains can make any room funky, sweet, serious, pleasing, cozy or simply beautiful.

Comments (33)

  • 11 years ago

    I personally have no problem with short curtains. My current house has two rooms with ribbon windows that start level with the ceiling and have a sill height that is about 5'8" above the floor. Curtains may make the most sense in one of the rooms. I am not putting floor length curtains up to cover 5-8" of wall.

    It's a MCM house so I think short curtains will be appropriate in any case.

  • 11 years ago

    In our house, most of the heat/a.c. vents are under the windows :( so I almost have to use short curtains. When long curtains (like in DS's room and the sheers in the DR) are drawn the heat or cool stays right there, because the air blows the curtain out a bit. That's my case for short curtains! Most of the windows, though, have blinds.

  • 11 years ago

    In the right application, and on the right window...I think they can be fine. Personally, I think they tend a bit to much toward a country look for my taste, but of course everyone has a different style & taste. You seem like you like them, so go for it!!

  • 11 years ago

    Out, schmout. If you like it and it meets your need, go for it. If it's "out" now, wait a minute and it will be the latest trend.

  • 11 years ago

    It depends on the circumstance. I have a tiny living room with a big picture window which just about covers the entire length of one wall except for the entry door that the window wall is on. If I do long drapes I have a wall of curtain, which so overpowers the tiny room that its all I would see. I chose sill length sheers with blinds behind them and because I can see the wall beneath the curtains, it helps greatly not to overpower the room. Of course this is not the only situation where they work better, but I am glad I ignored the long curtain advice in this instance.

  • 11 years ago

    I love short curtains especially in a retro vibe room or a non-master bedroom.

  • 11 years ago

    I don't care for them personally, and they do make a room look dated because they are out of favor with designers. When people ask that question it means they are usually trying to make their room look more current, and the honest answer is that they are "out."

    I am somewhat past the point where I want my house to look en vogue. All I really care about is that it looks good to me, but it took me 59 years to reach this "devil take the hindmost" stage :-)

  • 11 years ago

    I don't have much of a choice. All of the major windows in my house has a radiator underneath, and floor-length curtains aren't feasible. No picture windows, no patio doors (no patio!).

  • 11 years ago

    I like them-- but it depends on the room. Looks less formal to me, which is sometimes a very good thing! Pretty room, Nhbaskets!

  • 11 years ago

    In two of our tiny bedrooms, in our small home, there are beds against the window -- short curtains for the win! In the third, which we use as an office/playroom/exercise space, there is artwork under the window so short curtains are there as well. I love love the look of the long curtains but it isn't a practical solution for everyone.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, I agree, more informal. I think quite pretty, light and breezy. I've been thinking about short curtains a lot for the bedrooms in the cottage.





  • 11 years ago

    Like anything, they can be well done or not. To me the only things that are "out" are things that are not well done. Long or short, if they don't look good in the room, it really doesn't matter if they are "in."

    Diane

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I ordered curtains that were made in England for the den in our previous home. We couldn't use full length curtains due to the placement of the stairs and the window. Shorter curtains are not uncommon in England, but they are known for having rather quirky old homes!

    New House 2015 · More Info

  • 11 years ago

    Eh, I dunno if any particular window treatment is out of favor with some pretty well known designers. I have even seen vertical blinds in Architectural Digest in the past couple of years. They weren't highlighted, but they were in a house that had a full-on spread.

    I still have a sneaking suspicion that the full-length drapery and the slightly puddled look developed out of laziness and lower budgets (especially with the vast dissemination of the full length look on design television). A full length curtain is one of a few standard sizes that can be adjusted above the window (Again supposedly to "add height" or not "crowd the window") to get the hem at the correct height at the floor.

    A well made short drapery ends at the sill or at the bottom of the apron under the window, pretty much period-end-of-sentence. And that either means custom, pure luck, or a bit more work than hanging something long that's a completely different size than the window itself.

    Yes, I like long drapes, but the whole thing that anything else is just too gauche is a bunch of Emperor's New Clothes, and we've all been taken in.

  • 11 years ago

    Well, darn - second photo was the wrong one. Should be THIS one instead. (Sorry - I can't seem to make the wrong one above go away either.)

  • 11 years ago

    I like that look! For the lazy who do not like leaving their houses (me) etsy is a great source for custom hem/custom width curtains at more or less off the rack prices.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    As others have said, it's more about context to me than what's in/out. We recently put a short curtain in my daughter's college apartment, as she needs the space under the window to be open. It looks cute! I only have two lengths in our house: just above the floor on most, and valances on others. But I am thinking of a short curtain for our wide guest room window.

  • 11 years ago

    Notice that Auntjen's end just at the bottom of the window apron, a good fit. Not some random short location in between.

    I've done this though, on occasion, where I wanted drapes to the floor and there was something in the way, I'm flexible:

  • 11 years ago

    We have short curtains in dd's room, ds's room and the breakfast nook. I like them and I think they make more sense in these relatively casual rooms. It's easier to clean the floor under them and ds ended up putting a trunk under them in his room. My living room and dining room have curtains that just touch the floor.

  • 11 years ago

    We need to get to the point where we have in the length of women's dresses, where anything goes as long as it fits the rest of the room.

  • 11 years ago

    I cant even remember the last time i saw short curtains in a higher end shelter mag, Pal. I guess its possible theyre being used by the cognoscenti but i'd have to see it first!

    Puddled curtains have always been a pet peeve, and I've often said they are the result of the fabricator's extreme laziness and probsbly originated in poor measuring :-)


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I actually think that looks fine, Pal. I would've gone that route too, had I fallen in love with full-length curtains and had the idea occurred to me.

    kswl - puddled curtains and cats do not mix. Can't begin to tell you the number of furballs my gang horked up on the fabric spilling out onto the floor.

  • 11 years ago

    I guess it depends where we grew up...and when. ALL curtains used to be attached to the window trim. Mine all are! I was amazed when I first saw curtain rods attached to the wall. I also LOVE houses that do not look like everyone else's! I prefer no gray walls, no gray and white kitchens, NO WOVEN BLINDS...etc. Crisp , white, cafe curtains make my heart flutter. Why would we want to see every window with floor length panels? Different is delightful!

  • 11 years ago

    I think shorter drapes can be really pretty when used in the right situation. I also think it's important not to take what is or isn't in vogue with designers too seriously.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If it serves your purpose, then do it.

    Why have the long drapes crushed against the wall?

    self-contained Huts · More Info

    Don't block the heat...
    Case Design/Remodeling, Inc. · More Info

    Short drapes over desk are matched on rest of windows

    Modern Bedroom · More Info


    Long drapes would get splattered with water and such, and ending where they do brings your eye to the lovely tile border.

    25,000 SF of Luxury · More Info


    Stopping above the window seat, even above the apron, so the seated don't get tangled up in fabric.

    Shadow Valley · More Info

    Works so well with the casual style of this curtain.

    Atlanta Christmas Show House - Girls Bedroom & Bath · More Info

  • 11 years ago

    Most of your examples are situations where longer curtains are not even possible, Annie, so they at least look "right" logistically in those situations. The glaring odd room out is the breakfast nook / window seat, where IMO those panels are clearly a poor choice for the architecture. Those short panels look terrible in that application, they would have done better with panels on each side and roman or woven shades over the seat itself.

  • 11 years ago

    Those short panels in the yellow-and-black dining room look odd to me too. I'm sort of waiting for them to start flapping around, kicking out their hems and going wild. They're not quite right.

    The other applications look fine. I particularly like the gauzey pair edged in lavender ribbon. Lovely.

  • 11 years ago

    The black and yellow ones are hung a tiny bit too short and really with such a wild pattern there is no real benefit in hanging them high against the crown. With short drapes I think they need to be a more specific fit than long panels. I would've done blinds in that case.

  • 11 years ago

    I think the most disturbing thing on the black and yellow is a combo of the color and pattern. I don't think the drape length is so much the issue, though I agree with pal that if you're doing shorty drapes, it doesn't make sense to put the tops at the ceiling...rather they should be all about the window.

  • 11 years ago

    OT but why would you put the high contrast, black and white fabric on the fretwork chairbacks instead of the seat? The two elements are fighting each other for attention.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Old-ish thread, but I'm having a hard time figuring out what window treatment, if any, I should do on these windows. The problem is 3 of the windows have no floor under them (atrium open staircase) and 1 has the floor.

    My thoughts have been leaning toward putting a simple window trim/molding around them and valances OR window trim/molding and some kinda of wood ornamental architectural piece above the area and just leave the remote control honey comb shades that are there with no valances.

    It's so cold with just the drywall and no trim. Any ideas?

    (Any ideas about a stair railing would be helpful as well. I don't plan to sand and paint all this because there's 96 of the little balusters, much less everything else). DH wants an iron staircase with glass....I think it's too modern.

    Thank you for any help you can give.

    The only iron/glass combo I would consider is if I could do this with glass to meet code.

  • 8 years ago

    I have a choice, since the "new" drapes and curtains I'm about to install are actually repurposed ones that are long, so I will be able to try them at full length before deciding, but every time I look at those windows my instinct screams "short please"!