Software
Houzz Logo Print
roarahgw

Curb appeal vs privacy?

11 years ago

We are in the final planning stages of adding a bath above an existing sunroom and I am having trouble pulling the trigger.

The architect plans for a 48x24 awning window placed five ft above the floor in the front elevation. A 36 diameter round gable on side elevation and a single double hung in back. I love our interior plans but worry they create an awkward exterior view with vast amounts of siding between windows and stories.

Here is what our interior should be.

Here is the existing house from street.

Here are exterior elevations

Here is a rough mockup of what I think it might look like.

Here is a mockup of adding an awning between windows. I would go with something less shiny and most likely roof material but could not find a good one to photo shop.

Would you try and add an awning above first floor window to lessen the big gap or a flower box under the top window or leave it as the architect plans. My rendering is not at all to scale... I can increase the top window to 48 x36 placed at four ft off the floor and lose a bit of privacy or put a single double hung like in the rear elevation too but I can not mimic the first story double window because we need the wall space in the bath room.

Any thoughts on this. I am afraid I might be ruining my homes style, or lack there of, to gain practicality. What would you do?

thanks and sorry so long!

Comments (13)

  • 11 years ago

    I would not do that awning window in the front under any circumstances. I would do two windows similar to the existing ones and just get shutters for them for privacy.

    The round window is not bad looking in that iteration and has historical precedent (although not necessarily for your style of house), but there I would probably also go with the same type window below it instead of round.

    Like most architects, yours has created a shopping mall of window styles with no thought to how they appear from the exterior. This is one of my pet peeves! We also have a "master bath" window that is apropos of absolutely nothing else in this house. It is only visible from the side of the house, but whenever I see it it makes me mad!

    roarah thanked User
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you KSWL for voicing what my gut is saying! I will ask about adding two front windows. Here is a mock of two double hung, any better?

  • 11 years ago

    Much, much better, roarah!!

    roarah thanked My3dogs ME zone 5A
  • 11 years ago

    I really dislike the look of the awning windows. Kswl has nailed it.

  • 11 years ago

    Yes, roarah, that looks 10,000% better!

    You are smart to catch this kind of thing BEFORE it happens. I have a friend with a beautiful ocean waterfront home who put in a window to accommodate a piece of furniture they don't even have any more. And her architect encouraged her to do it! They regret it now, but it is too late to fix.

    Your house is charming..... Isn't it ironic that an architect would be the ruin of it?

    roarah thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    The awning mockup is really not what I envision the architect meant, I think he had something more like this one in mind....

    But I do think I need to go with regular double hung windows and either rework the cabinetry or just block the edge of the window with it. Do I need to go exact same width as the first floor windows or can I go slightly narrower?

    thanks again! I could never image not being able to use this forum as a sound board before making big changes!

  • 11 years ago

    I think you could go narrower, as the gable narrows. But I would't go drastically narrower and would ask for drawings first, as you have done!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Could I use two 24by48 double hung in the front elevation. If so I can keep my plans for the sink wall. I hope to have all my ideas firm before asking for the next drawings. I think I have been too vague with my opinions with him.

    Here is a mockup of the original plans scaled with a 48by48 opening.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is the width of that wing to scale? If so that looks good! If the expanse of siding were wider, though, I think you might want to more closely replicate what you have downstairs.

    I hope Pal or Beverly or some other professional with a good eye sees this post and weighs in with ideas and opinions as well!

    roarah thanked User
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The drawing is to scale but my photoshopping of the house makes the wing look a bit wider than in real life. Again thanks for helping me think this all through. I am feeling guilty about wanting to add on an addition to the front of this house but it is our most feasible option cost wise and also to keep the interior original details intact. Moving would be cheaper and easier but I love my location and the house.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I did the mock-up and nothing is to scale. The room will have a cathedral ceiling and the mirror in real life will be a medicine cabinet quite a bit farther below the window. The sink will be in a dresser and that online picture was the one most like what I already own.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I do not like the awning at all!

    I agree with chispa about the bathroom window and mirror.

    roarah thanked rockybird