That really depends on the company you hire to do it. I would get quotes for both.

I agree with Interiors International. I'd add too that when you get quotes, consider whether you're comparing 'apples to apples'. Would new cabinets give you a stronger cabinet box? More accessibility?

If you are doing the work yourself it can save you a decent amount.

However if you are hiring people to reface then you will only save a little at best and still have the same cabinets, Most likely, inexpensive well made new cabinets will be better made then your present cabinets, as the cabinet industry has better, cheaper alternatives now. When you reface you also lose the ability to change your layout for free, always making it better and sometimes even saving money. For instance: Switching a design from a wall oven and cooktop to a range can not only open up your kitchen but save $3,000. If you are buying new appliances, this is due to the added cost for the appliances, the more expensive oven and cooktop cabinetry and the countertop cut out and square footage that you are paying for. A range slides into an empty space and needs no top or cabinet.

One advantage if you could learn to reface yourselves and save the labor money is that it could take as long as you wanted. You don't have to remove any plates, food or glasses, during the process. And you can do your countertop last. The internet will have videos on refacing. This Old House and Hometime have good episodes as well.

There are also some excessively priced, high pressure, cabinet refacing companies that will charge more than what a beautiful new kitchen could have cost. Beware If anyone wants you to sign the contract tonight, to get a discount. There are replacement window companies that operate this way too, and it is shameful.

To get prepared for the hard sell watch the Alec Baldwin, Al Pacino, and Jack Lemon movie Glengarry Glenn Ross. If during you're refacing presentation the movie seems familiar...... ah oh!

Cheers,
Paul

my experience it is often close in price. I equate it to the feasibility of fixing an old car. 56' T bird convertible-Maybe... 73' chevette-Not so much.

If the cabinet layout is perfect, the drawers work well and structurally everything is sound it can be viable. Also, depending upon your layout, there can be many edges around doors, end panels & kicks as well as trims like crown moulding that require changing too. That is where the costs really add up.

Often many issues with hinges & drawer slides that will need addressing. or improving accessibility of cabinets by adding more drawers etc... as previous commentators pointed out.

Consider too, the issues regarding appliances. Do you need to replace? Are any of the models different sizes than the spaces you already have or will that severely limit your choices.

If its a great kitchen, that functions well, reface can be worth it. Just be fully informed as to the exact quality & durability of the finishes/materials. Unfortunately the reface contractors tend to cater to folks trying to do refresh for very low cost. The materials available will reflect that price point.

Senior Designer~ Urbana