Software
Houzz Logo Print
kate3ryan

What type of range?

11 years ago

I've always enjoyed baking but didn't really learn to cook until a few years ago. Our last house came with an electric oven with the smooth top which is the only type I've now ever cooked on. I'm not a very neat cook, inevitably water will run over my pot when boiling pasta, and the top (induction? I forget) seemed permanently charred. I also prefer cast iron pans, which did not seem like a good match for the smooth top. I had lots of cooks comment that they did not know how I cooked on it because they had to have gas. We have gutted the kitchen in this house so we could switch out the electric to gas, assuming it's not too expensive, but now I'm torn. I'd bought a consumer reports last year when I'd hoped to tackle the kitchen so the info is dated but when I went through it last night the electric ranges were all rated much higher than gas. We'd be getting a pretty basic model either way so the 30 in. roughly $1300 ish type. Is gas really better? Are you happy with your range? Can I fit a turkey into those split ovens (one big one smaller)? Anything else I should know or look for? Thanks!

Comments (4)

  • 11 years ago

    There is a pretty big difference between cooking on induction and a smooth top electric cooktop. If you don't know what you previously cooked on, it is a bit hard to advise you


    I'd be very surprised if things charred onto induction. I have found it by far the easiest cooktop surface to keep clean, in part because spills do not get baked on.


    And most cooks love induction. I'm no gourmet cook, but I cook regularly and induction is so responsive, so fast to bring things to a boil, so good at holding a low temperature, it really is ideal for most kinds of cooking. (No cooktop is going to stop you from having boil over and such. That's just a function of the cook staying on task--hard to do sometimes I know.)


    Nontheless if you need to use cast iron and you need to slide the cast iron pans around to cook, I wouldn't suggest induction because you will just scratch it. Generally if you are not getting induction, most people prefer a gas cooktop over an electric one. And generally people prefer an electric oven. You can buy dual fuel ranges but they are pricey.


    It sounds to me like you want a gas range.

    Katherine thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago

    If you are interested in induction (and it's extremely unlikely you had induction without knowing it), you might want to check out the Frigidaire slide-in that AJ Madison sells for $1498:

    http://www.ajmadison.com/cgi-bin/ajmadison/FGIS3065PF.html

    You have to put it in the cart to see the actual price and it always says "ends today" but so far it never has. If you have a local dealer who carries they would probably price match it.

    Cast iron is great on induction, but you can't slide the pans around, just as with any glass cooktop.

    Katherine thanked writersblock (9b/10a)
  • 11 years ago

    Do you really want to clean a gas stove top? No way. Lifting and soaking the grates? Dragging the grates to soak in the sink? Scrubbing? You know how you clean induction? Spray ammonia free windex on induction and wipe with a paper towel. Done.

    You didn't have induction. It is different and you would know it. There are so many advantages to induction. I have induction and love it. I also have a beach house with a gas stove and there simply is no contest. Induction is way better for tons of reasons. We also bought a house in Arizona to snowbird in and it has a nice electric smoothtop. It is really not bad but we will get induction when we remodel that kitchen. There are peeps who want to see a flame and char peppers. Gas is for them. But that's it. The heat from a gas burner heats up the air-not so with induction. Think summer. The smoke, heat, grease of gas, yuck. Only grease with induction and not if you use a splatter screen.

    Google the applances forum using 'gas+induction' for the many posts where the advantages and disadvantages are posted.

    Katherine thanked westsider40
  • 11 years ago

    THANK YOU so much!! Sounds like I have no idea about induction but it's clearly much better than what we had before!!