Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_21884067

...is this rose a gonner do you think...?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

ok...today I received 3 own root, bare root roses from France... a week in transit but well packed and still moist.... 2 are in excellent condition, the other, which is 'Cels Multiflore' incidentally, does not look right at all and I'd like some advice as I'm not terribly familiar with own roots...

....there is one cane and at the bottom of this cane, just above the root system, it has started to turn yellow with black marks.... now if this was a grafted rose, I would expect 3 or 4 good canes and if one was yellow/black I would prune that out... what I'm thinking here is that this rose is on the way out.... would you say so from this description?... all the growth above the yellow part is still green and looks o.k. even red bud eyes and a few leaflets...

...here are some photos, although I've planted the rose now so I cannot show the base exactly...

..3 roses in a bucket of water... 'Cels Multiflore' is the one in the middle with the yellowing cane centre bottom of pic... the cane is at an angle upwards towards the top right of pic...

[ignore the buds, they're on a different rose]... hope you can see the yellowing base here..

I have planted this rose with the cane about level with the green twine holding the label in place, if you can see that.... in the perhaps vain hope it might set more roots above the yellow bit... although at this time of year it's a tall order... but the rose will remain in my greenhouse and maybe indoors even in warm bathroom during coldest spells...

question is, do you think this will survive? or is all hope gone?.... I know I'll find out soon enough, but just thought you would know more about this sort of thing... have you had this before on own roots yourself? and has the rose survived?..

thanks for any advice....

..bewitched, bothered and bewildered.... that's me...

..the planted rose...

..some good leafage...

Comments (9)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I only grow own roots thus far, but I'm afraid that my experience is so limited, that I have no useful suggestions, other than to echo Nik's advice about asking for a replacement.

    I do have a plant of "Ping Dong Yue Ji", a found rose that MIGHT be 'Cels Multiflore', and if it is the same variety, my experence was that the rose just sat tight for what seemed like an inordinately long time, before deciding to grow.

    "Ping Dong" may not be 'Cels', but my point is that it may take a long time for that plant to decide if it's 'a gonner' grow or croak (sorry!). Requesting a replacement is a good idea.

    Good luck,

    Virginia

    User thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Definitely ask for a replacement! I've grown over 100 roses, most own root. Would never accept something like that.

    User thanked carriehelene
  • 11 years ago

    ..thanks people..... my worst fears confirmed I think.... I've notified the vendor...

    Virginia... I shall sit tight with it until I'm sure it's gone...

    that rose is very pretty.... I was hoping for one like that...

  • 11 years ago

    So you're not considering surgery?

    Is this from the Hooks? I'm sure they will oblige (if they have another one ready).

  • 11 years ago

    ...yes it is from them Nik...

    ... I thought I would leave the rose settle and see what happens, which was your first option.... If I find all the top growth dies off then I will take the second course and cut it under the bad part... although I don't think there will be any cane left at that point..

  • 11 years ago

    ...just to say, I've heard from Mrs Hook, she was very sorry about it, and told me that this rose struggles for them too so it's difficult to get propagating material... but she will send another in due course, although I have advised that I would be delighted to receive any other she may have available if that's more convenient...[I love surprises]....

    ...she also advised me Nik, to do what you suggested and cut it right back, but I think I'll leave that just for now...

  • 11 years ago

    Marlorena, since you do have that greenhouse handy, how do you feel about taking a cutting or two from the still-green top to see if you have any luck rooting them? Stranger things have happened, I'm sure. I'm not sure what your odds are in any case, but Kim's burrito method of rooting cuttings just might do the trick...

    On the other hand, another variety might be a better choice; I may be mis-remembering, but isn't 'Cels multiflore' supposed to be one of the Teas that really, really loves a hot climate? Don't trust my memory- I read too many rose descriptions, and they get jumbled up...

    Oh, and I cheated and read the label on one of the other roses you got, so I know that you and I both have an "Odee Pink" now, but what was the third rose you got?

    "Curious in SC"

  • 11 years ago

    Virginia, I was thinking about taking a cutting, I have nothing to lose so I just might do that.... I just wanted a small pretty rose for my greenhouse where I can replicate a warmer climate, say from April onwards... as soon as the sun shines the temps. rocket to the 80's.. even though it may be only 60's outside... so I thought it would be something different and a challenge..

    ...I think the buds on 'Odee Pink' are rather nice don't you?... Mrs Hook left them on for me to see as she told me about them...

    ...the other rose is a Tea that I wanted to try as I read something about it on HMF... 'Comtesse de Leusse'... the foliage is really prettily tinted and it looks a nice plant actually....it's a parent of 'Unermudliche' and I suppose another to keep as warm as possible although I'm tempted to put it outside later on... it may be hardier than I suppose...thanks for asking about it.... I'll keep you posted...