Software
Houzz Logo Print
liamblastoff

Grapefruit Soil Change

I got mine in July & its 1 year old but it hasn't grown an inch & its getting annoying, its in Miracle Gro. Potting mix & if its bad i'll move it into Miracle Gro. Citrus, Cactus & Palm mix

Comments (83)

  • 11 years ago

    When I took down the greenhouse my 2 tangerine trees could not stand up to there own weight. I use ties to hold the tree vertical so that it was strait but could sway in the wind. It wasn't until august before they stood up even in wind storms

    7 feet tall and 2.5 year old from seed sprout. The lsast of the cloth strips holing the limbs up are visible.

    5.5 feet tall from seed sprout has one lat strap hold a branch up.

    I have no problems giving a small tree some support and I rarely get winds over 30 mph. both trees are very solid and have held up tp one storm producing 50+ mph winds

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked poncirusguy6b452xx
  • 11 years ago

    Wow, citrus grow fast

  • 11 years ago

    Hey Pip. Orangelime1's huge trees are not grown in a citrus growing area. He is in Canada north of Ottawa. We can all learn a lot from him!

    Cory

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked cory (Zone 7a, NJ)
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    He must have a nice greenhouse then. Either way it can't compare to growing in an apartment. My trees haven't been outdoors in years. When you transplant into a fast draining mix like gritty and your humidity is 30% or less, leaf drop is to be expected. They will recover just fine once the roots start to colonize the mix.

    hes simply taking offense to the fact that its recommended to remove the stakes from all trees besides a few exceptions such as severely dwarfed apples. I'm not feeding into his B.S. Let him be butthurt.

    liam, I still think your biggest problem is a way oversized pot. It looks like 10 gal or so. A tree that size should be in a 1 or maybe 2 gal pot.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Pip you know talk talk talk talk that's all you are by the way we're are your pics I guessed right none. Lol


    Brian

  • 11 years ago

    Lol. Your funny. Search the forum, I've posted before.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Liam you know pip is probably right on the stake thing and you might even find that same statement in a book no proplem to each their own . My call I would rather take advice from Cory and Mike and many more here you can see their results they've had in the past and present just a suggestion or you can go buy a book on citrus and follow it word by word . Don't you find it a little strange Pip was afraid I was going to rip into his pics but doesn't mind ripping into other people's pics and suggestions STRANGE. Not only that he is ripping into people who I think are pros at growing potted citrus I dont get it very STRANGE .Why would any one rip into pics of trees that have just been transplanted is beyond me .With that much knowledge his trees must have looked beautiful before the transplant and no pics . No matter what you do we have all been through what your going through it's a learning experience there will always be a little trial and error until you find what's right for your growing conditions . Everyone needs a different soil and everyone waters differently and fertilizes differently for there environment you will find your your RIGHT and then you will be growing some beautiful tree's .

    Brian

  • 11 years ago

    1. OK, I will remove the stake later, its dark & 42 out.

    2. @ Orangelime, if you wanna start a fight with someone don't do it on my thread

  • 11 years ago

    Oh, what about drainage? It takes about a minute to reach the bottom

  • 11 years ago

    I wasn't ripping, you just took it that way. Look at his other threads, he has more than one. There is a serious problem he is having. The other grapefruit thread shows a tree that is very unhappy. It's ok for a tree to go through a hard time when your doing something like transplanting, but yeah when you don't know the cause it can be a different situation.


    he specifically said and I'll copy and paste: its in Miracle Gro. Potting mix & if its bad i'll move it into Miracle Gro. Citrus, Cactus & Palm mix


    so yes, I did tell him that both of those mixes drain poorly. He has the choice to do whatever he wants. My opinion is swapping one for the other isn't the cure-all.


    who did I rip into that you think is a pro? Mike? First of all that's all in the past, second I made it clear many times I did not want to substitute it's not my fault he wouldn't let it go.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    I'm sure it's easy to grow outdoors and in a greenhouse with the sun and high humidity. Me, my environment is sorta like Liam's, very, very dry air and no rain.


    There is no way your going to convince me you wanted to see pics for any reason other to nit pick. So yes, once they are done adjusting to the new mix I'll be happy to post pics of all 15 of my citrus, 2 cacao, and my avocado.

  • 11 years ago

    @ Pip, I totally appreciate your advice Pip, its just that I would break of tons of roots, it takes up 7/8 of the pot. So if I don't move to the house in December I will move the pot up a scale & add better draining soil, like Sandy soil?

  • 11 years ago

    Wait, I thought citrus LOVED dry climates, or you just can't put it out side

  • 11 years ago

    Have fun with it Liam . No problem there.


    Brian

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked orangelime1
  • 11 years ago

    Move the pot up a scale? You mean an even bigger pot? Your pot is already too big. Look at orangelime's pics. The pots look the same size as yours with trees significantly larger.


    ive made the mistake of potting too large too fast before. It only got better when I down potted. That's why I keep recommending it, I've gone through it before.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Actually Pip is right about the bad drainage, I figured out the reason the bottom wasn't doing good was because the top absorbed it

  • 11 years ago

    OK, no up size

  • 11 years ago

    Lemonade tree under 35 gallon trash can light painted bright gloss white


    These are some devices that triple winter inside growth rates. All use a 23 watt CFL's


    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked poncirusguy6b452xx
  • 11 years ago

    Dry climate is totally fine, sorry if I confused you. My point is in dry climates, when you transplant, it's not as easy to keep the tree happy while the roots colonize the soil. We have the problem of fast transpiration.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Hey Steve, do I have trees or am I a liar?

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    @ Pip, you have trees, I think I've snooped on the forum & found a couple pics

    @ Steve, that is REALLY cool!

  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, that lemonade he's talking about is the tree I was talking about when I said I've even given a tree to a member here. Steve will confirm.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    I removed the stake

  • 11 years ago

    Also, of this doesn't make it there is always buying another plant when I plant in ground

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Or keep it alive and still buy another one. I don't know about you but I can't stop finding varietys I want. And like I've said I've got like 15 in an apartment lol.

    i just counted it's 17 so far, all dwarf and young besides the giant key lime, couldn't find it in dwarf.

    Lemon:

    - Lisbon

    - Lemonade

    Lime:

    - Giant key

    Orange:

    - Valencia

    - Smith red Valencia (blood)

    - Moro (blood)

    - Vanguilia pigmented

    - Sanguinelli (blood)

    - Cara cara pigmented

    Grapefruit

    - Flame

    Kumquat

    - Meiwa

    - Centennial

    Mandarin

    Tango (seedless)

    - Depokon

    - Xei shan

    - Gold nugget

    Pomelo

    - Hirado buntan

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    I was planning on planting a Meyer to

  • 11 years ago

    Also, how big is your Grapefruit? I would like to know because we have the same variety

  • 11 years ago

    I just got it it's only a year old. From Briteleaf. I had another but I cut the scion off to grow rootstock seeds. Then threw it away because I wanted the space.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Hmmm, i really need to try a Pomelo

  • 11 years ago

    Here are some updates now for future reference...

    1. It can not be centered, for pete sake its 1 inch from it

    2. I removed the stake

    3. Its growing in a side ways direction on the top

  • 11 years ago

    Pictures:

  • 11 years ago

    It's a lot better than it was before you dug it up.


    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Your gonna hate me but you should put the stake back. Until the roots establish, because you disturbed them.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Harris has dwarf hirado buntan. It's supposed to be one of the best.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    No problem


    Its also closer centered than you think. Like you said

    Thorns

  • 11 years ago

    Liam....First off, Brian was not trying to pick a fight with anyone.If you would of looked closely at what he was trying to say, it was because he was concerned about a lack of tact towards you.That's it... Even my friends and family could see that. If anything, you should appreciate his compliments, suggestions, and in making sure that others treat you warmly here...Actually, the true is opposite, in all my years here, I have never seen such a kinder person as Brian and how much he cares about how others are treated here...The stick support thing was just a reaction....

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm not against him at all, he's shown some pretty good advice, its just the fact that he's being a little mean, specifically at pip

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Liam, as far as your tree goes...Here's my input...

    Pip and Brian gave you a ton of good info..What I can tell you is to relax about your tree and hurting a few roots..You live in a climate that encourages great growth with warmer temps...The mixes you are using are ok for a holding period and not for more than a few months..

    You have the warmer and longer days on your side to have your trees roots fill your containers within a short period of time, even more quickly if you just put a tree in a pot just a bit bigger than the root system, probably before your mix can ever compact and suffocate which explains the good growth..

    In your area, you could do a bare root, but that is preferable to the spring growing season and yet even if you did one now, your tree/trees woyuld still take a shorter time to recoup, and in may cases nor go into shock at all..For those of us growing way up here in fall and winter, we have much more to contend with..

    As for the stick thing, many use sticks, stakes, elastic, bungee cords, poles, wire attached to pole around the tree to help support trees until the roots start to hold a tree up on their own..Another way of supporting a tree in a container is with use of wire attached to the root zone through bottom holes like Bonsai do...Working in the landscaping business for years, we would use such support until the roots were able to support themselves and then remove the support..It has no bearing on the size of the trunk unless the trees were dependent on them for years, or unless something was wrapped around the trunk of the tree that eventually choked the life out of it..

    Using a stake for support is not Taboo, but discouraged here for fear many don't know how to use them and for how long....

    Fyi...Using a porous mix is always BEST no matter where you are located, because it supports more than the average growth on all citrus in containers and encourages the full potential of your trees roots systems...The mix you are using will get you buy, for how long, no one ones...

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked myermike_1micha
  • 11 years ago

    It's all good, I'm not the nicest person either.


    he clearly mistook my 3 quick, short, non elaborate statements as being rude. Really I just don't like turning a sentence into a paragraph. Too much work on my iPhone.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Liam, there is a history there you are not aware of..I would just focus on your tree and keep appreciating what every one has to offer..You will be great some day on that tree, especially once the roots hit the earth)

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked myermike_1micha
  • 11 years ago

    What ever, but this advice will really help, thanks everyone! By the way, when are Pomelos in stock at the store? I wanna try one

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Never here in my area..I do know that down south many of my friends have a much wider selection come around the spring...What state are you in?

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked myermike_1micha
  • 11 years ago

    I've found them in Michigan in the store maybe February? March?


    They are pretty much dry and acidless yet still very, very good. It's weird and hard to explain.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    Mike do you have a joes produce in ma? That's where and only where I've found them.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked pip313
  • 11 years ago

    I live in Las Vegas NV


  • 11 years ago

    Yes Pip has lots of trees and I got that lemonade tree from him. It is flowering now.

    Liam Coldwell (Zone 9a) thanked poncirusguy6b452xx
  • 11 years ago

    I had a Pomelo, it was DELICOUS. It was 2 dollars... But it was worth it! it is exactly like a Grapefruit but Sweetness replaces the Tartnes. I honestly like a little more than Grapefruit

  • 11 years ago

    One of the best is hirado buntan, Harris citrus has it in dwarf on flying dragon stock

  • 11 years ago

    Orangelime1, I bet I'm not the only one who'd like to know what you do to get your citrus looking so nice. Are there any threads where you discuss this? I'd particularly like to know what your soil mix is, and how often you have to water in hot weather.

  • 11 years ago

    I bought 2 more and ate one, lol