Software
Houzz Logo Print
romcorn

Any problem using shredded christmas trees as mulch?

10 years ago

Is the end of holiday season now and the city offers free shredded christmas trees for pickup. Could this mulch be used now to cover tomato patch? If shredded again with home shredder would it decompose?

Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    It will decompose even if you don't re-shred it.

    Just use it as a thick mulch and in the spring, move a bit aside to dig the planting holes.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you lazy-gardens.

    That is my intention. I wonder if pesticide/herbicide be a concern?

  • 10 years ago

    I don't have the impression that a lot of pesticides are used on Christmas trees. I suppose if there was an infestation of some kind of borer, etc. they might spray them. Generally speaking, modern pesticides break down rapidly in a soil environment anyway. I wouldn't worry about using this for mulch.

  • 10 years ago

    Nitrogen tie-up only occurs if the material is incorporated into the soil. If used just as a mulch, this is not an issue, just the same as it is not an issue with any wood-based mulch...........as long as it is not mixed into the soil. Otherwise, conifer needles, shredded Xmas trees, even blown down conifer branches (common in my neck of the woods) make an excellent mulch.

  • 10 years ago

    The Xmas tree industry uses an enormous amount of pesticides.....herbicides, fungicides, miticides, and insecticides. Growers have to (are supposed to) comply to spraying schedules in order that the pesticide residue is minimal by the time a tree reaches your home.

    But frankly, chemical residue is of less importance to the industry than the chance that any pests may survive. Consumers of US trees all over the world (we export this crop in huge numbers) inspect for the existance of pests, not chemical residue.

    Some of these chemicals are systemic, of course, and the regulations are different for non-edible crops. Any tree produced in a commercial tree farm should be considered a high pesticide use product. That's just the way it is.


  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the info rhizo. I learned something today.

    Considering what kind of product a Christmas tree is, this should not surprise anyone I guess. It's a whole plant that is cut and shipped far and wide. The last thing anyone would want is for them to be a vector for spreading pests or diseases.

    Note to self, don't eat the Christmas tree. :-]

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    'Ever it a pinetree? Some parts are edible'

    Euell Gibbons

  • 10 years ago

    You can get a lot of plastic and glass in the "mulch" from lazy people that don't take the time to completely remove decorations. Personally I would stay away from it.

  • 10 years ago

    Euell Gibbons! :-D

  • 10 years ago

    We may be getting somewhat over cautious about this subject :-) Shredded Christmas trees are a perfectly fine mulch, treated or not. Whatever the tree are sprayed with is highly unlikely to leach into the soil and at this time of year, contact with any edibles is pretty limited anyway. And it sure makes far more sense to recycle these things into a mulch product than to dump them into the landfill.

    FWIW, there is a very strong growing presence of organic Christmas tree farms. They are becoming more and more prevalent and popular here in the PNW where the bulk of cut Christmas trees are grown. And while not necessarily certified as organic, most cut your own lots use very few pesticides - it is just not practical. Currently there are 'environmentally friendly' commercial Christmas tree operations in 22 states.

  • 10 years ago

    Yeah, but I have a choice of "organic" wood chips from brush at the transfer station any time I want or the trees.

    The mulch might temporarily be more attractive, but all other things being equal, why not default to the chipped brush?

  • 10 years ago

    The Christmas trees may have a little higher nitrogen content because they have more twigs and leaves (OK, needles, same thing). So-called ramial mulch is a little more nutritious and will decompose faster into the soil than straight wood chips. This is good if your soil is poor and you're trying to build it up. Also, it may be a bit more acidic while it's decomposing, if you have acid-loving plants. Pine mulch doesn't create permanent acidity though.