Software
Houzz Logo Print
awestruck

Compost Rots, Smells, and Has Flies

10 years ago

I have a compost pail that I put food scraps in. I also have small compost bins in the garage. For some reason, the compost usually rots and stinks really bad, or it grows mold and also has lots of flies. I am trying to add more dry ingredients like newspapers, but I still have lots of flies. What am I doing wrong?

Comments (21)

  • 10 years ago

    Prob several things could be improved - covering the food scraps with browns such as leaves, shredded newspapers or cardboard will help reduce insects but you still need to kill the eggs also. So freezing or heating up those scraps first will help kill the eggs. Have a microwave or gas grill you can use? Or is it freezing outside?

    But it sounds like you need more air in the pail and bins. Blowing a fan over these containers might keep the mold from growing. Also keep the contents moist but not overly wet.

    HTH

    awestruck thanked gumby_ct
  • 10 years ago

    Is there a particular reason you need to keep your compost in the garage? Don't let it get really wet 'cause that will cause it to become anaerobic and smelly for sure. Like gumby said, dry browns on top should help as well.

    Harry

    awestruck thanked harry757
  • 10 years ago

    I can't keep a compost bin outside because we live in a subdivision with rules, there is not room for one, plus, we live near a wildlife conserve and have all kinds of animals getting into the rotting food. I have a worm bin kept in the garage as well. The plastic bins I have are like this one - http://smile.amazon.com/Exaco-ECO-2000-Kitchen-Compost-Collector/dp/B0017WOFSI/ref=pd_sim_201_9

    The stainless steel one looks like this. http://smile.amazon.com/Epica-Stainless-Steel-Compost-Gallon/dp/B00AMNCYNQ/ref=sr_1_1 . I no longer keep it in the house though because we got too many flies inside.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I was not aware that compost needs plenty of air. I thought it was just the opposite. It would make sense though, that compost would need plenty of air because that is what will keep it from going bad so quickly. Thanks.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    You sound like a good candidate for bokashi composting, not traditional composting. (I do both.) Most of the bokashi process happens in closed 5 gallon buckets and you only need a small space outside with dirt to do the finishing (or even bury it directly gardens.)

    awestruck thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    That is it :) I use the bokashi in the small bins, but not in the worm bins. I can bury the compost in the gardens after some of it is dissolved, so that the raccoons don't run off with the oranges I put in the compost bin!


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    awestruck - neither of the containers you linked to is actually a compost bin. They are compost collection containers. So they are designed just for collecting scraps in your kitchen, not for actually making compost in. They are far too small for that. I have a kitchen container similar to your steel one and it fills up in a day. Then it gets emptied onto the compost heap outside. Your indoor compost collection container shouldn't ever attract flies. If it does it needs emptying and cleaning more often.

    I've never done bokashi but given your circumstances that might be the way for you to go. But note that even bokashi needs 5 gal pails according to Veda.


    awestruck thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 10 years ago


    Since you already have worm bins, you could put your scraps into the worm bins.


    Another thing is that I assume you are composting for gardening purposes. Even if your area didn't allow having compost bins, but it seems they are OK with gardens. You could then also use the trench composting idea, and bury the food scraps directly into your garden. Either bury them deeply or put something heavy over the buried area until it doesn't attract the wildlife anymore.



    awestruck thanked purslanegarden
  • 10 years ago

    So you are intending to do bokashi in these containers, but it's apparently not working correctly. It should be odorless. Are you adding the bokashi inoculant? Have you read up on the process and how it is supposed to work? I haven't done it and I would hesitate to give much advice as a result. I thought that a Bokashi container was basically closed which would keep bugs out. I'm not sure you can do it in the kind of containers you showed. But don't take my word for it.

    awestruck thanked toxcrusadr
  • 10 years ago

    There are a lot of Bokashi threads here in case you are looking for more on it.

    http://www.gardenweb.com/gardenweb/query/bokashi/topic=soil

    awestruck thanked toxcrusadr
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks all, for the help. The compost is probably way too wet for one thing. I needed to add more newspapers as well, but haven't done so. My worm compost bin is too full to add anything more at the moment. I do add occasionally to it though, and put more newspapers in it as well, as a lot of liquid comes out of this bin. I have used the Bokashi stuff and I do think it helps. I am going to keep a closer eye on the compost as well, and keep it more airiated too.

  • 10 years ago

    awestruck, I do both worm and bokashi as well as regular composting - I find using all three methods gives me plenty of options and lots of ways to experiment. I first read about bokashi about 2 yrs. ago and wanted to give it a try. Seems to work for me although I haven't used the leachate or finished bokashi enough to claim any miraculous results in the garden. The bokashi is very different to regular or worm composting in that you are processing your food scraps in a very low oxygen environment. Normally that would cause your food to putrify and stink to high heaven. But by using the bokashi bran (homemade in my case) the food scraps are more or less fermented or pickled and as such don't look very different after 2 wks. of bokashi treatment. The real breakdown to something akin to soil comes when you bury the scraps in the ground or just mix it with some healthy soil in a big tote. Since you are worm composting you can also feed some of the finished bokashi to your worms. After fermenting for 2 wks. your food material can smell a bit like pickled cabbage and is quite acidic so go easy if feeding to your worms. I have found they stay away for a few days then just go crazy for it. I got my original info. from a guy named Brian McGrath (try "Prokashi") and he explained things very clearly.

    Good luck,

    Harry

    awestruck thanked harry757
  • 10 years ago

    The reason compost stinks, grows mold, and smells bad for the most part is that it is too wet and has gone into anaerobic (in the absence of air) digestion.

    What size are those bins in the garage? Volume does make a difference. While some people claim success in composting in 5 gallon pails more have problems since the volume is too small.

    Perhaps this composting tutorial may be of some help.

    http://sarasota.ifas.ufl.edu/compost-info/

    kimmq is kimmsr

    awestruck thanked kimmq
  • 10 years ago

    Isn't compost *supposed* to rot?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    <Isn't compost *supposed* to rot?>

    I like to say it "de-composes". :-)

  • 10 years ago

    The material put in to be composted is digested by various bacteria, and fungi, and to some people that means it "rots" and to others it "decomposes". While the terms are somewhat interchangeable "rots" and "Decomposes" do not really describe what does happen.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    Either way, it rots, but it is not rotting in a good way in my compost bins. I have made some changes and am taking more time with the composting ingredients so it will turn out better. I took some out today to put into the garden (because I probably tend to keep it inside the compost bins too long). I placed the compost (which was not finished by any means) onto newspapers in the garden bins. I threw some potting soil on them and more newspapers. Because I have such a problem with squirrels and raccoons, the compost needs to be composted as much as possible before it goes into the outside gardens or the animals start digging into the compost materials and dig in the gardens. We'll see how this all works. Thanks again for all your help and suggestions.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    When it rots it smells and has flies.

    When it decomposes things are broken down into their basic elements and there is a pleasant earthy smell.

    So think of it any way you wish and it will prob turn out that way.

    Said another way to make rot takes no skill.

  • 10 years ago

    'Isn't compost *supposed* to rot?'

    What kimmq said.

  • 10 years ago


    Yea there's a definite difference to the earthy smell and the rotting smell. I prefer the earthy smell, even if I do still see bugs and flies around the compost.


    If it has the rotting smell, I try to add more dry browns. Even the browns getting added changes the smell almost immediately, and will help the compost pile gradually.



Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations