I think you'll enjoy Lady of Shalott. She takes a bit to bloom well so give her time. Since you have read some here you probably already know she's a big one.

As for Angel Face, unless she is religiously sprayed it will never keep her leaves. It's part of the reason she doesn't grow for you. Roses need their leaves to provide nutrients for good growth. I had to remove mine also. What a gorgeous flower she had.

I'll let someone else comment on Ebb Tide. Mine did meet the same fate as Angel Face. I'm not sure if a pot would make a difference in it. Most likely ET needs sprayed to survive in humid regions. If so it will never be a great rose without her leaves. Hope this is helpful. Maybe others will know more.

I've dug up a few old roses because they aren't doing well and I have them in pots. Time will tell if I can rejuvinate them. I'm not familiar with Angel Face, but I have Ebb Tide. It can be kept in a pot. I spray regularly, but I haven't noticed Ebb Tide gets more blackspot than other roses. It's worth a shot since you want to put another rose in its place.

I planted Angel Face in a pot last year. It doesn't seem overly vigorous yet, but is doing good. I think it might be one of those roses that take awhile to get established. All season it set on a few blooms here and there and most of then were on the small side, but later in the season they were full size and late in the season it had thirteen nice buds, by that time it was too late for them to open. I'm looking forward to seeing what it does in a few weeks, it's such a pretty rose. It might not do any better for you, but might be worth a try.

Angel Face is a notoriously bad rose almost everywhere! The reason it's still around is because she does bloom, is usually gorgeous when she does and she smells divine! Oh, and she is winter hardy. Other than that she stinks! The growth habit is rather awkward and gawky, she is the first and worst to get black spot and she isn't very vigorous growing either. I have a sentimental attachment to mine because she is one of the last ones I have from my Mom's garden. So she stays spots and all. If you have no attachment to this rose ditch it and get one you love! Life is short don't waste your time on a dud.

I have to take back what I said about my Angel Face looking good. I have 18 HT's, Floribundas or Grandifloras in pots. Sixteen of them look great. The two that don't are Angel Face and Heirloom. Right now I think I would heed Seil's advice about Angel Face!