Software
Houzz Logo Print
nicoleannette75

BEST TOP SOIL FOR KNOCKOUTS?

10 years ago

Hi, no experience with roses & wanted to plant them by the curb w/ a row of evergreen shrubs behind them. Someone suggested top soil with peat moss. I've heard others say peat moss doesn't add value. I've read about compost ... do you have to make it or can you buy it? How many inches of top soil would you recommend? Dirt that is currently there is sandy loam that was brought in for new grass. Any tips to beautiful Knockouts appreciated - I'm totally new to this.

Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    Knockouts can get 7' tall. Just to give you perspective.

    "Stormy" Gray thanked diane_nj 6b/7a
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    In some places, you can get "free" compost. But, you don't know what is in it--it may have grass clippings that have been contaminated with broadleaf herbicides that are poisonous to roses. I prefer to make my own with grass clippings and tree leaves so I know what is in it.
    http://compostingcouncil.org/persistent-herbicide-faq/

    "Stormy" Gray thanked zack_lau z6 CT ARS Consulting Rosarian
  • 10 years ago

    THANKS everyone for suggestions!! Buford, I have about 7 or 8 inches of sandy loam in this curbside flowerbed. I would have to bring in a lot more dirt if it needs to be entirely sandy loam. I was thinking about mixing it in with the existing dirt? Diane, someone suggested that the medium size knockout bushes have more blooms than the large. What do y'all think? Would I still need to space the "medium" size 3 or 4 ft? I've heard roses like air circulation but I want a filled-in look.

    Zack, I think I'll end up having to go with a bagged compost from the nursery. It's supposed to have manure in it but should I add additional? Do I need to worry about using too much manure if I get the kind that doesn't burn? And should I add peat moss in with it? Thanks!

  • 10 years ago

    It is time to sing the "Where are you?" song. Without knowing that, none of your questions can be answered with answers that make any sense. What is the existing dirt? The short answer is to tell us where you are, and we (or people more local) can make reasonable guesses. How should you space the Knock Outs? It depends on how large they are going to get in your climate. Again that depends on where you are. What is a 'large' Knock Out? Is there even such a thing? How much air circulation are they going to want? How is your disease pressure, and what diseases are of major concern? The list just goes on and on.

    The usual thing is assume that posters in unknown places live next door. If you were my neighbors, I'd strongly recommend against Knock Out since they have hardiness issues here. There are Canadian Explorers and other roses that do the job much better.

  • 10 years ago

    Sandy loam is excellent soil for most shrubs, roses included. Beyond that, as mad_gallica rightly points out, for superior results, more information is needed. Rose performance is region-specific.

    "Stormy" Gray thanked hoovb zone 9 sunset 23
  • 10 years ago

    Not mentioning my zone was an oversight. Thought I had. Zone 8a. Thanks!

  • 10 years ago

    Which State? Southeast and Southwest etc vary a lot regarding rose growing.

  • 10 years ago

    Um, Knock Out, is Knock Out. There is no such thing as a "medium sized" Knock Out, at least not here in central NJ. Are you talking about one of the other roses in the "Knock Out" series? The size on the Star Roses site is misleading. I suppose that it could be kept smaller by pruning back, but it would have to be done frequently.

  • 10 years ago

    I had one planted and it said "medium" on the tag. It could have been "Star." And someone told me that the large are leggy and the medium or small the only way to go for more roses. But, thinking if I kept the large pruned it would probably bloom as much and I wondered if the large would be hardier?

  • 10 years ago

    In our location Knock Outs reach 8-9 feet tall and 4 feet wide. My neighbor planted some one gallons along a fence last spring. She too was told they'd stay small. By November they were 6 feet tall and two feet wide even with pruning all summer. She was most upset because she didn't want big roses. In February she pulled them out. I see houses all over that put Knock Outs in front of their house only to have them grow so big you can't see the house much at all. As others said their growth rate and form will depend on your location but I'd probably look for something different if you want small.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Welcome to the Roses Forum, Stormy! Knowing where your garden is located, as well as your zone, is a big help in getting practical info from others in your neck of the woods regarding mature size & performance. That's why so many of us include it with our names. I'm Virginia Sue near the city of Charlottesville. There's a wealth of wide-ranging experience generously shared here.

    There are now 8 varieties in the Knock Out line, in addition to the original Knock Out, for a total of 9. So Small, Medium & Large on the tags may be a rough idea of how tall & wide each one may be expected to grow. HelpMeFind lists Pink Knock Out at 24-28" tall, for example, in contrast to Sunny Knock Out at 4-1/2 feet. Guessing Pink would be tagged Small & Sunny Large in comparison? HelpMeFind is a great online resource for specifics on roses. Using the search feature turns up this list of Knock Out varieties - www.helpmefind.com/rose/plants.php?searchNmTyp=5&searchNm=knock+out&rid=3957&sbSearch=SEARCH&tab=1  You can click on any one of the names & then click any of the tabs across the top of the listing for member comments, ratings, photos & other information.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Don't believe the tags.

    It would help to see if you can find any growing in local parks or botanical gardens, or if there is a rose society that you can ask. Or, if we knew approximately where you live (such as coastal SC, central TX, etc., we don't need the exact city) so that someone here on the forum who is closer to you can help. "8a" covers a large part of the US.