Software
Houzz Logo Print
kayla_thomas3817

Paint the cabinets or just replace?

10 years ago

We have this house under contract.

I love the house. It's old, stately, tons of character...but I don't love the kitchen. There's nothing particularly wrong with I, and I know it's probably someone's style...but its not mine. I feel like I doesn't fit the rest of the house at all. It's too dark. Too ornate. Too heavy. The finishes are too modern and mismatched the the rest of the kitchen. Etc. It just looks disjointed to me with the varying cabinet heights, and everything thats going on. Also, even though it looks like it has a nice big range hood, it's not vented to the exterior, so it's essentially a glorified microwave type of vent. Womp, womp.

That said, the cabinetry, though not my style, is custom and cost $20k (owner provided receipts). I kind of feel bad wanting to come right in to paint them knowing that, but I really don't like them as is. This house is a reasonable distance to a cabinet factory outlet, where I purchased what would be custom plywood box cabinetry, but was misordered, over ordered, etc. for our last home, painted it,and it worked out wonderfully and was less expensive than buying the unfinished builder grade press wwod box cabinets at Lowe's. The only thing is I don't REALLY want to jump right into a new house and tear the kitchen out and put more money into it right off the bat- maybe in a year or two.

What do you think, wise Houzzer's paint the cabinets without guilt, or just replace?

Comments (20)

  • 10 years ago
    Beautiful house! I say PAINT! You will feel much more comfortable in your new kitchen.
  • 10 years ago
    Look at the before and afters which I googled....
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I would paint them too. I think that it will brighten up the space so much. I would have it done professionally with a cabinet maker though who would spray paint them not hand paint them as they will chip. My suggestion is to do an off white in a satin finish not gloss and not matt.


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    The other thing would be to have a builder add a bulkhead from the ceilings to the cabinets so there is no space at the top. Looks way better however you would have to replace the cornice too so depends on budget.

    Farmers - Showcasing designs built & designed by Joinery Group NSW · More Info

  • 10 years ago

    The sink is in the island? It looks like a weird layout. Live with this kitchen for awhile. If you like the layout, paint. If not, replace.

  • 10 years ago

    Agree with Emily. Live with it just a little while before making a decision either way. You may find that there are other things more annoying than the cabinet color that lead you toward a cabinet replacement. If it works out, then feel free to paint them if that is your thing.

  • 10 years ago

    I think you should move in, live with it for a while, then decide if the current layout works well for you. If so, painting them should be sufficient (would the current counter & backsplash work for your vision if you paint the cabinets or would you be replacing it?). If you decide you don't like certain things about the layout, then live with it for a year or two until you can do a full gut. In that case, you'd also have to replace counters, backsplash, and flooring if the layout changes at all (unless the tile runs under the cabinets). Don't rush into painting or gutting yet...live with it for a bit.

    I will say that I'm not a fan of the staggered cabinets either, nor do I like the reddish stain color or the island corbels so if this was going to be my kitchen I would make changes but still not until I got a feel for the flow of it. :)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The selling and going towards new is why I'm hesitant to paint. I'm not sure how well they would sell painted. As mentioned, I painted the cabinets in our last house (sprayed doors, rolled faces), as well as built the bulk head, cut and installed trim, built the range hood, laid the tile, etc. Aside from plumbing and electrical (husband) and installing the granite, my two hands did everything else in this kitchen (http://confessionsofadiyaholic.blogspot.com/2014/07/we-moved.html?m=1) from top to bottom. I know I can handle the work, but in the meantime... How much can cabinets like these sell for? What if I painted them and then sold them later just to live in the house and figure things or for a while first? (Eta: looks like we're kind of tracking on the same page on this one)

    To answer a few questions: yes. The sink is in the island. Yes. I think that's weird. It's not a prep sink. It's the main sink. The dishwasher is there too, but it is a good distance from the stove and other cooking features.

    Also, running a bulkhead along the tips of the cabinets isnt completrly possible since they are staked at 3 different heights. :/

    Corbels definitely must go, along with the round pillars leading to the living room. They're gaudy, and don't match the rest of the house. The cheap bifold pantry door must go as well. I don't like the glass backsplash, or the feature tile. Not the style, not the color. I really just....don't like this kitchen, darnit.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is one instance where I really think you need a professional opinion from a kitchen designer. There are too many variables to consider- function, cost, configuration, compatibility with the overall style of the home. I would also suggest a counter depth refrigerator since the current one juts out too far from the cabinetry.

    The exterior of your home is lovely and classic. Congratulations!

  • 10 years ago

    BTW, I checked out your blog. Fabulous remodel of your previous kitchen.

    Kayla Thomas thanked flopsycat1
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I don't know where the home is, I don't know your finances, but that house is deserving of a far different kitchen.........and I believe you already know that. I think you answered your own question?

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    That island with the dozen corbels is just hideous that would be the first thing I would tacles remove the counter have stainless supports insta;lled and lose all thos corbels and FYI 20,000 for all those cabinets was cheap and probably for a reason. A counter depth fridge would be the next thing, check out what you can do for proper venting and then get a pro to paintthose cabinets but I do agree to wait for a bit to see how that kitchen functions for you to me it seems avery large unfunctional space but that could be just me. A kitchen this size done with good quality cabinets would have probably been in the 60,000 range so don’t cry too much if you feel the need to gut this.

  • 10 years ago

    I understand kitchens are expensive. I'm only talking material expenses on the cabinetry here, not labor or a of the other work involved.

    I'm still taking the corbels off. They have to go. I don't think I'd be able to live with them for any amount of time. Bleh. I do like the idea of living with the kitchen for a while to get a better feeling for a layout plan. I know this one isn't ideal, but I'll need to figure out plumbing/electrical options before doing a new kitchen. This is an addition on this old brick house, so that's an extra challenge in the whole thing...I can't just drop right down into the basement.

    I don't like the appliances either. The fridge is awful, but I I'm going to redo the entire room, I'll probably suck it up and leave it there until we redo everything anyway. It actually seems short. I didn't have a tape measure with me, but I think a standard height refrigerator wouldn't even fit in that opening.

    It seems the consensus is that this kitchen needs to be redone, which my husband and I are in total agreeance with. We'll move in and live in it for a while. If I get a crazy wild hair, I'll paint the cabinets, otherwise it'll wait until a complete remodel can be done.

  • 10 years ago

    I am not sure used cabinets sell for a lot, painted or unprinted. At least on craigslist, they never seem to go for a lot. You probably have a broader buyer pool for unpainted. People who buy used cabinets tend to be DIY types willing to paint. So the wood would not be a turn off. For those who despise painted cabinets (myself included), painting would make the unappealing.

  • 10 years ago
    Kayla, I just checked out your last kitchen remodel and am so impressed! Whatever you decide to do this time will be fabulous. Of that I'm sure.
    Kayla Thomas thanked cloudpants
  • 10 years ago
    Paint the uppers, then judge the balance before deciding what else to paint.
  • 10 years ago
    Paint out the corbels under the island's top. Also. Paint out the door on the back wall, but tape off the bottom so you can continue the line of the baseboard.
  • 10 years ago

    Just sharing a couple more pictures a friend sent me. Turns out her husband did some work on the house, and he had these pictures. I wonder when they added the other billion corbels. :P


  • 10 years ago

    Probably best to live with it, for sure. Having said that, it won't hurt a bit to kiss the columns and the corbels goodbye. I'm not too fond of the ceiling detail. If those things went it would streamline the kitchen quite a bit.