Software
Houzz Logo Print
travelngal

Ikea or Not Ikea

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I am at the stage of construction where I have to decide on cabinetry. I can go with Ikea and save about 2/3 of the cost of a custom build. The house is modern. The kitchen has no uppers--just an island and the wall with the stove and fridge and related cabinets. The closets and laundry rooms and pantry are mostly out of sight. Everyone keeps going on about my resale value in 20 years. But I am living in the house now and I have the wallet I have now.


Shall I go fancy dovetailed boxes for tens of thousands or Ikea for a lot less?
Any thoughts? Experiences?

Thank you in advance for your responses

Comments (30)

  • 10 years ago

    You will be using your cabinets everyday. I haven't used Ikea ones. To me, especially for a kitchen, I think it's important to get the best quality cabinets you can afford. It is the base for the countertop, you can get a configuration that fits better with your needs, and good quality will last - soft close, heavy construction, good hinges, deep drawers, etc. Save on the laundry room or bathrooms if you need to.

  • 10 years ago

    We decided to go with custom quarter sawn white oak cabinetry and marble look quartz, again that resale value concept, but we were very fortunate to access a very good local cabinet builder who were very reasonable and included three uppers and then about 26' linear of lowers with many drawers and apron sink.

    I did my usual budget sanity question, of how many $1000 do I spend on eating out in a year, you know the questions, how much do I earn in a week of work, is that worth spending on better cabinets.

    All that being said many designers use ikea cabinets and they do have solid wood doors, that can be refinished. I would only go with solid wood, no foil wrapped or veneer versions. search 'ikea cabinets' on houzz and see what you think of the various styles of their cabinetry and how it looks

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    I'm not normally a big IKEA cabinet fan but in some situations they make a lot of sense. They work well in a more modern look home. Avoid their lower end lines. Many people buy the cabinet boxes and interiors, and get doors and drawer fronts from places such as Scherrs. Especially if you don't like the IKEA doors.
  • 10 years ago
    We just bought an Ikea cabinet as a temporary solution (we are eventually going to redo the whole kitchen) and my housemate who can be really picky about how stuff is engineered is super impressed with the drawer construction - we got the more expensive Maximara drawers. Between that and going around a recent home show testing the feel and performance of higher end examples, I think we will go IKEA when we redo the kitchen, possibly with custom doors. The cabinets just seem to now be decently built and likely to stand up to use and abuse so why go more expensive? I would not be upset to walk into a mid range home around here and find an Ikea kitchen as long as it was properly installed.

    Depends on your house value, though. An Ikea kitchen in a house no one would look at if it didn't have a SubZero fridge and a Viking or Wolf range is an entirely different kettle of fish.
    travelngal thanked KD
  • 10 years ago
    We are installing an IKEA kitchen with white Grimslov doors. It looks great. We are putting in quartz countertops and a nice backsplash, along with Bosch appliances. We're also making our own under cabinet molding. Spend your money on nice countertops, lighting, and appliances, and save money with the cabinets. The nice thing about IKEA cabinets is that you can update them with new doors and side panels years down the road for a whole new look.
    travelngal thanked cajonqueen
  • 10 years ago

    Here's your answer: http://www.semihandmadedoors.com

    Go with Ikea, but get the doors from semi handmade. The difference in price is small. We will be using this company in our kitchen reno.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    calidesign - Ikea cabinet's Maximera drawers use top rated Blum drawer systems and glides and are all soft close. The Ringhult and the Bjorket doors are great, I'd stay away from the cheaper thermofoil doors, no matter the manufacturer.

    travelngal - I highly recommend you go over to the Gardenweb kitchen forum for Ikea specific help as well as layout advice. Good luck.

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/kitchbath

    travelngal thanked User
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    check out REFORM http://reformcph.com.

  • 8 years ago

    This whole post happened over a year ago but I just found it. Friends of ours live in the most exclusive part of town and have a home worth gazillions. They put in an Ikea kitchen quite a few years ago and it's still beautiful. It has remained sturdy and rich looking. And it has stood the test of time as far as design is concerned. That's why I'm going the Ikea route as well.

    travelngal thanked Beverley Bergman
  • 8 years ago

    I love ikea kitchen cabinets. Some of their stuff is trash. Their kitchen cabinets are not. I can't even buy the Blum hardware for the price of their drawers with Blum!

    travelngal thanked Milly Rey
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks to alI who replied. I went with IKEA cabs for all my cabinetry--kitchen, closets, bathroom, laundry. I got their sinks and faucets(bathroom only) too. Based on the money I saved not doing custom cabs (which didn't include sinks/plumbing), I was able to afford build a pool too. Further the flexibility and ease of returns is unmatched. Originally I had ordered one type of door and just before my order shipped Summer 2016, I noticed that IKEA had come out with a new door type that didn't need handles. I was able to switch out to the white Voxtorp doors for the kitchen. An amazing experience. Their software to design the kitchen was crap but I pretty much was able to realise my design--even with the limitations.

  • 8 years ago

    Kudos travelngal - but we do like photos....

  • 8 years ago

    Forthcoming shortly. It's hard to find a moment when that kitchen is spotless to take some nice shots. It's if dirty bowls and glasses spawn in the sinks and on the island the minute I turn my back. Just like dirty clothes regenerating in the hamper the second you've put away the last of the clean laundry.


  • 8 years ago

    Alas, I know all about that. Take your time.

  • 8 years ago
    My IKEA kitchen.
  • 8 years ago
    More of my IKEA kitchen
  • 8 years ago
    IKEA kitchen round 3
  • 8 years ago
    I also used IKEA for all bathrooms. This is the Godmorgon wall mount with Odensvik sink and Svensakar faucet in our powder room. The lights are Twiggy lights from Lightology.com. Skimp to splurge is my motto.
  • 8 years ago
    The mirrors are all IKEA as well. Each size sink/cab has matching sized mirror. The good thing about the Ikea mirrors is they are mounted slightly off the wall. They can be removed easily if needed and compensate for drywall that may not be perfectly straight.
  • 8 years ago

    Wow! What a great looking space. Your kitchen looks fresh and cool, perfect for the desert environment. Love all the natural light coming through those large windows and patio doors too. Nice!!!

    I so agree about skimping to splurge. I love the built-in fridge paired with the sleek Ikea Voxtorp fronts. Same for the bathroom - the Lightology sconces look perfect with the the floating Godmorgon vanilty.

    Great job all around. Enjoy your kitchen!



    travelngal thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It's gorgeous! I love everything about your kitchen. The Voxtorp doors, those lovely light grey countertops that add just the right amount of contrast, and to top it off: those beautiful views of the desert and mountains. So jealous!

    What's the name of your counters? They positively GLOW!

    travelngal thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks @modellie. my countertops are actually white OCEANA by Arizona Tile. they contain tiny flecks of glass to give it sparkle.

    https://arizonatile.com/en/products/quartz/oceana.

    It's not as white as the voxtorp which are more of a flat chalky white so when I first saw it I was a bit bothered by the difference but now I do not notice it.

  • 8 years ago

    @travelngal: I love the choices you made. Everything looks so easy to clean. How did you choose your contractor/workers? I'm looking for one now. Had they installed IKEA before? Did you have IKEA plan the layout? I hadn't considered IKEA cabinets until I was inspired by a friend who has IKEA storage in nearly every room. She put it all together herself. I want to do a kitchen, living room entertainment/storage system and laundry room remodel in 2019. Your post has helped me.


  • 8 years ago
    @carolscully. I did the kitchen layout myself on the Ikea planner. It was torture but I persevered. There’s a service called inspired kitchen designs. IKD online and they charge a fee but provide you a better 3D rendering as well as a more detailed shopping list for your Ikea products than I got 2 years ago via Ikea. I highly recommend ikea products though. I was able to change my order at the last minute as the voxtorp doors had just been added. And I can always change them. The one thing I don’t like are the kick-boards where the corners meet the clip on covers tend to pop off if I sweep too vigorously. I could crazy glue them but I am OCD-ish and a couple times of year I feel the need to remove the baseboard and clean beneath the cabinets. As for installation—at the time, IKEA suggested a firm called Traemand. The installer who put up my cabs was an experienced, brilliant and meticulous former cabinet maker who knew a few tricks and hacks.
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks very much travelngal!


  • 8 years ago
    I say get the Ikea and in 20 years you likely will need to replace them. Well even with custom cabinets you likely will need to reface them for an up to date style. Your family and friends can make their own choices in there own homes. :)
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I have made this comment on several different homeowner posts on the topic of Ikea cabinets. Our firm does very high end homes in Coastal Southern California and we use Ikea boxes occasionally and they are great. A cabinet is just a "box" and as boxes go, Ikea is a great box that can be embellished, different doors can be put on and there are tons' of configurations. Sometimes the client wants to save money in their budget for other items and these are a great option that is not really a compromise. The photo below shows IKEA cabinets used in a very high end Manhattan Beach Home office/yoga room combo. The client had all custom millwork elsewhere in the house and this was a perfect item to fit the budget for that space.

    Yoga room/Office · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    I'm so happy to have come across this post using white matte Voxtorpe cabinets. I keep coming back to Ikea Cabinets because the price is just so much lower than even the replacement door companies that sell for ikea sektion boxes. We have a Bodbyn kitchen in our rental and those doors are so perfect to maintain, easy to wipe clean and they look new even years later. I do prefer a flat front this time around and what I'm wondering about the Voxtorp cabinets is do they get really grubby and worn because they don't have handles. Does anyone have experience with this?