Software
Houzz Logo Print
lifetime98

Franke Sink Comparison: Peak, Planar, Cube

10 years ago

Looking for some insight on these 3 sinks. any personal experience? Peak is 16ga vs 18 on the other two, and the peak has the integrated shelf and drain cover (I'm thinking this may get grimy)


This will be our only sink with two young kids, we'd like to hang a drying rack in the sink for bottles sippy cups etc.


Base cabinet is 36".


TIA!.

Peak PKX11028 Stainless Steel
http://www.franke.com/us/en/ks/products/kitchen-sinks/Peak/122-0074-954_detail.html
Cube CUX11030
http://www.franke.com/us/en/ks/products/kitchen-sinks/Cube/122-0371-978_detail.html

Planar 8 PEX110-31

http://www.franke.com/us/en/ks/products/kitchen-sinks/Planar%208/122-0325-211_detail.html

Comments (35)

  • 10 years ago

    I keep a drain cover in my sink all the time and it's not nearly as attractive as the Peak's! I have a sink with the integrated shelf and don't know how I ever lived without it. It is extremely versatile and handy ... for drying dishes, for rinsing and draining leaf lettuces and other veggies, as a resting place for hot pans right off the stove, to set a colander on for draining, makes a good place to air dry a dishtowel, etc.

  • 10 years ago

    thanks for the comment! I've never seen a drain cover previously, do you find that it gets gunked up, and is a pain to clean? or do you just clean that instead of the strainer...

  • 10 years ago

    I'm also thinking of buying the new Cube series. Have anyone seen it at a store yet?

  • 10 years ago

    That drain cover just seems weird. What is the point? I would also steer clear of the square drain hole - there was a previous thread about the difficulties you may encounter with the square drain.

    As to the drying rack that sits down in the sink, I have one and yes, it does eventually get grimy. However, it's crazy handy and I don't know how I ever lived without it. I have a stiff-bristle brush and hit it with that every week or two and it cleans up pretty good. Mine is from Blanco and instructions say not to put it in the dishwasher but I think some of the regulars here do.

  • 10 years ago

    The square drain is still just a round hole underneath so the disposer can be easily attached. I am not sure how it is different from the regular round holes more commonly seen in sinks.

    I personally like the Peak alot. I saw it at ICFF and it is great looking sink like all Frankes. I don't remember if I Cube was on display at the time.

  • 8 years ago

    lifetime98, I am curious which sink you decided on and if you are happy with it. I am deciding between Franke Cube or Peak, or Elkay Crosstown. Leaning towards Franke Cube. Thanks for any advice!

  • 8 years ago

    I would not get a Franke sink. I purchased a "made in Italy" Frank Planar sink and was surprised when the sink was delivered to me. It had "made in China" all over the box. I called the retailer (appliances connection) and complained that the Franke website said it was "handcrafted in Italy" but they gave me some garbage answer saying that it was designed in italy but could be made anywhere. WHAT??? The Franke website says handcrafted in Italy! I had to eat the shipping cost which was $135. Total false advertising. I ended up with a Create Good sinks and am very happy. Looks stunning with the seamless drain. By the way this sink is made in Malaysia but at least they state that. Very disappointed in the way Franke advertises their sinks for the premium they charge.

  • 8 years ago

    I have a Franke sink made in Switzerland -- Oceania OXX110 with the ledge. Big sink, quiet and the ledge makes it versatile. If country of origin matters to you (and like Alex74, it matters to me as well) then make sure you either call Franke or read over their literature carefully. Many of their sinks are made in China but not all.

  • 8 years ago

    Many people here love the integrated shelf with the ledge, and they give lots of the same reasons jellytoast gives above. I, too, am thinking of getting one for my upcoming reno, but the primary reason is one I don't see others give: when my frying pan has baked-on crud, I want to scrub it off at the height of the integrated shelf, not way down at the bottom of a 9" or 10" inch sink. It seems so much more ergonomic to me. But, since I don't ever see others listing that they do this, and I don't actually have this sink yet, this benefit is just a theoretical bonus, but still perhaps something to consider.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Wow i just checked the Franke website and they removed the "Handcrafted in Italy" description on the Planar 8 sink. That really was blatant false advertising so its good they removed it. I have nothing against Chinese made sinks (I bought a Kraus sink for the laundry room) but I don't like to pay a premium for deceptive advertising. There really is no reason for Franke to charge a high premium for their made in China sinks anymore.

  • 8 years ago

    Did you look at the Franke Orca? We just moved from the home where we installed a stainless steel Orca over 10 years ago. I miss that sink sooo much that we are planning a remodel of our new home's kitchen and getting a new Orca is the already made decision! The Orca has the grid shelf that doesn't sit on the bottom of the sink. The grid sits on a ledge. I would occasionally put the grid in the dishwasher or just spray it with sink cleaner and clean with a brush every 3-4 months or so. The value of the grid far exceeds the little bit of extra effort to keep it clean.

  • 8 years ago

    Aurora Tee - thank you so much for sharing your experience. May I ask what was the name of the sink which had the ledge collapse when you were trying to clean the cruddy pans?

  • 8 years ago

    georgiamom - the Orca looks awesome. I'm wondering if you have had a similar experience as Aurora Tee above, where if she has to apply a lot of pressure to a cruddy pan, the shelf grid collapses and falls from the ledge.

  • 8 years ago

    Katie- I always felt like the ledge was stable and had no issues with it collapsing. I have zero hesitation about installing the Franke Orca in my next remodel.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Interesting about the shelf not holding.

  • 8 years ago

    RCKsinks post here reminded me of a thread I read somewhere here about the Franke Orca which said that the fireclay and the SS Orcas are slightly different sizes and you need to make sure you get the right size grid shelf. I wonder if that might be the source of the problem, esp. with georgiamom saying that she has not had this problem.

  • 8 years ago

    lifetime98, we are looking at purchasing the cube11030 and have seen reviews on Amazon that mention staining and scratching. Also a mention that the bottom is flat and water doesn't drain well. Have you noticed any of this on your cube?


  • 8 years ago

    We have the Frank Peak; it's been terrific. No scratching and draining is excellent. It's our prep sink. I use the grid but don't like cleaning it - it's too large for the dishwasher so how the heck does one clean it properly?

  • 8 years ago

    I can see where they are coming from with the flat(ish) bottom, we make a habit of hosing it down once a week and wiping it with a sponge. I think any sink of this design would have that issue.

    For the grid we use an old toothbrush to clean it.

    Haven't noticed any scratching but thats inevitable regardless of the price.

  • 8 years ago

    I have been using the PKE sink for about three years. It is true that the ledge does not hold the grid securely. I solved the problem by getting flexible plastic tubing from the hardware store to augment the grid bumpers. I just cut to fit. I soak those in white vinegar every few days. No dents in the sink, and I cook daily.

  • 8 years ago

    I am considering between two sinks, Franke cube series, 11030 or the Elkay crosstown series 311610. We are building a new home and I love my old Franke sink. It still looks new after 25 years of heavy use. My only concern with the Cube series is the lack crease accent lines on the bottom of the sink to help the water drain better. Does anyone have any experience with either brand? Is it true the drain in the Cube series is square?? any comments will be helpful.

  • 8 years ago

    I had the same concern about the Cube. We got the Franke Kubus and we love it! It drains well

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    For those with a Peak, what size did you get? I wanted a 36" sink and thought I would get a Kohler or a Julien, then I saw the Peak and i am wondering if i will miss the extra four inches since their biggest is 32". But I have to tell you, I am deeply in love with the finish and styling of this sink. I kinda feel like a weirdo for caring so much about a stainless steel sink.

  • 7 years ago

    Apparently the largest size Peak sink is 28". My heart was set on a really big sink. Am I rightbin thinking bigger is better, or is 28" fine and I am looking at diminishing returns once the sink is big enough? Mind you i have not seen people with huge sinks complain here.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    "... or is 28" fine"

    @Zalco - I can't comment on Franke itself (other than to say stories like Alex74's above have appeared on this forum before re Franke sinks). However, my SS sink is 32" wide, and it is fine, but I would not have minded a few more inches. I would not go smaller. I think your initial idea of a 36" sink is good. To me, as long as the sink is single bowl and 16-gauge or thicker, the brand name does not matter, just MHO.

    No one has mentioned a corner drain. Those are a bonus, and once you have one, you can't do without it. That is what I would look for, more than finish or "styling". There are only a few SS sinks made with a corner drain. Elkay off the top of my head, Rachiele for custom.

    "I am deeply in love with the finish"

    Stainless steel sinks will scratch, no matter the brand or the price paid. That is just what stainless steel does, so to me, finish doesn't matter much as it will become a patina of scratches in a year or less. People on this forum are so happy with their Kraus sinks, a Chinese-made sink that makes no bones about it. It is 16-gauge and comes with a free grid, which on other brands could cost $80-125 extra. (BTW, I don't use a grid; I find it one more thing to have to clean.)

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thank you, Shannon. You're absolutely right. I am over the shiny Franke. Kraus looks great, the reviews are uniformly solid and the price is amazing. I don't know what happens to me sometimes. I am usually a reasonable person!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    This is a great thread for me with a 36" base cabinet - I'm in the market for two sinks one bar sink and one kitchen sink and the Cube, Peak and Planar are what we are considering for our new construction. We have a Franke Kubus in our current home and it works great. So was looking at the same brand (hope that their quality is still great from 7 years ago!). Its an undermount sink so not easy to change if something doesn't worked out with the sink down the line!!


    Ours is a modern construction so going for a tight radius (not zero radius) in the sinks - Planar is just 8mm radius unlike our Kubus which is 25mm


    After reading this maybe I should look at Kraus too. Thanks.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    " Its an undermount sink so not easy to change if something doesn't worked out with the sink down the line!!"


    I can change an undermount sink in just over an hour. Done it many times.

  • 6 years ago

    Looks like the Franke Kubus is made in Switzerland - since I had no problems with it - I should look for a Franke that is made in Switzerland too!! Looks like the Planar is made in China - wonder where the CUBE is made? (I posted on their side - lets see what they say)


    Is the Planar finish more shiny stainless steel and the CUBE a more satin steel (satin nickel) look? because they say it's diamond finish (Planar) and pearl finish (CUBE)


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Update: Planar and Peak have the diamond finish and Cube has the pearl finish. I saw it in a store. Peak is made in Switzerland and the other two are made in China.


    My choice is between the Planar and the Peak. Peak is a LOT more expensive than the Planar. Both have a tight radius and look modern. I have the ledge (KUBUS) and don’t really use it. So it’s just the square drain look which is not a big deal for me.


    My main concern is - should we worry about the quality of a Franke made in China vs Switzerland?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    "...should we worry about the quality of a Franke made in China vs Switzerland?"


    No. Say what you want about the Chinese, but they make some very nice sinks.

  • 6 years ago

    Will buy the Planar 31“ for the kitchen and the Peak 13” for the bar - the square drain will be helpful at a bar area by making the sink a completely flat bottom to rest the wine glasses.

  • 5 years ago

    Just called Franke inquiring about the Planar (18 gauge), Peak and Professional 2, both 16 gauge. Only sinks now made in Switzerland are the Peak and the Prestige

  • 5 years ago

    Planar, by the way, is being phased out. The Planar in pictures appears to be wider at the top than at the base. Is that accurate?