Software
Houzz Logo Print
elbell19

Need Help Choosing Range / Oven / rangetop combo, etc.

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Hey Folks

As we get closer to submitting plans for our remodel to the city, we're starting to get serious about choosing our appliances. Like most folks, we're on a budget, etc.

I have a few items I'm seeking opinions on. If they are better spread out into separate threads, let me know and I will do so.

Bit of background: both wife and I cook all the time. Not 'high end' cooks, but we cook for groups semi-frequently and for family regularly.

If money were no object, I'd get a 48" range (likely bluestar) w/ 2 ovens. However, I'm kind of enamored with the idea of open burners. So, by my research, that puts us in the $8-9k price for such a unit. The 36" bluestar RCS is more in our price range ($4k). I would be sad, but, really, I'm on a POS frigidaire 30", so anything will be an upgrade.

(1) So, first question, are there other open burner options that offer better value? Or is it "pay the piper" for open burner? Are there other "value" options for folks like us that are really trying to stretch their $? We just had a discussion about making the kitchen with a 48" opening for the range, putting our POS 30" frigidaire in the space until the whole project is finished, then go back and save for what we want. Crazy, I know...

(2) Next question: I have a thing about serving food on warm plates. If we end up with, instead, a range top and wall oven...is a warming drawer the best value option vs. a 2nd oven to serve this purpose?

In the end, we are thinking long and hard about how to spread our money. The remodel involves a lot of parts so we don't know what and where to committ. The current budget / bid for the whole project is $95k (kitchen + enclosing a couple of porches and adding 6' on one side of the house + mild master bath re-do). If that budget went up by, say, 20%, we'd make it, but it would sting big time.

Anyway, I hope the question makes sense. If I am misguided on where I am posting, please let me know and I will re-direct my efforts.

Much thanks.

matt

Comments (8)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Since you are thinking hard about the money aspect, keep in mind the expense of the exhaust for a 48" range. You will need a hood that is 48-54" wide. A Bluestar is very powerful so you will need the proper amount of cfms for that hood. Your ductwork for the hood needs to be sufficient too - an 8" or 10" duct. Your budget then should include the several thousand for such a large hood. The size of the hood means you will be foregoing upper cabinet space (may not be an issue, unless you are storage-constrained).

    I think the 36" Bluestar rangetop + another brand's wall ovens hits your checklist. You don't need to get the built-in griddle; you can get the 6-burner model rangetop, and buy an adjunct portable griddle (which also frees up all 6 burners for when you don't need a griddle). For ovens, the Bosch double wall ovens are popular; they run from $2400 to $6000 depending upon the model.

    A warming drawer is a good idea, but it is essential that it is placed properly. And that means not at the bottom of the wall oven stack. If it is there, so close to the floor, you will rarely use it, guaranteed. The warming drawer needs to be placed directly under the counter, ideally next to the wall ovens. You will enjoy it with that location.

  • 10 years ago

    oh, very, very good point with the hood. That definitely puts it out of our price range. Excellent point.

    Thanks for the guidance on the warming drawer. Sounds like it's not a nutty solution. For kicks, this AM, did some eggs for the Mrs. and just splashed some water on the plates and microwaved for 30 seconds. Not quite the same and splotchy (e.g. water spread). Took the chill off though, so that would work (weird I didn't think of it before).

    thanks again.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree, but not on the warming drawer placement. There are several contenders for that. Some people like it right under or next to the cooktop. Some like it near, or on a quick path from, point of service. Others like it between the cooktop and ovens. And others still like it in the baking area (I guess most of them use it for reheating/crisping breads and crackers). For mostly plate warming, near the plates or the place you'll dish up/serve from both make sense.

    The one thing everybody agrees on is not to put it in a place that's inconvenient or you'll never use it. People tend to stick it under the ovens to be out of the way--and don't use it because it's out of the way. Those who love it in that position put it there because it's truly the only place they have and they want it enough to use it even if it's inconvenient.

    Microwaving the empty damp plates too much, unless they're Corelle or similar, could eventually make them crack. Clever, but not not a long term solution. Warming drawers have many uses, especially keeping food warm (!!). Since your plates are cold enough to want warming for eggs on a Spring morning, I bet you'll like have the serving dishes with the second helpings keeping warm in there during the depth of Winter. Or keeping the plate of eggs warm when the Mrs. says, "Excuse me please, Honey. I'll be back in a minute." :)

    So, regarding your dream range and hood, and always taking into account your spouse's desires as well, the cooking units have the biggest impact on your use and enjoyment of your kitchen. If you want the range you mentioned, I'm guessing it's for the cooking power, rather than the pretty colors. It might be worth scrimping elsewhere to get the range and ventilation, if that's what you really want/need.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I went through a similar decision process (really thought I wanted the 48" Bluestar range), had budgetary concerns and ended up with a different solution. My kitchen is still under construction, so I can't tell you how it feels to use it yet!

    I really wanted the open-burners, definitely needed more than 30"/4 burners, but was not as crazy about the Bluestar ovens. I definitely didn't want the large oven in the 36" range - too big for me. Also, I intend to take the cr-a-a-a-azy risk of actually using the self-clean feature in my new wall ovens -- not having the option in the Bluestar oven bothered me. So my real interest in the 48" Bluestar was for the convenience of 2 ovens (big plus), neither of them over-large, and plenty of space (somewhat more than I need) for cooking. The cost however was prohibitive, especially when adding in the cost of ventilating a 48".

    I ended up buying a 36" 5-open-burner Bluestar cooktop (store display model, so discounted), a Bosch 800 30" convection oven, and a Bosch Benchmark micro-convec speed oven (both open box with minor dents). I'm planning to buy a 36" Kobe range hood (22" Deep, but remember, the burners are in a cooktop, so they will not overshoot the depth of the hood).

    This set of appliances will cost me $5800, and I think the biggest compromise I've made is in getting the cooktop instead of a rangetop -- cleanup of the crumb tray under the open burners will be significantly more difficult. Hopefully, it will not be an everyday occurence!

    I might want to retrofit a warming drawer into one of my below-counter drawer banks at some point - pillog makes it sound so useful! I have to think about whether it's $1,000+ useful, though....

    I'm happy with these choices so far, but wish me luck! I don't expect to be cooking in my new kitchen until mid-June - I'll let you know how it works out.

    *ETA - cost doesn't include the MUA - have yet to finalize $$ for that with contractor.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi


    I really appreciate the responses. We definitely want a range-top/range vs. cooktop. I like how you kept things in a reasonable budget. It has help me formulate another post that I'll make soon re: where to save money on lightly used appliances. thanks again.

  • 10 years ago

    Does anybody have any insight, thoughs, and/or opinions as to what would be better --- a cook top with wall oven or a regular range and oven?


    We are looking at remodeling our kitchen and are debating which of the two to do?

  • 10 years ago

    from what I gather it's not about 'better'. It's more about preference. Some people like the wall ovens, others like ranges.

    we like the idea of a range/oven without electric boards and we like the open burner so we're going bluestar. If we were getting the range-top, we wouldn't be able to afford a bluestar oven, so we'd probably just get the cheapest thing that looked ok, since I hear the electronics don't last long, especially if you do the self-clean.

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH