Software
Houzz Logo Print
subdood_ky_z6b

Opinion on fruit varieties

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Hello, I recently posted a report on the fruit trees that we've planted over the last month or so. I've looked for certain varieties on the Forum and didn't find a lot of opinions on them. Could anyone offer their opinions, good or bad, on these particular fruits?

Novaspy, Winecrisp, King David, Macoun, Cortland, Grimes Golden, Roxbury and Golden Russet apples

Orient and Pineapple pears

Coralstar peach

Since we are in eastern KY, was also wondering what people in this part of the country consider their best growing/tasting apples and peaches.

Thanks

Comments (8)

  • 10 years ago

    Peaches the Indians are very highly rated. Indian freestone and Indian blood cling.


    i literally just ordered mine I don't even have them yet but the reviews are all highly positive.

  • 10 years ago

    Cortland have done well for me - a good dual-purpose variety. They are somewhat scab-susceptible and produce crops annually. Grimes Golden have done OK for me - they ripen mid to late season and are very hard and somewhat tart - I use them for juicing mostly. Roxbury's were not hardy in my climate. Still waiting on Winecrisp, Macoun and Novaspy.

  • 10 years ago

    I haven't grown any of those but Macoun is by far my favorite eating apple. We're lucky to have a bunch of great apple orchards in the area and I always time my visits when Macouns are ready. They have a pleasant sweet tart flavor(more sweet than tart) somewhat similar to McIntosh but bigger and sweeter. My wife who likes subacid apples like Red Delicious and gala also loves macoun. My only complaints are they don't store that well in the fridge and sometimes they're a little soft. Still the best apple I've ever eaten.

    Cortland is also pretty good but tend to be less sweet. They are however resistant to browning when sliced so it's a useful apple to have.

    They're both widely grown here in the northeast, zones 5-6, so they must do OK here at least.


  • 10 years ago

    KIng David rocks! It is a smaller sized apple with very dark red skin and a somewhat tart/wine flavor. Ripens around early October in SE WI. Hard to find from tree suppliers but one of my favorites. If you like the taste of Jonathan, you will like King David. Good for cooking and fresh eating.

  • 10 years ago

    I should have also added that the Macoun apple tree I grafted about 5 years ago has about 10 clusters of flowers this spring. A local orchard grows them and they sell out quickly. Thought I would give them a try.

  • 10 years ago

    sdood,

    After starting out with 60 apple varieties, I've lost or abandoned the vast majority of them. About all that I still care for or bother picking/eating are: MonArk, Centennial crab, Kerr crab, Bastian Orange crab. There's a Stayman Winesap or McIntosh - I don't know the difference in the two and long ago lost my orchard map - that is productive and tasty... but the kids are gone now and the deer get most of them.

  • 10 years ago

    So what your saying is you prefer crabs? Can you explain?

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks all for your inputs. That is encouraging to hear about Macoun and King David varieties, as I've never had one, but they sounded like quality apples. My apple palate isn't as refined as most folks, I guess my favorite over the years has been Gold Delicious. I prefer apples to be firm, tart and have some sweetness to balance that acid.


    We picked a bag of Macs up at the local Kroger, and I thought they were pretty good, with all those attributes. To be honest, other than store bought Macs, I don't know how they'd compare to fresh off the tree. But, I would venture to say a store version is prob a poor to fair representation of what a fresh apple would taste like. I'm sure it's not like that all the time, but I would guess most of the time. I spent almost 30 years in Texas, and you just don't get fresh apples there like you do in more northern areas. Peaches, pecans, yes, apples, not so much. So, I had to rely on store bought.


    Three of my selections are Mac offspring, so I think those ought to be good apples for us. Especially the Macoun, I've heard and read many good reviews of it. A lot of my tree selections, to be honest, were based on what other folks had written about them. A lot of my decisions were based on the orangepippintrees website, and their descriptions, and I wanted trees that had average to good disease resistance. Grimes are popular in these parts, so I got a couple of those, since it's also a Golden Del parent.


    But, our trees are still just whips with some leaves and a few small branches, so we'll have to wait at least a couple of years before we can sample any of them. All of them are about 50% of standard or smaller, so I'd think we ought to get some fruit in at least three years. So, until then, we'll have to settle for some local orchards to provide us with what we want. There is an orchard within an hour of us over near Paris, KY, called Reed Valley, that is growing 8 of the same apple varieties we are, and both peach varieties we have. So, I'm excited to check them out later this year. Plus, there's tons of orchards up in Ohio that I'd like to visit as well.


    Right now, my biggest concern is keeping the varmits, mostly deer, off my saplings. I have them all protected with circular fencing, so that should keep them at bay for now, but I'm going to have to beef that up when the trees start growing up over their protection. At least this will keep them off the lower parts, and since the fencing has 2*4 inch spacing, it ought to keep out the rabbits.


    But, our next chore is to get our 70 tomato and 20 pepper plants in the ground soon. It's been so cold and rainy this month, it's put that part of our gardening way behind schedule. We've already got corn and potatoes growing, though.