Software
Houzz Logo Print
hitenjrawal

Andersen Windows in new home

10 years ago

My builder has included Andersen 200 series windows in my new construction. But someone we know has recommended that we should go for the 400 series with simulated divided light (SDL) with grill applied.


Any ideas or thoughts whether I should just go with the standard or pay extra for the 400 series as per above? I would have thought that the 200 series would be adequate from an energy efficient perspective and that they will look good?

Comments (16)

  • 10 years ago

    If you go to the window forum they will tell you to go with a high quality vinyl window over the Anderson 200. If you want the wood look instead of vinyl then upgrade to the 400.

    hitenjrawal thanked midwest gal
  • 10 years ago

    I say upgrade. I've studied windows as I walk my dog around the neighborhood, and while I don't actually know which ones cost more, I can tell that nicer windows really make a difference in the overall look of a house. I definitely prefer divided light windows.

    As I say this, keep in mind that I'm one of the more financially conservative posters here. I'm usually the one saying, Do you really need all that space? Do you really want to pay for double this or extra that? Yet I think windows are a place to splurge.

    hitenjrawal thanked mrspete
  • 10 years ago

    This is one of those items where you get the very best that you can afford. They will be more energy efficient, look nicer and last longer. I would sacrifice something else for a better window.

    hitenjrawal thanked homechef59
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Not enough information. Andersen makes different kinds of windows even within the 200 and 400 series designations. Are the windows casements or double hungs? If double hungs, are the 400's tilt wash or woodwright?

    The primary deficiency of the 200's is the inexplicably flat sill design. I don't believe SDL mullions are available and the sash is epoxy paint instead of vinyl cladding. It's a builder grade window and looks like it. It is very attractively priced to the builder.

    If you haven't looked at these windows you need to do that.

    hitenjrawal thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    The 200 series the builder has included are double hung SDL with grids and inside with screens.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Is it SDL with removable grilles on the inside? Would the upgrade be for 400 tilt-wash or woodwright?

    Ask the builder if the sash has a cladding or is epoxy painted and see what he says. Here's a clue: only the 400 Woodwright has a PVC & wood fiber composite cladding.

    hitenjrawal thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Yes grilles on inside. Upgrade would be to either 400 tilt-wash or 400 Woodwright. I think Woodwright costs more. Essentially I'll be deciding between 200 tilt-wash and 400 tilt-wash.


  • 10 years ago

    I've made the decision to go with Marvin Integrity wood ultrex if I can fit it into my budget. If I can't I just don't know what to do because all other reviews are so incredibly mixed.

  • 10 years ago

    The most important difference between the 400 tilt wash and the Woodwright is the sash of the former is painted and the latter is a composite cladding. The frames are the same

    Why use interior snap in grilles? I've never been in a house with these things where one of them wasn't missing. To save money only put full SDL mullions in the upper sash. Also use fewer but wider windows and don't mull paired windows.

    Rather than guessing about costs, get written proposals for all 3 windows as well as Marvin wood-ultras. Make the suppliers work for your money.

    The 400 Tilt Wash is far superior to the 200. I would eliminate the 200 just for the 3rd rate sill design. Go look at them; its difficult to believe they are made by the same company.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Just a quick point I'd like to make.

    A friend has large Andersen casement windows in her house. She did not build this house. No problem with the windows. But, they had problems with the vinyl wrapped extension jambs bubbling. Andersen provided all new extension jambs (painted wood) and the homeowner paid for labor to replace them.

    are any of the Windows you are looking at vinyl wrapped? I would stay away from them I think, based on my friend's experience.

    (edited)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Why would an interior extension jamb be vinyl wrapped? I suspect you might mean an epoxy coating which Andersen sometimes pretends is a cladding. In general, extensions jambs are painted when the trim is painted.

    Here are the details of these windows in question. You can discover much of what you need to know by comparing them carefully.

    400 Woodwright

    400 Tilt Wash

    200 Tilt Wash


    200 Tilt Wash sill detail

    The 400 Woodwright has a very handsome sash fully clad with a smooth composite material called Fibrex (a very tough material made of wood fibers and PVC). The depth of the sash frame allows a full height mullion like you would expect on a traditional wood window. The sash of the 200 and 400 Tilt Wash is not clad; its wood with an epoxy coating that Andersen sometimes calls a cladding. The frame is almost flush with the glass so the mullions are not very high and are not convincing. You need to see the actual unit to determine if you like the mullions. Some of these details are old so don't rely on them; go see a window sample!

    Both the 400 Woodwright and Tilt Wash have the same composite (Fibrex) steeply sloping sill (with a notch below it to prevent water from getting behind the siding). IMO this is the best sill design in the business. The upper parts of the frame of both of the 400 windows are vinyl wrapped.

    One of my pet peeves is the way the Andersen 200 (and other similar builder-grade windows from other manufacturers) has a virtually flat sill so if the screen weeps get clogged or the wind force is great, water will rise until it overflows the interior dam since the seal under the window will not stop water in a storm.

    And if the screen weeps do not clog, water will roll over the nosing of the sill and run back horizontally to the top course of siding where it only has to penetrate a line of caulk at best (its difficult to apply and not very effective) and this caul is often applied poorly or not at all. Andersen even shows caulk at the top point of tapered clapboard siding in the above sill detail and even includes a tiny little round backer rod in a parody of a proper caulking detail. Caulk should never be relied upon to stop water from getting behind siding at a horizontal joint. Windows have had slopping sills with drips and notches for siding for hundreds of years. Why would Andersen use that design for the 400 series and not the 200?

    The Woodwright is a great window. I specify it when a client doesn't want to spend the money for the Marvin Ultimate series. If you cannot afford the Woodwright and can live with the lesser sash design of the 400 tilt-Wash, I recommend it. I cannot recommend the 200 Tilt-Wash nor would I specify it for any house for which I was responsible.

  • 10 years ago

    JDS...I could be wrong about the jambs being vinyl wrapped.

    this is what her extension jambs looked like.

  • 10 years ago

    I don't think Andersen sells pre-finished extension jambs but I could be wrong. I know they can be bought unfinished which would be preferable IMO.

  • 10 years ago

    Given a choice between Andersen 200 and Pella 450 for the exact same price which would you suggest?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    That's a tough choice. Most people use PVC in that quality class.

    I have avoided Pella because of their habit of delivering the wrong windows and refusing to take responsibility for their errors and their archaic cladding system but if you can tolerate the cheesy white PVC jamb liners and the sloppy corner overlaps of the thin aluminum "roll-form" cladding, I guess the Pella 450 is slightly better.

    But this window MUST have a sub-sill added under the window instead of flat trim. Extend the sub-sill to the outside edges of the jamb trim for a first rate traditional appearance. Pella uses goofy folding fins (cheaper to package) so be sure to lap flexible self-adhering flashing tape over the joint where the fins meet the frame especially at the upper corners in order to avoid costly leaks.

    Make sure two knowledgable people check and sign the final window order and that one of them immediately inspects the delivery for conformance to the contract. Mistakes can cause long delays.