Software
Houzz Logo Print
carolyn72465

Soil Test result-Vegetable Garden-High Iron

10 years ago

I had a soil test done through work recently and the agronomist emailed me that he'd bring the detailed results next week. I asked if he could tell me if my soil was deficient in anything so I could try to amend before planting next we/end.

He said everything looks well-balanced except iron was on the high side. Can you recommend anything for me to do/add to the soil before planting or should I just plant & top-dress with fertilizer around my veggies?

I'm itching to plant but after last years failures, I want to be cautious too.

Comments (18)

  • 10 years ago

    I'm going to guess that it is hard to make recommendations without knowing a lot of other things like pH, soil type, organic matter content, and how high the iron actually is. It sounds like he didn't say it was 'excessive' to the point it would interfere with plant growth.

    Any idea how it got high? i.e. any iron or mineral supplements added? It could very well be natural or done by others before you.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi toxcrusadr,

    Here's some background.

    Last summer, tomato & pepper plants were stunted and didn't put out much growth or fruit. Year before(first year with raised beds) was successful. Great growth, good fruit production.

    In the fall of the first year, I added leaf mold to beds-most had broken down, some had not. I also added composted cattle manure. Leaves were Locust, Oak & Maple leaves mainly. Worked it in in spring before planting. Removed some leaf clumps that hadn't broken down. Planted late May/early June-terrible results. Got soil test done in early fall but wasn't happy with results for many reasons-couldn't get a detailed report, company put me off for weeks, I waited & waited into fall to get results. The company that sent the soil off for testing went under, etc. Nightmare.

    In fall I planted clover cover crop & also added composted crabapples from tree in yard. Have not tilled it in yet. This spring took soil sample from the deadest looking area of my 3 plots and gave it to agronomist at my company to have evaluated. I suspected something was wrong with the soil since I couldn't see any weeds growing in most of the beds. That's the soil I dug up for the sample.

    He will be in my area next week & will bring my results then. All he said was elevated levels of iron, everything else good. I don't know much about what excessive iron(I don't know # yet) does to plants. Ideas?

  • 10 years ago

    If he said that everything else is fine, I'm assuming that your pH can't be too out of whack. If the pH of the soil is higher than 5.5 or so, odds are that iron won't be available enough to cause any issues, even if it is a bit on the high side.

  • 10 years ago

    Any chance you have pictures of lasts year's stunted tomatoes & peppers?

    If not, can you describe more specifically than "stunted." That is, how were they stunted? Just small overall? Or tightly curled leaves? Or what?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    <I had a soil test done through work recently and the agronomist emailed me that he'd bring the detailed results next week.> You don't mention where you work but if I had access to an agronomist I would be inclined to follow their advice but only after you share with them the history you mention above. After all you say the agronomist has the complete result of the soil sample.

    I also wonder why if last year was such a terrible year why you didn't take a soil sample then and begin to amend the soil last fall? Also sounds as if you should have sampled in more than one spot?

  • 10 years ago

    Where in the world are you? Zone 6b does not tell anyone much worthwhile except which plants might survive a normal winter in your area.

    If the soil needs amending you want to do that before planting, several weeks before planting especially if amending with organic matter so the Soil Food Web has some time to start working on that.

    Excessive levels of Iron, a micronutrient, might interfere with a plant ability to properly utilize Phosphorus which could adversely affect to grow and produce the fruit we use. However, much also depends on soil pH and the balance of the other nutrients.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    Jean, no pics of last years plants. Stunted, as in, peppers were 4 inches tall when put in & remained 4 inches tall through the summer. Tomatoes got to 1-2 ft. tall but were single-stemmed & spindly. Leaves started turning yellow early on and plants just looked unhealthy, in general.

    My tomatoes usually grow to well over 6 ft. tall. Tomatoes planted in containers close by performed well and had good fruit production.

    gumby_ct,

    In my post I indicated that I did get a soil test in late summer but only got results in mid-fall due to complications with the company that sent the soil off for testing. Sample lost, company went under-vague results.

    Okay, I think my second post went missing-it was the one with all the detailed background info :(

    Anyway, while waiting for soil-test results, I added composted manure,composted crabapples to these beds and planted a clover cover crop. Some of the clover took but most was killed off in the first hard frost. Soil in beds originally was a combination of top soil, triple mix & manure.

    The beds currently look mostly weed free with some clover that needs to be tilled under. I took samples from deadest looking areas of the 3 beds.

    Importantly, what I was most concerned about was the addition of leaf mold to the soil, added in the fall after the first summer with the raised beds. I added mostly composted leaf mold but there were some clumps of leaves that hadn't broken down. Leaves are locust, oak & maple.

    Last spring, before the bad summer, I tilled the soil and removed large clumps of leaves that hadn't broken down and roots that were also in the leaf mold. Added more manure and a month later planted the toms & peppers.

    I'm wondering if the leaf mold created poor growing conditions for my crops and is responsible for elevated iron.

    Oh, and I'm in Niagara Falls, Ontario, Canada, kimmq.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh so my second post didn't disappear. I didn't see it initially. Weird?

    gumby_ct, you must've not read yet that I did do a soil test.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Be sure to tell your agronomist this <Added more manure and a month later planted the toms & peppers.> I wonder if this manure along with the other things you added were tying up the N while trying to decompose things in the soil?

    I guess what I was wondering is why you were waiting until now to amend the soil again? But if it all has to do with problems with soil testing Co., so be it.

    I just think if you rush again this year you will continue to have trouble.

  • 10 years ago

    Several possibilities.

    How was that manure composted and for how long? Was it clearly 'compost' or could you still see that it was manure and maybe bedding? What I'm getting at is, if there was a lot of incompletely composted wood shavings or sawdust, it could have tied up N.

    Same goes for the leaves, although I kinda doubt that if they were already partially broken down when you put them on in the fall and you only tilled them in the following spring. But if there were clumps of leaves, maybe it could be that.

    The manure could have raised the pH if it was from someone who used lime for odor control in a barn. If he said 'everything looks well balanced', if that was a problem last year it has righted itself by now.

    Finally there is the possibility of persistent herbicides in the manure that were used on pasture or hay. Those can mess you up for up to two years.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi all. The manure was the bagged composted stuff that has very little manure smell-picked up from HD or somesuch place. Cattle manure.

    Leaf mold was well-broken down for the most part. My neighbor creates a mulch and leaf mold pile for me & others to use. He finely chops up the leaves and the pile is usually nice & broken down by the time I get to it in the fall. The ones that didn't break down were located closer to the top after he rotated the pile. I added them in the fall but when they didn't break down over winter I removed them in spring.

    Can't wait to see my soil report next week. I will dig over my soil & remains of that cover crop. I haven't added anything this spring & won't add anything before I plant.

    I will fertilize around my plants, however, with formula based on recommendations from agronomist. Thanks for your help.

  • 10 years ago

    Keep in mind they only test for certain things in the soil. Meaning IF they didn't test for herbicides or other toxic materials the test won't reveal any problems.

    So be sure to ask exactly what they did test for - he may advise another or diff test.

  • 10 years ago

    Be sure to ask your agronomist if it was possible this excess came from anything used in the garden such as mulches, or other things added. Write yourself out a list so you don't forget when you see him.

    Good Luck

  • 10 years ago

    Talked to the agronomist briefly today & asked him about my results. He said my PH for the sample was 7.4 but iron was listed as 82parts per million which is high.

    He thought the bagged manure & top soil I've added over the years could be responsible for high iron. He said not to do anything with the soil except plant next we/end and then later add a slow release 180 day Duration which is Urea, shaken onto the soil.

    I work for a fertilizer manufacturer so have access to all this but am not certain of his advice since he's rather cavalier about inorganic fertilizer & pesticides :)

  • 10 years ago

    He's suggesting not to mess with anything except to add some N. Urea is, what, 46-0-0 or something.

    The pH is a tad high, 6.5-7 would be nicer, but it's not too far out and if you have good organic matter it mitigates that somewhat.

    After checking a couple other threads on high iron levels, it sounds like yours is not that astronomical. I wouldn't worry about it. There is a type of fertilizer, Ironite, which is 10-0-0 so it provides N but has a lot of iron in it. Don't use that.

  • 10 years ago

    Hey thanks! I'm gonna plant next we/end & just see how it goes through summer. I have noticed a few more weeds so that's gotta be good. It's not dead after all. I should point out that in one of these plots. I have garlic growing &it looks healthy so I'm not terribly worried. I'll add some slow release Urea later on in the season. Hopefully this summer's crops won't be a bust!

  • 10 years ago

    I'm no soil expert but wonder if blood meal wouldn't be a better choice?

  • 10 years ago

    If you are going to use Urea I would put it down before you plant to avoid burning your plants. Ideally you would work it into the soil a few inches deep. You mentioned a 180 day Urea which I have not seen before although since you work for a fertilizer company I'm assuming it is a coated time release product to which you have access.

    A few other alternatives would be feather meal, soy bean meal, alfalfa meal or as mentioned above, blood meal. The first 3 are slower and longer acting than most synthetic fertilizers. They are actually animal feed products and will be sold as such at a feed store. I just bought a bag of soy bean meal for $12/50lb bag this week.

Sponsored
River Mill Construction
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Delaware County's Customer Focused General Contractor