Software
Houzz Logo Print
octoberdana

Tile or Granite Fireplace Surround (Update)

10 years ago

A few weeks ago I posted about whether to do a granite, tile, or stone fireplace surround. The overwhelming answer was stone, and I was all prepared to do that. When I got to my design center appointment I was told that my builder requires that the stone on the exterior and the interior be exactly the same. Sadly, the stone I chose for my exterior will not work with my interior choices and I wasn't wanting to change them. So this leaves me with a choice of tile, granite, or brick. Since my brick would have to be white and my trim is white I eliminated this choice. The granite's are pretty busy other then absolute black. My kitchen island will be directly behind the couch, and it will have Azul Platino granite, so my selection can't look like it is trying to match. We have 5 base tiles to choose from, none of which are super amazing. I narrowed it down to these 3 choices and I have a picture of them with my flooring. My cabinets are an off-white, and my kitchen/great room floors are the same walnut.

Which would look best?

This choice is a base tile, shown with the white mantle and the walnut floor selection.
This choice is also a base tile....
This is the black granite.

My concern with the base tiles is that they will pull too yellow. My concern with the granite is that it will pull the room cold feeling.

Comments (26)

  • 10 years ago

    I am not sure if I am following correctly, but for what it's worth, I think I like the granite (like at the bottom of your last photo)- I know it's on the dark side but I think it has more life, more warmth, interest than the others. I have something similar for my kitchen counters so maybe I am biased. I googled your counter tops and while it would seem black white or gray would complement, I think for interest sake I would opt for the varied granite choice I should have really prefaced this by saying I am far from a decorating expert- so you should wait for the rest of the crew to weigh in.:)

  • 10 years ago

    I only have three granite choices: absolute black, wheatfield, or tan brown. I can do black slate (which I didn't like) or a beige marble which did not look good with my flooring. Builder gives you very few choices, unfortunately.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I love the absolute black. It coordinates with your island and will go with any color or decorating style you choose to decorate either room with, either now or in the future. A simple and elegant statement. :)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I would go with black slate - it looks great and you will never have any worries about it. Mine was put in 31 years ago and looks like new.

  • 10 years ago

    Some examples with varied decor.


  • 10 years ago

  • 10 years ago

    What is the advantage of using slate over granite?

  • 10 years ago

    I like the black also, but really like black slate. My neighbor has black slate and it looks gorgeous. Why would you have to do white brick? Many, many fireplaces have white trim and red brick surrounds. It can also be nice. I don't care for the tile at all.

  • 10 years ago

    The builder requires that the stone or brick used for the exterior of the house be used on the interior. My outside brick is Windsor White, so that would have to be my interior brick. It just doesn't work with my interior selections.

    Is slate or granite more transitional? My house is a good blend of modern and traditional finishings.

  • 10 years ago

    My vote is for the black.

  • 10 years ago

    Black.

  • 10 years ago

    Black granite or black slate?

  • 10 years ago

    Or you could always go black marble.

  • 10 years ago

    Black marble not a choice, only beige marble. Black slate, beige marble, black, green, wheat field, or tan brown granite are my choices.

  • 10 years ago

    Black slate = timeless

  • 10 years ago

    Black slate.

    I'm sorry you can't pick your own stone. Did the builder give a reason? I mean, other than "I just don't do that".

  • 10 years ago

    Black slate is my first choice, followed by black granite.

  • 10 years ago

    Never imagined I would vote for black slate-but in this case, I am. Second choice-black granite. I think slate will give warmer appearance than the granite..

  • 10 years ago

    My builder is a tract builder and limits choices. It's frustrating because it is not an entry level house but trying to work around it.

  • 10 years ago

    If the granite is shiny, I would do the slate for sure.

  • 10 years ago

    It is absolute black granite so it has the typical granite finish.

  • 10 years ago

    Any chance you can just get a credit for now and put the tile on after you move in? Tiling is not that difficult to do.

  • 10 years ago

    No all finishings must be in place per building codes in our state. The loan can't close without them.

  • 10 years ago

    I don't want to hijack this thread, but thinking about black slate for my own fireplace surround sometime in the future. Is it typically templated and fabricated like a countertop, or is it large format tile with minimal grout lines? Lots of photos I see of beautiful slate surrounds have two upright pieces and then a horizontal piece at the top across the entire width.

  • 10 years ago

    I love the absolute black also. I have it on my kitchen island. For the fireplace surround it is terrific. It immediately grabs your attention as you enter the room and pulls your eye to the focal place "fireplace", exactly where you want the attention to go.