Software
Houzz Logo Print
canadianplant

Need "tropicana" information

10 years ago

I have found a hybrid tea that i like, but I am in zone 3/4. "The hunter", which is rated zone 4 has survived 7 years here, with some dieback but nothing that it couldnt recover from. The site I wish to order this from seems to rate its hardiness to zone 4, but "needs protection" in winter. I have found very conflicting information as to how hardy it is (which seems to be the same for most hybrid teas) ranging from zone 4 to zone 7.
Does anyone have any experience growing tropicana in a colder zone? How hardy have you found it? Maybe some suggestions of similar roses to try? I have "the hunter", blanc double de coubert, persian yellow (All 3 are hardy here), and this year I have planted a campfire, antique 89 and John cabot.

Comments (17)

  • 10 years ago

    Had to ask since I am confused - what has your post got to do with Tropicana?

    Jackie

  • 10 years ago

    In the post this question is present: Does anyone have any experience growing tropicana in a colder zone?

    Basically the OP explained that roses not rated to be hardy for them have in fact been quite hardy and wants to know if Tropicana will grow well in their zone 3/4 climate.

  • 10 years ago

    If you are going to take such a chance better find Tropicana own root. Now being an older hybrid tea I don't know if it is a good grower on its own roots but when it comes to freezing and being frozen for long periods at extremely low temperatures, own roots have been shown to fare better than grafted plants in every condition. While grafts planted deep (like 6 inches) will survive most climates, grafts are still quite susceptible to winter damage and death. An own root plant with damage only needs a tiny live root to start making a comeback. Something to keep in mind.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh I should be more clearer then. Tropicana is a rose that is rated "zone 7" and warmer (hmf site) and my zone is 5 by american rating and 6 by canadian. My point is that it survive with no problem in my garden. However, the original poster live in a much, much colder zone (3/4).

    I agree with richard that if you can find an own root plant, the chance of surviving is higher but at least in my area, I rarely come across roses grown on its own roots. That may be different in your area as it is much colder.

  • 10 years ago

    I don't see own root roses locally either, it would have to be sourced most likely from an online nursery

  • 10 years ago

    Hi. I grow it here in MN Zone 4 borderline zone 3. Mine are grafted and I have heavy alkaline clay. They have survived 4 or 5 years but have not thrived. Mine are not heavy bloomers as they suffer substantial winter dieback but are in an open, unprotected location. I would recommend growing three in a grouping to have a fuller bush with potential for more blooms.

  • 10 years ago

    The only way to really know if a rose is hardy in your yard is to grow it. I've had roses that wintered fine in my yard and died in my cousin's yard just a block away from me and vice versa. Location is the entire key and even in your own yard you will have different "zones". If you really want the rose buy it and plant it in the best place possible and give it what ever protection you can and see what happens.

  • 10 years ago

    Having attempted to grow Tropicana own-root in a cold climate, I wouldn't recommend it. As a budded rose, it is hardier than the average floribunda, and came through some winters with temperatures in the -20's F fine. How it would do at colder temperatures I don't know. If you can grow Persian Yellow, there are other hardy roses in the yellow/orange color range that would do better than Tropicana. They take one look at my humidity and run, so they aren't things I have personal experience with.

  • 10 years ago

    You can always try growing it & winter protecting it. It is a beautiful bright colour. I'm in zone 5a, Canada & have it. But if you are not a gambler. The closest hardy roses I could suggest in the orange/peach/yellow are olds college centennial rose or Morden sunrise. They are rated zone 3.

  • 10 years ago

    I grow Tropicana and I winter protect it. I love the colors.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks everyone

    I usually try the " plant and see" approach with roses, and have killed "hardy" roses like Adeleide hoodless, ramblin' red and a few other explorer roses. I managed to have "olympiad" survive but it was one of the first things ive planted and it got swamped by plants. I also had "peace" survive a season here.

    Needless to say, I have odd luck with roses and was wondering what peoples experiences were in colder areas, since the hardiness data is so inconsistent.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Winter hardiness depends a lot on snow cover and control of fungal diseases. Snow is easily the best way to protect roses from the cold, but it is unreliable in Connecticut. A plant that has healthy green leaves all season long has a much better chance of surviving winter than one that defoliates due to black spot. One can get lucky and not have BS all season if the weather stays sufficiently dry.

  • 10 years ago

    We do get quite reliable snow pack, 2-4 feet on average. This has enabled me to grow some borderline plants like bamboo. I have never been able to protect roses quite as well.


  • 10 years ago

    I just wanted to say that I overwintered a newly planted St. Patrick's rose last year. I had not winter protected it. We had one of the most unusual winters here in terms of snow, melts, ice & thaws. It would snow for a week then completely warm up, then freeze. It was like that for 2 weeks. I thought I was going to lose more than just one rose. Everything was fine. The rose had complete dieback, but is now 3.5 feet high, 5 canes & has about 15 beautiful blooms right now! It's only it's second summer. So totally worth a try in my opinion!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    St. Patrick normally won't survive a winter in Red Sox territory around Boston, but I grow it between two black asphalt driveways. I cover mine with burlap and shovel snow over it during winter.

  • 10 years ago

    I find winter condition is not a big problem but rather spring freeze. This year everything survived and put out new canes and buds but after a sudden freeze and freezing rain for a couple days, that killed everything. I had Lichtkoningin Lucia which had survived the winter but died after the freezing rain storm. It didn't recover when the tender new growth died. Tender or young plants are of course much more vulnerable.