Go with what you like.

I voted for the green! It does not matter what colors you have in the interior since this is the exterior of the front door. I had mine painted Fire Cracker red and the entryway and living room colors are gray, cream, black, and burgundy. I did paint the interior of the front door black.

Can you show a full front pic of the home? The one pic of each color swatch is not giving enough information to the whole outside scheme. I'm seeing Gray vinyl with Dark Blue Shutters. Are the shutters going to be painted?

Here is a full pic of the home, though our lighting fixture will be changing to a brushed nickel pendant (under arch) and the new walkway and landscaping is still to come. We are trying to get away with not changing the shutter color to save a little money, but we will see...Thanks to all who have voted and commented. I am so undecided and it is very helpful to hear other perspectives!

After seeing the full picture of the front exterior of your home, I think the green would provide more of a POP of color.