Software
Houzz Logo Print
acarsme

Soil advice needed for project....

10 years ago

My house sits close to the edge of a fairly steep hill. This spring I built a retaining wall at the edge of the "flat" area of ground just before the hill starts to drop off sharply. This area between the house and wall still has a pitch down to it, and my goal is to raise the soil level up higher and trying to make the area more flat. I intend to lay paver stone in this area too and plant a bunch of dwarf mondo grass.

Our soil is clay, and we live in northern Mississippi. I've bought bags of topsoil at Lowes before, and it doesn't even appear to be dirt to me......it almost seems more like finely ground mulch. It's very light and airy. I'm looking for the kind of soil that will compact to make a firm base for walking on, but yet also support plants. I take it nothing I can buy in bags at the big box stores will work? Should I be looking at a garden center that sells soil in bulk? I talked to one recently and they sell different kinds of mixes, but they also sell "fill dirt" too. He suggested I could mix 50/50 fill dirt with the better soil if I wanted something that would compact well, but also have some nutrients in it to support plantings.

What is my best option here? It's not a very big area I have to do, so if I could do it with just something readily available at Lowes or Home Depot I'd prefer that, but if I need to go the bulk route to get what I desire, then I will. Thanks.

Comments (8)

  • 10 years ago

    What you should get will depend on the depth that area needs to be filled. There is no good reason to fill in an area with good soil much below 6 to 8 inches from the surface, but you do want something there that will not compact and prevent good drainage. For the top 6 to 8 inches you would want good soil and that would be a soil mix of about 45 percent sand , 25 percent silt, 25 percent clay and 5 percent organic matter and that is seldom what is sold as "topsoil".

    "Topsoil" is defined as the top 6 to 12 inches of soil form someplace, but that is not always what is sold as "topsoil". Perhaps this may be of some help.


    http://msue.anr.msu.edu/news/the_shocking_truth_about_topsoil

    To determine about how much soil is needed you multiply the length , in feet, by the width, in feet, to get the area and them multiply that by the depth, in feet, to get the volume in cubic feet. To convert cubic feet to cubic yards divide the cubic feet by 29. If what you need is less than about 5 cubic yards buying from a bilk yard may not be cost effective.

    kimmq is kimmsr


  • 10 years ago

    Why 29? May be 27?

  • 10 years ago

    well in the one spot that I'm trying to level I only need it to raise about 3-4 inches to make the area level like I want. I have another area in my front yard that's rutting away beside a tree. The rut is about 7 inches deep. I want to fill that too with something that will be stiff enough to walk on, but also be good for planting. There is this landscape place near me that sells dirt.....here is some descriptions of what they sell. Would these work for my application?


    ProMix "Whether you are planting trees, shrubs, flowers or grass you will want to start with ProMix. Different people call different things ProMix. Ours is leaf compost, sandy loam from the river bottom, screened dirt and pine material all ground up together at a perfect neutral ph of 7.0. This does not have to be tilled into the soil but certainly can be. "

    Screened Fill Dirt "Local dirt that is excellent soil for leveling yards, seeding or sodding new lawns, filling holes and back filling walls. Clean dirt is relatively free of large clumps and roots, however, an occasional one can be found. "

    And since the screened fill dirt says it's local I'm assuming it's clay since that's what we have mostly down here. Would a 50/50 mix of this promix along with the fill dirt be a good combo for my application maybe? Or just even using straight up ProMix?

  • 10 years ago

    Oops, that should be 27, not 29. I must have hit the wrong key and not noticed.

    The "screened fill does not sound like it is screened very well if an "occasional root or clump" might be found. If the soil around you is clay this will most likely also be clay. To determine if that is something you might want you need to look at it, closely.

    The description of the "ProMix" tells you nothing either. What proportion of each is there? What river is the sand from? River bottom soil around here is polluted with nitrates and phosphorus as well as motor oil from storm runoff from the roads. Sandy loam from the river bottom and dirt are really one and the same thing. Again, do not rely on the sellers description but take a good look at this stuff

    Take a handful of the soil and look at it, feel it, smell it. Sandy soils will feel gritty while clay soils will feel greasy, kind of like talcum powder feels when you rub it between your fingers.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    Nitrates and phosphorus are not pollutants in the garden, they are nutrients. I would be delighted to have them. As for other pollutants, whether they are at any kind of level that would be significant is very site-specific. All river sediment is not contaminated. In most places the amount of pollutants from urban runoff is small compared to the volume of water and sediment. Usually urban runoff is more of a water quality issue than a sediment problem. In some places sediment becomes polluted with persistent chemicals. All depends on the location. I would not turn down river bottom soil by assuming it's contaminated.

    The ProMix sounds like it will do what you need better than fill dirt. This kind of thing is available almost anywhere - obviously it will vary some but it's soil amended with compost/organic matter intended for growing. It's going to be 1.5 to 2x as expensive so it depends on how much you need and your tolerance for the cost. I would spring for this if you can afford it.

  • 10 years ago

    I would recommend building up the area with the builders sand, tamped hard, then dig out between the pavers and fill it with a mix of local dirt and compost for planting. If a paver settles, lift it out and add more sand to level it, plop it back down. That will give you some drainage under the pavers.

    None of the stuff sold for amending planting soil is suitable for installing pavers unless you want to have a lot of settling.

  • 10 years ago

    A couple years ago I bought a yard of 'garden mix' type of soil. A local company is excavating clayey silt from creek bottom land where it's been deposited many feet thick. It's a bit better than the clay most of us have in our yards around here. They mix in some composted manure. As far as organic matter it was marginally better than unamended stuff - in other words I had to add compost when I put it down and more in the subsequent years. So be prepared for that, if you want a nice rich soil. Some dealers will have more of a deluxe mix with a lot more compost in it but the price reflects it. The most important thing is to INSPECT what you are thinking of buying. Go look at it, see the color, texture and particle size.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio